Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: AVENUE Q at Mercury Theater Has Big Laughs and A Bigger Heart

Review: AVENUE Q at Mercury Theater Has Big Laughs and A Bigger Heart

The lovable and lewd puppets of AVENUE Q have returned to Mercury Theater in a remount of the company's successful 2014 production. I have a soft spot for this musical gem-which beat out WICKED in 2004 to take home the Best Musical Tony Award-and Mercury's production reminded me precisely why that appreciation runs so deep. With a book by Jeff Whitty and lyrics by Jeff Marx and Robert Lopez (the latter of subsequent THE BOOK OF MORMON and FROZEN fame), AVENUE Q strikes a delectable balance between outrageously funny and unabashedly heartfelt.

AVENUE Q'S high concept is "Sesame Street for adults," as evidenced by such numbers as "Everyone's A Little Bit Racist" and "It Sucks To Be Me." Yet as I watched Mercury Theater's production on Friday night, I was also struck by the fact that this show fully wears its heart on its fuzzy puppet sleeve. AVENUE Q's ragtag, diverse community of puppets, monsters, and humans coming together to face the challenges of NYC living has a hopeful sincerity to it that makes the show especially relevant now. Some of the show's material has certainly aged since 2003, particularly the number "The Internet Is for Porn" that pre-dates the ubiquity of smartphones. Yet AVENUE Q's genuine optimism about the ability of diverse individuals to come together and support one another feels so needed now.

That's not to say, however, that this AVENUE Q is short of the laughs it needs to succeed. On the contrary, director L. Walter Stearns's ensemble that brings together a mix of returning and new cast nail both the comedic and sweet moments in the show. In the leading roles of Princeton and Kate Monster, Jackson Evans and Leah Morrow capture an earnestness so pure that it will squeeze your heart. Evans portrays Princeton's optimism and naiveté with such genuine intent, drawing audiences to both him and the puppet character he carries onstage. Morrow easily essays Kate Monster's big heart and her character's longing for love and success in her career. She's also vocally so expressive and wonderful. As free-spirited Nicky and uptight Rod, AVENUE Q's send-up to that iconic Sesame Street duo Ernie and Bert, Dan Smeriglio and Christian Siebert play off each other beautifully. Audrey Billings wins the day as Japanese immigrant Christmas Eve, married to the rather directionless Brian (Matthew Miles). Billings not only has a command of her character's comedy, but also has a chance to show off her classical vocal training. Overall, the whole cast truly comes together to build a sense of community, and there's not a weak link vocally or acting-wise among them.

AVENUE Q's relatively modest and intentionally dilapidated set design from Alan Donahue lends itself well to the Mercury Theater's intimate venue. Of course, the puppet design is perhaps the most critical element for AVENUE Q. Russ Walko designed the puppets; they largely evoke those of the original Broadway production, with some unique changes. Notably, Rick Lyon-who designed the puppets for Broadway and performed in the OBC-also consulted as puppetry coach on this production. The actors nail the puppet work. AVENUE Q's signature staging has the actors visible and performing alongside their puppets, and that combination is particularly delightful here.

Whether you have seen AVENUE Q before and can mouth the lyrics to all the songs or if you have never experienced it, Mercury Theater's production is worth a visit. AVENUE Q will provide uproarious and NSFW laughs for days, but it also will touch your heart and provide a much-needed dose of theatrical sunshine.

AVENUE Q plays through December 30 at Mercury Theater Chicago, 3745 North Southport Avenue. Tickets are $35-$65. MercuryTheaterChicago.com

Photo by Brett A. Beiner



World Premiere of MIA: WHERE HAVE ALL THE YOUNG GIRLS GONE? to Open at Greenhouse Theater  Photo
MIA: WHERE HAVE ALL THE YOUNG GIRLS GONE? will be performed at Greenhouse Theater Center. See how to purchase tickets.

