Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: Strawdog's ONCE IN A LIFETIME Offers Up Comedic Nostalgia

For Strawdog Theatre Company's final production in its Broadway home, the company fittingly presents George S. Kaufman and Moss Hart's 1930 comedy ONCE IN A LIFETIME-both play and production are rife with charm and sly winks to the audience. Director Damon Kiely's choice to stage this particular Kaufman and Hart comedy is also an intriguing one. ONCE IN A LIFETIME chiefly concerns itself with the changes to the entertainment industry after the appearance of the first "talkie" (a film with spoken dialogue) and a frantic trio of three former vaudeville performers--May, George, and Jerry--who scramble to Hollywood hoping to strike it rich. And just as Jerry contemplates what these new "talkies" will mean for the future of the "legitimate stage," so too do we now find ourselves on the precipice of immense change for the film and entertainment industry.

Indeed, the art of movie-making and the practice of going to the theater is shifting in this age of Netflix streaming--and once again those in the film business must ponder how to keep up. It's incredible to think that it's been fewer than 100 years since the debut of 1927's THE JAZZ SINGER--the very first talkie--and that the nature of film has changed so much since. Film buffs will undoubtedly enjoy the countless cultural references to the early days of film in ONCE IN A LIFETIME.

The pressure May, George, and Jerry feel at the changing times they face in ONCE IN A LIFETIME nicely mirrors the present moment. Kiely's production does well to highlight this parallel by incorporating some twenty-first century touches. Namely, the ensemble of 13 performers (many of whom take on multiple roles, as the play calls for some 40-odd characters) perform 1920s-style arrangements of many contemporary songs. These musical numbers function as a comment on the quest for fame and money that the protagonists seek. These numbers include some songs that overtly refer to Hollywood, including "Party in the USA" and "California Girls." It's an interesting and charming gimmick. The result is mixed, however, as much of the ensemble can't quite meet the vocal demands (though it's worth noting that actors Justine C. Turner and Sarah Goeden have great voices).

In terms of the acting, Kiely's ensemble wins every moment. Kathleen McDonnell triumphs as leading lady May, who proposes to start a school in which to train aspiring Hollywood actors in the art of elocution. McDonnell captures all of May's determination and crafty methods to achieve success. She also makes us feel for her character, who above all, just wants Jerry to propose marriage after several years of courtship. Scott Danielson lands the laughs as the daft and clueless George. As aspiring actor and equally ditzy personality Susan, Goeden provides a great counterpart as George's love interest. Mike Dailey infuses charisma in the relative "straight man" role of Jerry. As renowned film critic Helen Hobart, Turner's outsized performance earns some of the biggest laughs of the evening. Also of note: Michaela Petro and Anderson Lawfer as a dynamic comedic duo. The two perform a range of roles throughout the evening together, including hilarious turns as wannabe stars and inept pupils in May's elocution school (with Lawfer in drag).

Overall, ONCE IN A LIFETIME makes for an affable evening at the theater that's always charming, occasionally laugh-out-loud funny, and steeped in nostalgia for an era gone by.

Strawdog Theatre Company's ONCE IN A LIFETIME is now extended through June 11 and plays at at 3829 North Broadway. Tickets are $28-$30 and can be purchased online at or by phone at 866.811.4111.

Photo by Tom McGrath

NRDC Partners with Art at a Time Like This at EXPO CHICAGO to Highlight the Power of Women Photo
For the 10th anniversary of EXPO CHICAGO, NRDC (Natural Resources Defense Council) has partnered with Art at a Time Like This (ATLT) to create HOW ON EARTH, a climate-focused exhibit from acclaimed artists Janet Biggs, Lily Kwong, Helina Metaferia and Jennifer Wen Ma.

Metropolis Performing Arts Centre Presents RAGTIME in May Photo
Metropolis Performing Arts Centre presents the acutely renowned musical inspired by a novel of the same name, Ragtime.

Lookingglass Theatre Company Announces Registration Is Now Open for 2023 Summer Camp Photo
The Department of Curiosity at Lookingglass Theatre Company invites high school students to participate in a one-of-a-kind experience this summer in the historic Water Tower Water Works on Michigan Avenue. 

TRADE FEDERATION Exploring Globalization Through Star Wars, Opens April 28 Photo
Otherworld Theatre Company, the premier science fiction and fantasy production company in North America, has announced the staging of Andy Boyd's “THE TRADE FEDERATION, Or, Let's Explore Globalization Through the Star Wars Prequels,” running April 28 - May 13, 2023 on the Ray Bradbury stage at 3914 N. Clark St.

From This Author - Rachel Weinberg

Chicago native Rachel Weinberg has been one of the most frequent contributing editors and critics for BroadwayWorld Chicago since joining the team in 2014. She is a marketing professional specializ... (read more about this author)

Review: THE BOOK OF MORMON National Tour Presented By Broadway In ChicagoReview: THE BOOK OF MORMON National Tour Presented By Broadway In Chicago
March 30, 2023

I was curious about the changes to Trey Parker, Robert Lopez, and Matt Stone’s THE BOOK OF MORMON, which underwent revisions before its post-pandemic return to Broadway in 2021. I imagined a substantial overhaul of the material, along with input from co-director/choreographer Casey Nicholaw (Parker also co-directed). After seeing the show, I can state the changes are minimal. All of the musical numbers are the same, and some of the dialogue may have been altered. But I don’t buy that the Ugandan characters have been given more agency or power.

Review: THE COMEDY OF ERRORS at Chicago Shakespeare TheaterReview: THE COMEDY OF ERRORS at Chicago Shakespeare Theater
March 17, 2023

Chicago Shakespeare Theater Artistic Director Barbara Gaines cleverly marries play and production concept in THE COMEDY OF ERRORS for her final production.

Review: LAYALINA at Goodman TheatreReview: LAYALINA at Goodman Theatre
March 15, 2023

Martin Yousif Zebari’s LAYALINA is a heartwarming multigenerational family play that spans from Baghdad to Skokie. While Zebari doesn’t shy away from portraying the family’s trauma and the challenges of their immigrant experiences, LAYALINA is the opposite of many other family plays. It’s about how the central family tries to reconnect and find commonalities, despite their generational and cultural differences.

Review: DESCRIBE THE NIGHT at Steppenwolf Theatre CompanyReview: DESCRIBE THE NIGHT at Steppenwolf Theatre Company
March 13, 2023

Rajiv Joseph’s DESCRIBE THE NIGHT, now in its Chicago premiere at Steppenwolf Theatre Company, is a sprawling exploration of the blurring of fiction and fact, censorship, and the quest to preserve truth.

Review: TONI STONE at Goodman TheatreReview: TONI STONE at Goodman Theatre
February 8, 2023

What did our critic think of TONI STONE at Goodman Theatre? TONI STONE is a memory play-in more ways than one. Lydia R. Diamond's play is indeed structured in non-linear (and yet, still mostly chronological order) as the titular Toni Stone recounts her memories as the first woman to regularly play professional baseball. It's also a memory play in the sense that it captures a moment in history that many audiences may not know before they see the work. In real life, Toni Stone played for the Indianapolis Clowns, a Negro League team, in 1953. The play itself never references that year-or any dates in Toni's timeline-outright (the program merely lists the setting as '1920's-1940's USA.') Instead, Toni weaves between different moments in her life, diving in and out of them-much like she might dive to catch a ball in the outfield (although she played second base).