The Nowaks of Buffalo, NY, have always believed in their family`s miraculous Christmas Eve story—until Ruth decides to turn it into a one-woman show, only to have a deathbed confession threaten to unravel the legend. As the truth emerges, the Nowaks must face their faith, family and hilarious truths in this heartfelt comedy.
Cast and Creative team for Miracle on South Division Street at Citadel Theatre
Cast
Naomi Hershman
Clara
Lorelei Sturm
Beverly
Mindy Shore
Ruth
Robert Wood Frank
Jimmy
Sheri Warren
U/S Clara
Jennifer Ruffner
U/S Beverly
Jamie Hendler
U/S Ruth
Philip J Macaluso
U/S Jimmy
Creative Team
Scott Shallenbarger
Director
Mathew Kier
Stage Manager
Bob Knuth
Scenic Designer
Danielle Reinhardt
Costume Designer
Joel Zishuk
Lighting Designer
Maya Reter
Sound Designer
Ellen Markus
Properties Designer
Mitchell Pollitt
Technical Director
Alex Trinh
Stage Crew
SUBMIT UPDATES
Citadel Theatre Frequently Asked Questions FAQ
Citadel Theatre is at 300 S Waukegan Rd., Lake Forest, IL.
Misery (9/12/25-10/12/25)
Admissions (2/13/26-3/15/26)
Videos
 |
Bernadette, The Musical
Athenaeum Center for Thought and Culture (2/12 - 3/15) | |
 |
The Dance of Death
Steppenwolf (1/29 - 3/22) | |
 |
Dear Evan Hanson
Paramount Theatre (2/4 - 3/22) | |
 |
The Ultimate Cher Show Starring Annika
Raue Center For The Arts (2/7 - 2/7) | |
|
Lucy's Comedy
Raue Center For The Arts (5/22 - 5/22) | |
|
Chicago Comedy Hour
de Maat Theater at The Second City (1/9 - 1/30) | |
|
The Wiz
James M. Nederlander Theatre (3/31 - 4/5) | |
|
2000s Throwback Hip Hop Party With Too Hype Crew and Bobby Afterlife
BaseCamp Pub (3/6 - 3/7) | |
|
Bernadette, the Musical
The Athenaeum Center for Thought & Culture. (2/12 - 3/15)
VIDEOS
| |
| VIEW SHOWS ADD A SHOW | ||
Get Chicago's #1 Theatre Newsletter
All the show news & discounts for Chicago & beyond.
