I was there last night. Got to the stage door about 10 or 15 minutes after curtain and a few of the cast members were already outside. I stayed for about 1/2 an hour. Seemed like eveyone was out by then except Chase and Karl (unless I missed them). Everyone was nice. Got a picture with Ms Block and Ms Rivera. They stopped and cjatted and Ms Block check every picture to make sure it came out ok for the people who asked for one. There were only about 20 people waiting so I figure that's why the cast was able to just kind of hang out and chat. I don't stagedoor much at all but glad I did last night! Oh, and met Ms. Block's dog who is in the show with her.
Echoing CharinMarin's statement- I was there last Saturday, and those were the three who didn't come out. Everyone else was very nice- Chita came out last that night and signed for everyone and chatted. So did SJB, which I thought was really gracious since there was a crowd of her friends waiting for her, too.
Stage doored last night and the only person I didn't see was Andy Karl, but I was on a major time crunch or might've missed my bus so he might've just been slow. Everyone was swee and gracious and signed/took pics. A truly AMAZING stage door experience to match the truly AMAZING show!!!
Curious as to who does/doesn't come out after matinees. Going on Sat. with my sister, I saw a matinee of Anything Goes and SJB came out and was very kind.
Best advice I can give is to learn the names of cast members before you go if you don't already know them. Nearly everyone came out of the stage door (18 one time I was there), but many only stopped and signed when addressed by name. For example, I recognzed Kyle Coffman as he exited the stage door, and asked him to sign my window card. He signed for me and the guy next to me, and then took off.
I appreciate the responses, I guess I should specify, I am curious as to 2 show days and who does/doesn't come out then. I'm familar with the cast, so that's a non issue.