Advertisement

Page: 1


NYC Pizza?

Dionysus3 Profile PhotoDionysus3 Profile Photo
Dionysus3
Chorus Member
joined:12/13/19
Chorus Member
joined:
12/13/19
NYC Pizza?#1
Posted: 1/15/20 at 9:57pm

My wife and I dont get to NYC often—roughly once every three years. We have a trip planned for April and want to try some good pizza while we’re there. There are only two of us, so we don’t want to visit a place where we have to buy a whole pie, but most (or all) of the slice shops I’ve researched have little or no seating. While I understand most people either stand and eat or take their pizza to go, without going too much into it, that’s not something that will work for us.

So my question is, are there any good, traditional NYC pizza places that sell by the slice and have reasonable seating accommodations? Thanks!

Updated On: 1/15/20 at 09:57 PM
UncleCharlie
Broadway Legend
joined:6/26/16
Broadway Legend
joined:
6/26/16
NYC Pizza?#2
Posted: 1/15/20 at 11:29pm
I don't know if it's the best although every place will have it in their name and tell you they are but my go to slice place in the theater district is Famous Amadeus on 8th ave. between 50th and 51st. Decent pizza, reasonable prices and plenty of seating. Pretty basic but a good place to grab a slice and sit if you want.
Jordan Catalano Profile PhotoJordan Catalano Profile Photo
Jordan Catalano
Broadway Legend
joined:10/9/05
Broadway Legend
joined:
10/9/05
NYC Pizza?#3
Posted: 1/16/20 at 12:46am
If you want here in midtown, my absolute favorite pizza place there is on 46th St directly actors from the Richard Rodgers theatre - Patzeria Pizza.

But just know that asking us New Yorkers where to find good pizza is only going to give you a different answer for everyone you ask. NYC Pizza?
Dionysus3 Profile PhotoDionysus3 Profile Photo
Dionysus3
Chorus Member
joined:12/13/19
Chorus Member
joined:
12/13/19
NYC Pizza?#4
Posted: 1/16/20 at 10:06am

Jordan Catalano said: “

But just know that asking us New Yorkers where to find good pizza is only going to give you a different answer for everyone you ask. NYC Pizza?"

Fair. But also, that’s okay—that gives me choices to research! 
 

Thanks to you both.

ModernMillie3 Profile PhotoModernMillie3 Profile Photo
ModernMillie3
Broadway Star
joined:9/23/13
Broadway Star
joined:
9/23/13
NYC Pizza?#5
Posted: 1/16/20 at 4:18pm

Harlem - Sottocasa Pizzeria

Midtown - Don Antonio

LES - Scarr’s Pizza

Enjoy!

Huss417 Profile PhotoHuss417 Profile Photo
Huss417
Broadway Legend
joined:5/15/03
Broadway Legend
joined:
5/15/03
NYC Pizza?#6
Posted: 1/16/20 at 5:04pm

ModernMillie3 said: "Harlem -SottocasaPizzeria

Midtown - Don Antonio

LES -Scarr’s Pizza

Enjoy!
"

I didn't realize Don Antonio served slices. Good to know.

 

"I hope your Fanny is bigger than my Peter." Mary Martin to Ezio Pinza opening night of Fanny.
n2nbaby Profile Photon2nbaby Profile Photo
n2nbaby
Broadway Legend
joined:10/22/10
Broadway Legend
joined:
10/22/10
NYC Pizza?#7
Posted: 1/17/20 at 12:24pm

Jordan Catalano said: "If you want here in midtown, my absolute favorite pizza place there is on 46th St directly actors from the Richard Rodgers theatre - Patzeria Pizza.

But just know that asking us New Yorkers where to find good pizza is only going to give you a different answer for everyone you ask. NYC Pizza?
"

YES YES YES. I love Jordan and this just cemented it further. Their pizza is incredible. 
 

But be warned, seating is very limited to a couple stools.

AEA AGMA SM
Broadway Legend
joined:8/13/09
Broadway Legend
joined:
8/13/09
NYC Pizza?#8
Posted: 1/17/20 at 2:35pm

I believe that Bleecker Street Pizza recently expanded their seating area. They've always been one of my go to spots when I have people visiting from out of town.

Did you know that every day Mexican gays cross our borders and unplug our brain-dead ladies?
Jordan Catalano Profile PhotoJordan Catalano Profile Photo
Jordan Catalano
Broadway Legend
joined:10/9/05
Broadway Legend
joined:
10/9/05
NYC Pizza?#9
Posted: 1/17/20 at 5:21pm

n2nbaby said: "Jordan Catalano said: "If you want here in midtown, my absolute favorite pizza place there is on 46th St directly actors from the Richard Rodgers theatre - Patzeria Pizza.

But just know that asking us New Yorkers where to find good pizza is only going to give you a different answer for everyone you ask. NYC Pizza?
"

YES YES YES. I love Jordan and this just cemented it further. Their pizza is incredible.


But be warned, seating is very limited to a couple stools.
"


 

<3 <3 <3 <3 <3 <3

Melissa25 Profile PhotoMelissa25 Profile Photo
Melissa25
Broadway Star
joined:5/20/12
Broadway Star
joined:
5/20/12
NYC Pizza?#10
Posted: 1/17/20 at 8:13pm

My go to place is Little Italy 55 W. 45th. 

Dionysus3 Profile PhotoDionysus3 Profile Photo
Dionysus3
Chorus Member
joined:12/13/19
Chorus Member
joined:
12/13/19
NYC Pizza?#11
Posted: 1/19/20 at 1:15pm

AEA AGMA SM said: "I believe that Bleecker Street Pizza recently expanded their seating area. They've always been one of my go to spots when I have people visiting from out of town."

This is good to know!

dave1606
Broadway Star
joined:12/8/07
Broadway Star
joined:
12/8/07
NYC Pizza?#12
Posted: 1/21/20 at 1:04pm

Joe's pizza just opened just below Times square on 39th or 40th and Bway. They are consistently one of my favorite by the slice spots though there can be a line. 

ColorTheHours048 Profile PhotoColorTheHours048 Profile Photo
ColorTheHours048
Broadway Legend
joined:4/4/08
Broadway Legend
joined:
4/4/08
NYC Pizza?#13
Posted: 1/21/20 at 4:30pm
If you’re willing to venture to Brooklyn, Juliana’s in Dumbo is my favorite pizza in the city. It’s the original Grimaldi’s pizza recipe.