Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: GREEN DAY'S AMERICAN IDIOT at The Noel S. Ruiz Theatre

Review: GREEN DAY'S AMERICAN IDIOT at The Noel S. Ruiz Theatre

When Green Day's American Idiot arrived on Broadway in 2010, it received a mixed response. When I saw the original Broadway production, I thought the cast was glorious and found the Book, like everyone else, safe; an emotional roller coaster. Furthermore, you have the rocking score of Green Day's Grammy-winning album the musical is based on. Overall, it was an enjoyable experience seeing it on the Great White Way, and I am delighted Oakdale's Noel S. Ruiz Theatre at CM Performing Arts Center (CMPAC) has added it to their current season.

The superb Ashley Nicastro directed production, running through March 14th at the adorable Long Island venue, boasts a beautiful and energetic cast.

Johnny, John Gallagher, Jr.'s role from the Broadway cast, is powerfully portrayed by Andrew Murano. We watch Johnny roam the city and meet a woman we only know as Whatshername, portrayed by Jess Ader-Ferretti, who joins him on his journey. We also meet, with a stellar and fierce performance by Michael Visconti, St. Jimmy, who is Johnny's enabler. Johnny's friend, Tunny, Stark Sands' role from the Broadway cast, is excellently portrayed by Matthew Paredi. Tunny joins the military and meets Extraordinary Girl portrayed by CMPAC super-talent Samantha Rosario. Not happy with living in suburbia in a post 9/11 world, they flee looking for a more meaningful life. Their friend Will, Michael Esper's role from the Broadway production portrayed by David DiMarzo, decides to stay as his girlfriend, Heather, portrayed by Marly Mensher, has revealed she is pregnant. We find Will become withdrawn descending into a drugs and alcohol induced depression.

Everyone in the cast is top-notch wonderfully executing the music filled with some of Green Day's biggest hits. Most are, of course, from the 2004 album, but with some additional classics mixed in, too. It is a treat to see the young actors in a musical style they are thoroughly familiar with and can fully deliver on the intent of the music and message.

Also a highlight is the fantastic set done by Patrick Grossman, who also serves as CMPAC's Artistic Director. A bi-level, stationary design, with additional rolling pieces, make for seamless scene changes highlighted by Alison Weinberger's atmospheric lighting. It is a visually stunning production. The live orchestra, of whom sits on stage with the cast, is also brilliant headed up by Musical Director Christopher Russo.

And so, Green Day's American Idiot is indeed another hit for Long Island's Noel S. Ruiz Theatre at CM Performing Arts Center. Forget any negative things you may have heard about this show and enjoy the superb cast and music. The cast even invites you to sing along with them for a rendition of the classic "Good Riddance (Time Of Your Life)" as the Broadway cast did. All in all, this is a thrilling and emotional night of theatre.


Green Day's American Idiot is presented by the Noel S. Ruiz Theatre of Oakdale, Long Island, through March 14th. For more information and to purchase tickets, please call 631-218-2810 or visit

Music by Green Day, Lyrics by Billie Joe Armstrong, Book by Billie Joe Armstrong & Michael Mayer, Directed & Choreographed by Ashley Nicastro, Music Direction by Christopher Russo, Stage Management by Karen Tese, Dance Captain is Evan Torres, Set Design by Patrick Grossman, Costume & Wig Design by Ronald Green III, Sound Design by Viper Studios, Lighting Design by Alison Weinberger, Projections by John Mazzarella

Starring Andrew Murano, Matthew Paredi, David DiMarzo, Michael Visconti, Jess Alder-Ferretti, Marly Mensher, and Samantha Rosario with Courtney Braun, Kara Burke, Tommy Castelli, Vinny Donnadio, Dan George, Hans Paul Hendrickson, Cas Holliday, Briggs Houston, Steffy Jolin, Christian W. Kalinowski, Danielle Pafundi, David Reyes, Evan Torres, Jordan Yates, and Adriana M. Scheer

Photo by Justan Garcia

From This Author - Melissa Giordano

Melissa has been covering theatre for BroadwayWorld for the past eight years and has loved every second of it. She is consistently inspired by the talent of the artists of her beloved Long Island and... (read more about this author)

Review: ON YOUR FEET! at The John W. Engeman Theater
July 21, 2022

What did our critic think of ON YOUR FEET at The John W. Engeman Theatre?

July 15, 2022

What did our critic think of SOMETHING ROTTEN at Bayway Arts Center? With all the heaviness in the world nowadays, one thing to remember is that's it's OK to shut off the brain for an evening to indulge in true laugh-out-loud entertainment. Indeed, Studio Theatre's showing of Something Rotten, a Long Island premier, will help you do that in these crazy times. Running through July 24th at Studio's adorable East Islip venue, the Bayway Arts Center, this offering boasts an absolutely stellar cast.

Review: ANNA IN THE TROPICS at Bay Street Theatre
July 8, 2022

What did our critic think of ANNA IN THE TROPICS at Bay Street Theatre? Sag Harbor's Bay Street Theatre certainly has another hit on their hands with their latest offering, the Pulitzer winning Anna in the Tropics. The stellar production, the second of their current season, runs through July 24th at the adorable East End venue. It was on Broadway from the Fall of 2003 to early 2004 and this showing is indeed not one to be missed.

BWW Review: HEAD OVER HEELS at The Gateway
June 10, 2022

What did our critic think of HEAD OVER HEELS at The Gateway? Happy Pride! June is starting off splendidly with The Gateway's wonderful incarnation of Head Over Heels. Running through June 26th, this Keith Andrews directed mounting boasts an extraordinary cast and the fun music of the Go-Go's. Not to mention they are using the same sets and costumes from the Broadway production. Indeed, this show should be on the list for your summer viewing.

BWW Review: DRIVING MISS DAISY presented by Studio Theatre At BayWay Arts Center
April 8, 2022

Alfred Uhry's Pulitzer Prize winning play Driving Miss Daisy, presented by Studio Theatre through April 22nd at the BayWay Theatre in East Islip, is indeed a stirring and heart rendering tale. The heart of this story follows the relationship of Daisy Werthen and Hoke Colburn over the span of twenty-five years (from 1948 - 1973). It examines race and religious prejudices, but ultimately looks at human relationships and our ability to look at a person’s core.