GavestonPS said: "DADDY LONG LEGS hasn't been mentioned here. It's a two-character show, but one I listened to daily for six months after it was streamed for free on the internet."
Seconded wholeheartedly. It's an Off-Broadway show based on the short novel Daddy Long Legs by Jean Webster. You don't need to read the story beforehand to understand it, though!
Once Bring It On Matilda Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder Violet Hedwig and the Angry Inch Fun Home Something Rotten The Visit Hamilton Bright Star Great Comet Bandstand Daddy Long Legs (Off-Broadway) Sense & Sensibility (Chicago Shakespeare Theatre)
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian
And I know that the show wasn't very successful but I thought Bright Star had an absolutely lovely score. I think of the major flops of the last five years Bright Star was the musical that had a score that deserved to be heard for way longer.
HTDobson, matter of opinion. I an not a fan of a few you listed.
I would add Bright Star.
I also loved and was a bit obsessed with the score to "Nevermore...". I really liked the walk-in music a lot. Finally got a copy of the show amd walk-in music.
I posted my favorites when this thread was first started, but since then, I've discovered "Venice," which I've absolutely fallen in love with. I know it got a lot of negative word of mouth at the Public, but I think the score is just phenomenal. It's my current musical theatre obsession. I've made it my goal to introduce it to all my musical theatre-loving friends, because I don't know anybody who has heard it.