Skip to main content
Vote for the BWW Central Pennsylvania Awards
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: ANNIE at Fulton Theatre

Don't wait for tomorrow, get tickets today!

By:
Review: ANNIE at Fulton Theatre

Director and choreographer, Marc Robin brings dazzle, energy, humor and heart to the Lancaster area this holiday season. Lyla Randall is perfect as the title character in Annie.  She has both the sweetness and the sass needed to lead this show.  Her numbers, especially the iconic Tomorrow are an excellent fit for her powerful and confident voice.

James Patterson and Kathryn Boswell are lovely as Daddy Warbucks and Grace.  Both actors convey warmth and sincerity into their performances.  Patterson does the impossible in 2026… he makes us care about and root for a billionaire!

Charis Leos is wonderful as the wicked Mrs. Hannigan.  She brings equal parts humor and menace to the role and had me laughing out loud on many occasions.  Notably, she is matched in talent and vibrancy by Coleman Cummings as her brother (Rooster) and Tori Heinlein as his girlfriend (Lily St. Regis). The trio’s number for a better life, Easy Street was a first act highlight.  

Annie’s friends in the orphanage were consistently talented and polished. At the pre-show announcements, it was mentioned that this cast has been hard at work for the past two and a half weeks.  As a person familiar with children’s theater, I can attest that many community shows rehearse for two and a half months and still do not get half the performance quality reflected on this Fulton stage.

The program states that there are 2 different groups of orphans that alternate performances, the red cast and the green cast.  This is more than enough reason to come see the show a second time.

Robin’s choreography was impressive, explosive and athletic.  There was a surprising number of gymnastic moves called for, and the cast was more than ready for the challenge.

Finally, I want to draw attention to two deserving, but largely unrecognized stars of the show.  Annie’s lovable four-legged friend, Sandy (uncredited in my playbill) was a scene stealer.  The dog’s shaggy fur and unkempt appearance made me believe that he really did have a hard knock life.

The production also makes great use of a beautiful golden curtain throughout the show.  It is often brought down for set changes, while actors do a short scene in front of it.  This bit of traditional stage craft is seen very infrequently anymore, yet it adds a nice sense of theatricality and elegance.

Don’t wait for Tomorrow, go see Fulton Theatre’s Annie today! Everyone’s favorite orphaned ginger is onstage through December 31st.  Get your tickets while you still can.

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on The Fulton Theatre
Upcoming Shows
Annie
Annie
11/20 - 12/31/2026
Twas the Night Before Christmas
Twas the Night Before Christmas
11/28 - 12/26/2026
Recent Articles
Interview: Lyla Randall (Annie) And James Patterson (Warbucks) of ANNIE at Fulton Theatre
Interview: Lyla Randall (Annie) And James Patterson (Warbucks) of ANNIE at Fulton Theatre
11/18/2026
Kathryn Boswell and More to Star in ANNIE at Fulton Theatre This Holiday Season
Kathryn Boswell and More to Star in ANNIE at Fulton Theatre This Holiday Season
11/11/2026

Reader Reviews



BroadwayWorld TV


Golden Girls The Laughs Continue in Central Pennsylvania Golden Girls The Laughs Continue
Hershey Theatre (11/24-11/24) VIDEOS
Dancing at Lughnasa in Central Pennsylvania Dancing at Lughnasa
Messiah University Department of Theatre and Dance (11/12-11/22)
Gutenberg! The Musical! in Central Pennsylvania Gutenberg! The Musical!
The Fulton Theatre (5/14-6/06)
A Christmas Carol in Central Pennsylvania A Christmas Carol
Totem Pole Playhouse (12/04-12/13)
Beethoven's Ninth in Central Pennsylvania Beethoven's Ninth
Appell Center (5/15-5/15)
9 to 5 in Central Pennsylvania 9 to 5
Dutch Appe Dinner Theatre (2/26-4/02)
SIX (Boleyn Tour) in Central Pennsylvania SIX (Boleyn Tour)
Hershey Theatre (6/18-6/20)
The Stinky Cheese Man and Other Fairly Stupid Tales  in Central Pennsylvania The Stinky Cheese Man and Other Fairly Stupid Tales
Messiah University Department of Theatre and Dance (2/25-2/28)
Little Acts @ LTM in Central Pennsylvania Little Acts @ LTM
Little Theatre of Mechanicsburg (1/22-2/07)
THE SHARK IS BROKEN in Central Pennsylvania THE SHARK IS BROKEN
Little Theatre of Mechanicsburg (3/19-4/04)