League of Chicago Theatres to Host Free, Public Celebration to Kick Off Chicago Theatre We Photo
The League of Chicago Theatres, in partnership with Choose Chicago, will present a celebratory evening of food, drinks, mingling, and performances to launch Chicago Theatre Week 2023. 

Nominations for 2023 Jeff Awards for Non-Equity Theater Announced; See the Full List! Photo
Kicking off the new year, the Joseph Jefferson Awards announced its nominations for theater excellence among Non-Equity theater. See the full list!

AstonRep Theatre Announces 14th Annual WRITERS SERIES Photo
AstonRep Theatre Company has announced its 14th annual Writer's Series, featuring two free staged readings of new works by emerging writers on Saturday, February 25 at 2 pm at The Edge Off Broadway, 1133 W. Catalpa Ave. in Chicago's Edgewater neighborhood.


From This Author - Rachel Weinberg

Chicago native Rachel Weinberg has been one of the most frequent contributing editors and critics for BroadwayWorld Chicago since joining the team in 2014. She is a marketing professional specializ... (read more about this author)


Review: THE RIPPLE, THE WAVE THAT CARRIED ME HOME at Goodman TheatreReview: THE RIPPLE, THE WAVE THAT CARRIED ME HOME at Goodman Theatre
January 24, 2023

In the ripple, the wave that carried me home, protagonist Janice must metaphorically reckon with her homecoming and her childhood in the fictional Beacon, Kansas.

Review: CABARET at Porchlight Music TheatreReview: CABARET at Porchlight Music Theatre
January 20, 2023

What did our critic think of CABARET at Porchlight Music Theatre? Porchlight invites audiences into the glittering, gritty world of early 1930s Berlin with John Kander and Fred Ebb’s iconic musical CABARET. Under the direction of Porchlight Artistic Director Michael Weber and with associate direction and choreography by Brenda Didier, this production largely belongs to Erica Stephan in the role of Sally Bowles. As the seductive and desperate nightclub singer, Sally, Stephan is an absolute dream. She not only plays the character’s arc beautifully, moving from artful seduction to total desperation and panic by the show’s end, but she showcases her powerful belt and vocal control in each of Sally’s solo numbers. In this way, Porchlight’s production mirrors Sally’s character arc; as the other characters in the show are awakened to the realities of the Nazi party’s rise to power, they must contend with the fact that life is not, in fact, a cabaret.

Review: BALD SISTERS at Steppenwolf Theatre CompanyReview: BALD SISTERS at Steppenwolf Theatre Company
December 12, 2022

What did our critic think of BALD SISTERS at Steppenwolf Theatre Company? Steppenwolf presents a new twist on the well-trod territory of the dysfunctional family drama with Vichet Chum’s BALD SISTERS. As far as dysfunctional families go, too, the family in BALD SISTERS doesn’t have the most baggage. That said, Chum’s characters still have plenty to contend with as sisters Him and Sophea mourn the loss of their mother. The play is a meditation on the circle of life, but I appreciate that BALD SISTERS is an exercise in subtlety as far as family dramas go. As a result, some of Chum’s scenes meander and don’t seem to have a purpose within the context of the play, but I like that BALD SISTERS has themes that wash over audiences rather than hit them over the head.

Review: Porchlight Revisits THE APPLE TREEReview: Porchlight Revisits THE APPLE TREE
December 9, 2022

Porchlight Music Theatre invited audiences to take another bite of musical theater history with Jerry Bock and Sheldon Harnick’s THE APPLE TREE. The musical, composed of three one-acts centered on the theme of temptation, was the season opener for the Porchlight Revisits series. As usual, Porchight Artistic Director Michael Weber introduced the show with a brief educational talk on THE APPLE TREE’s history.

Movies This Christmas Season for Broadway Fans — Old and NewMovies This Christmas Season for Broadway Fans — Old and New
November 17, 2022

Here’s our selection of brand-new, recent, and classic festive films featuring some of theater’s most iconic faces that you won’t want to miss.