Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: Winter Opera of St. Louis Presents L'ELISIR D'AMORE

Review: Winter Opera of St. Louis Presents L'ELISIR D'AMORE

We went out into the chilly spring evening - and it became, for me, one of the most totally pleasing evenings of opera I've ever experienced. Winter Opera of St. Louis presented Donizetti's "L'Elisir d'Amore" in a production that was as near perfection as one could ever ask.

The setting of this charming romantic comedy was originally a small rural Italian (or Basque) village around the turn of the 19th century. Winter Opera and stage director Audrey Chait have chosen to transpose the time to 1942 and the place to St. Louis' own beloved Italian neighborhood, "The Hill". This, it turns out, is wonderfully appropriate. The Hill is a neighborhood where, at least until recent decades, people would naturally speak (or sing) in Italian. As in a small village everybody knew everybody. The lovely set by Scott Loebl shows us a street scene, with the storefronts of Volpi's and DiGregorio's-iconic Italian markets on The Hill. There's the popular Dominic's restaurant, there's a stereotypical brick home, and in the background there's the warm heart of The Hill-the church of St. Ambrose. How appropriate! Winter Opera's offices and rehearsal space are a short three blocks from St. Ambrose. Moreover, company founder and executive director (and the splendid leading lady of this production) is Gina Galati; I have no doubt that she has some family connection to The Hill

So this is a very St. Louisy production, yet perfectly true to Donizetti's story.

Adina, a lovely young woman, is a landowner "of easy circumstances." She is adored by Nemorino, a young man of "comely appearance, but small means". Until now she has carelessly dismissed his professions of love. Two charismatic strangers disturb the equilibrium of the village: Recruiting Sgt. Belcore, who has come seeking enlistees for the army (and beautiful girls for himself), and Dr. Dulcamara, a charlatan snake-oil salesman. Belcore, the classic miles gloriosus, brags about his many feminine conquests, and sets his eye on Adina. Dr. Dulcamara and his beautiful assistant begin huckstering his patent medicines. The desperate Nemorino buys the doctor's love potion. This, the doctor claims, will make every woman fall in love with Nemorino (though it's really just cheap wine).

Everything about this production is just so right! Miss Galati has never been in finer voice. Such purity and vocal agility, such easy access to those high notes. She is beautifully paired with Peter Scott Drackley as Nemorino. He too displays a clear, sweet, strong voice which is utterly comfortable over the whole range of the role.

Andrew Potter, as Dr. Dulcamara, is tall, tall, towering dramatically over the rest of the cast. He has a powerful bottomless bass voice. (One almost needs a bathysphere to follow him as he plunges that word "eccelente" down to the depths.) He also has wonderful comic gifts. Christopher Holloway has just the right handsome looks and swagger for Sgt. Belcore, as well as a lovely strong baritone voice that serves the role well. Adina's friend Giannetta is sung by Karen Kanakis. I want to hear that beautiful voice in a much larger role.

Some musical highlights include "Volio dire", the bargaining over the elixir, where Nemorino sings a bright, lyrical melody against Dulcamara's patter background of lightning-fast syllables; "Una furtiva lagrima" where Nemorino, in a soft, lonely evening, sheds "one secret tear"; and "En guerra ed in amore", a marvelous trio with Adina, Nemorino and Belcore.

The large chorus does excellent work, under Chorus Master Nancy Mayor

Maestro Darwin Aquino draws great beauty from his orchestra of twenty-two. There's a clarity of individual voices here-one can sense the distinct timbre of violin, flute, reed. The Viragh auditorium has gorgeous acoustics that support such clarity.

JC Krajicek has costumed the show with her usual careful attention to period and detail, and with a beautifully balanced palette. Supertitles are very clear and well-handled.

A very important element in the overall excellence of the evening is the deft, masterful work of Stage Director Audrey Chait. She handles the large chorus (including four charming little girls) amazingly well. The stage, though often full, is never crowed, always natural, never static. Every "stage picture" is beautifully composed.

And the show bursts with lovely, clever bits of business: two old men playing checkers could have just walked to the square from a game of bocce ball at Milo's; there's much fun to be had in the energetic shaking of the magic bottle of elixir; Belcore's crisp military salute ends with a little grace-note of a flirting wave. The funniest thing I ever saw in an opera is Dr. Dulcamara singing a duet while he is eating a huge bowl of spaghetti. (How in the world?)

Design, direction, singing, acting, orchestra-everything is sublimely balanced, and everything is beautiful. It's the Winter Opera production of Donizetti's "L'Elisir d'Amore". It played at the Viragh center at chaminade on March 9 and 11.

(Photo credits: Wylde Brothers Productions)

(This review was first published by KDHX, St. Louis.)

Regional Awards

Related Stories

From This Author - Steve Callahan

A native Kansan I have a BA (Math and Theatre) and MA (Theatre). I was working on a PhD in Theatre when IBM sniffed my math background and lured me away with money enough to feed my (then two) chil... (read more about this author)


Review: A LITTLE NIGHT MUSIC at Union Avenue OperaReview: A LITTLE NIGHT MUSIC at Union Avenue Opera
August 25, 2022

This, Sondheim's most charming work, receives a splendid production at Union Avenue Opera. Yesterday I mentioned to two of my kids that we'd just seen A Little Night Music. Now they had both memorized most of Sweeney Todd some forty years ago while in grade school or junior high, so I was appalled to find that neither of them was familiar with this earlier Sondheim masterpiece. What sort of wretchedly deprived childhood had we given them?!

Review: FALSTAFF at Union Avenue OperaReview: FALSTAFF at Union Avenue Opera
August 1, 2022

Verdi's Falstaff is another glittering gem in the train of Union Avenue Opera. I'm not a big fan of 're-purposing' classic plays. Poor Shakespeare! He's been subjected to such vandalism over the years with modern 'concept' versions of his works. No, I do not want to go to see a trendy lesbian-Hamlet-on-Mars!

Review: EUGENE ONEGIN at Union Avenue OperaReview: EUGENE ONEGIN at Union Avenue Opera
July 11, 2022

Glorious voices fill Tchaikovsky's masterpiece with beauty. After the tribulations of the pandemic the Union Avenue Opera returns to its lovely home. Here, in the nave of the Union Avenue Christian Church, the company presents first-class opera up-close and intimate. They open their 28th season with a superb production of Tchaikovsky's Eugene Onegin.

Review: CENTER STAGE at Opera Theatre Of Saint LouisReview: CENTER STAGE at Opera Theatre Of Saint Louis
June 23, 2022

What did our critic think? Center Stage is a great smörgåsbord of opera- No, no, that's far too Swedish and Lutheran and heavy. If the whole OTSL festival is a great feast, then Center Stage is the delicious icing on the top of that final cake. It's all dessert and no vegetables.

BWW Review: A Revised, Dream-Haunted HARVEY MILK  at Opera Theatre Of Saint LouisBWW Review: A Revised, Dream-Haunted HARVEY MILK at Opera Theatre Of Saint Louis
June 13, 2022

A marvelously theatrical, dream-haunted evening tells of gay-rights activist Harvey Milk’s life and death.