Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Photo Flash: MORE BETWEEN HEAVEN AND EARTH With Melissa Errico, Matthew Modine and Kathleen Chalfant

More Between Heaven and Earth, a "play-with-music" about Thomas Jefferson, Maria Cosway, the French Revolution and the doctrine of Separation of Church and State, was performed for an enthusiastic and sold-out house at the AbiGail Adams Smith Auditorium on Saturday, December 17th. Thomas Jefferson met and fell in love with the married, Italian-born painter/composer/musician Maria Cosway during his post as Minister Plenipotentiary to France, and their passionate and intimate correspondence continued for almost 40 years. Part of a larger endeavor to "Reclaim the Founding Fathers From the Tea Party" and staged site-specifically by director Erica Gould in a performance space that is part of a complex built in 1799, the performance--starring Matthew Modine, Melissa Errico, and Kathleen Chalfant and featuring performances by The Clarion Society Orchestra with soprano Jessica Gould and tenor Karim Sulayman--enveloped the audience in the world of 18th century Paris, London, and America. And the actors, musicians, and director brought to vivid and exciting life the passionate, moving, and ultimately star-crossed relationship of Jefferson and Cosway, the violence of the French Revolution, and Jefferson's views, daring for the time (and perhaps even more so now) about the role of religion in American society.

The script, constructed by Erica Gould from Jefferson and Cosway's actual letters and writings, inventively intercut the letters to create the sense of active dialogue between the characters, and interwove the dramatic action with live performances of the actual music (researched by Jessica Gould) that Jefferson and Cosway heard together, shared with each other, and that Cosway wrote for him. When Jefferson (Matthew Modine) receives music Maria has written for him, Maria (Melissa Errico) sings it to him, in a moving realization of this complex and heartbreaking relationship. When Jefferson and Maria write to each other about an opera they have seen, the orchestra and opera singers (Jessica Gould, soprano, and Karim Suleyman, tenor) perform excerpts from it, while the characters watch. These included selections from an opera Jefferson and Cosway saw together in Paris on the night of Wednesday, October 4th, 1786, Dardanus by Sacchini. Never before performed in the US, the music for the performance was prepared from the original 1784 score that is housed in the Columbia University Music Library.

Modine's Jefferson came to life as a complex, compelling, and unexpectedly funny and vulnerable, as well as visionary, man. Melissa Errico's Maria Cosway was a charming, brilliant, and conflicted heroine, who sang exquisitely when finding it easier to convey her complex feelings through music than through words. Kathleen Chalfant's narrator was commanding, warm, and funny as she guided the audience through the story. And the music of the French Revolution was expertly rendered by the exceptional playing of the Clarion Society Orchestra, and the heartfelt, thrilling performances of soprano Jessica Gould and tenor Karim Sulayman.

A portion of the proceeds from the performance will be donated to Americans United for Separation of Church and State.

See photos from the rehearsal and backstage below!


BroadwayWorld Shop
Shop BroadwayWorld

Shop this season's new musicals! Get dressed up for a night at the theatre, or just a night at home, with merch from some of Broadway's biggest hits including SOME LIKE IT HOT, KIMBERLY AKIMBO, and more!

Start Shopping



Related Stories
Justin David Sullivan Withdraws From Tony Awards Consideration Photo
trans non-binary performer Justin David Sullivan, who is currently starring as May in the Broadway production of & Juliet, has withdrawn from consideration for the Tony Awards rather than compete in a gendered category.

Interview: Jonathan Groff on KNOCK AT THE CABIN Being Similar to Theatre Photo
Jonathan Groff is hitting the big screen in M. Night Shyamalan's latest film, Knock at the Cabin. Watch a video of our interview with Groff ahead of the film's premiere, discussing how their filming process was similar to theatre, returning to the psychological thriller genre, and the important representation that is featured in the film.

VIDEO: Watch FUNNY GIRLs Julie Benko & Jason Yeager Perform Me, Myself and I Photo
In just a few days, Birdland Jazz Club will welcome back Julie Benko - direct from Broadway's smash hit revival of Funny Girl - with her band 'Euphonic Gumbo'. BroadwayWorld is very excited to bring you an exclusive song from their last appearance at Birdland. Check out a video of 'Me, Myself, and I'.

Ivo Van Hove Working on DOLL Music Conservatory Television Series Photo
Ivo Van Hove is working with John Wells on a new television series taking place in a ruthless music conservatory. The series will be written by Matthew-Lee Erlbach, inspired by his experience training in the cutthroat environment at one of the top music conservatories in the country. 


More Hot Stories For You


VIDEO: Watch FUNNY GIRL's Julie Benko & Jason Yeager Perform 'Me, Myself and I'VIDEO: Watch FUNNY GIRL's Julie Benko & Jason Yeager Perform 'Me, Myself and I'
February 1, 2023

In just a few days, Birdland Jazz Club will welcome back Julie Benko - direct from Broadway's smash hit revival of Funny Girl - with her band 'Euphonic Gumbo'. BroadwayWorld is very excited to bring you an exclusive song from their last appearance at Birdland. Check out a video of 'Me, Myself, and I'.

Shiloh Goodin, Drew Lachey & More to Star in A CHORUS LINE at Cincinnati Playhouse in the ParkShiloh Goodin, Drew Lachey & More to Star in A CHORUS LINE at Cincinnati Playhouse in the Park
February 1, 2023

Cincinnati Playhouse in the Park will be a singular sensation this spring with the opening of Moe and Jack’s Place — The Rouse Theatre and an all-new production of A Chorus Line. See who is starring in the production, and how to purchase tickets!

Photos: First Look at Nathan Lane, Danny Burstein & Zoë Wanamaker in PICTURES FROM HOMEPhotos: First Look at Nathan Lane, Danny Burstein & Zoë Wanamaker in PICTURES FROM HOME
February 1, 2023

Get a first look at photos of Nathan Lane, Danny Burstein and Zoë Wanamaker in Pictures From Home at Studio 54 on Broadway.

HARRY POTTER AND THE CURSED CHILD Will Bring Back Hogwarts House Pride WeekHARRY POTTER AND THE CURSED CHILD Will Bring Back Hogwarts House Pride Week
February 1, 2023

The Tony Award-winning Broadway production of Harry Potter and the Cursed Child will once again celebrate the Hogwarts houses with four special performances dedicated to each house. Gryffindor, Slytherin, Hufflepuff and Ravenclaw houses are the four living and learning communities for Hogwarts students, named after the wizarding school's four founders. 

Tony Awards Administration Committee Determines Eligibility of 20 Broadway ShowsTony Awards Administration Committee Determines Eligibility of 20 Broadway Shows
February 1, 2023

The Tony Awards Administration Committee met to confirm the eligibility status of twenty Broadway productions for the 2022-2023 season, including Into The Woods, Kimberly Akimbo, A Beautiful Noise, Ain't No Mo', 1776, and more.