Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

BWW TV EXCLUSIVE: BWW NYC Cabaret Awards Show Highlights - Marilyn Maye, Ben Vereen, Jim Caruso and More!

The first-ever New York Cabaret Awards show was held at a jam-packed Metropolitan Room on Thursday, February 21. The evening featured a star-studded lineup, including performing legends Marilyn Maye and Ben Vereen, and cabaret stars Jim Caruso, Billy Stritch, KT Sullivan, Karen Kohler, Colleen McHugh, Jane Monheit, and more. These entertainers and many others became award-winners after almost two months of voting and the casting of an astounding 10,000 votes over 20 categories on the Cabaret section of the website.

Watch BroadwayWorld's exclusive highlights from the awards show below!

The 2012 New York Cabaret Awards Show was hosted by's lead Cabaret Reviewer/Columnist Stephen Hanks, with Musical Director Bill Zeffiro, who this year was a Award nominee for "Best Musical Director" and for his original song "My Kind of Guy" (written for "Best Female Vocalist" nominee Marissa Mulder's show Illusions). Hanks and Zeffiro opened the high-energy show by channeling Peter Allen and Harry Connick, Jr. on Allen's "When I Get My Name in Lights." Later in the show, Hanks had the Metropolitan Room audience in stitches with his cabaret parody song to the tune of "Trouble" from The Music Man.

Vereen was awarded "Best Male Celebrity Vocalist" for his 54 Below show Steppin' Out, and closed the awards show with a stirring rendition of "The Impossible Dream." Maye won for "Best Performance by a Duo/Group" for her show with Michael Feinstein, Swingin' The Night Away at Feinstein's, but Maye performed at the Awards show with Billy Stritch, who won as "Best Musical Director" for his show with Maye at the Metropolitan Room, By Request. Jane Monheit was the runaway winner for the Award as "Best Jazz Vocalist: Male or Female," while KT Sullivan and Karen Kohler took "Best Cabaret Show Revue" honors for their show at The Triad, Vienna to Weimar. Caruso and McHugh each won two Awards; Caruso as "Best Host of Variety Show/Recurring Series or Open Mic" for Cast Party at Birdland, while Cast Party, for which Caruso is the Producer, also won an Award for "Best Variety Show/Recurring Series/Open Mic." McHugh took the Awards as "Best Female Vocalist" mainly for her Calendar Girl shows at The Duplex, and for "Best CD Release (Solo, Duo or Group)" for her disc "Pret-A-Porter," based on the Cole Porter tribute show she performed at Birdland last year. New York Cabaret Award winners who also performed at the show at the Metropolitan Room included William Blake, "Best Male Vocalist" for his show Echoes of Etta: Tribute to Etta James at Birdland; Scott Evan Davis, who won "Best Original Song for a Cabaret Show" for the song "If We Say Goodbye" from his Don't Tell Mama show Cautiously Optimistic; Alison Nusbaum, the "Best Musical Comedy Performance" winner for her show Ladies! A Raucous Homage to Mel Brooks Broads at Don't Tell Mama; Steve Doyle, who won "Best Male Debut" for his CD release show Home to You at 54 Below, Stacie Perlman, who was voted as "Best Female Debut Show" for The Story Underneath at the Metropolitan Room, the clarinet and saxophone playing Will Anderson, who won "Best Instrumentalist (Non Piano)" honors, mainly for his work in Carole J. Bufford's show speak easy. at the Metropolitan Room; and Jackie Kristel, who represented "Best Director" Award-winner Collette Black, who guided Kristel's debut show A Girl You Should Know, at Don't Tell Mama.

Unable to attend due to other commitments were musical theater composer Brown won the Award as "Best Singer/Songwriter Show--Original Material" for his run at 54 Below, Betty Buckley, who took honors as "Best Celebrity Female Vocalist" for her show "The Other Woman," at Feinstein's (her award was accepted by the show's writer Eric Kornfeld), and Ann Hampton Callaway, who won both "Best Tribute Show" and "Show of the Year" for her The Streisand Songbook at 54 Below. William Blake accepted Callaway's awards by singing a thank you parody song to the tune of "Don't Rain On My Parade"--sent by Callaway--which brought down the house.

Click Here to Play the Video!play

Related Stories
American Conservatory Theater Sets 2023/24 Season Photo
American Conservatory Theater (A.C.T.) has announced the productions that will make up the company’s 2023/24 season. See the lineup, and learn how to purchase tickets!

Cast & Creatives Set for MURDER ON THE ORIENT EXPRESS at Paper Mill Photo
Paper Mill Playhouse has announced the cast and creative team for Agatha Christie’s Murder on the Orient Express by Ken Ludwig, directed by Casey Hushion. See performance dates and learn how to purchase tickets!

Broadway Grosses: Week Ending 3/19/23 Photo
Grosses for all the Broadway shows for the week ending 3/19/2023.

Anne Hathaway & Michaela Coel to Lead MOTHER MARY Pop Music Film Photo
Anne Hathaway and Michaela Coel will star in a new pop music film from A24. The film will feature new original music by Jack Antonoff and Charli XCX, accompanied by a score from Daniel Hart. The film is described as an 'epic pop melodrama' that follows the relationship between a fictional musician (Hathaway) and an iconic fashion designer (Coel). 

From This Author - BroadwayWorld TV

Exclusive: Samantha Pauly Channels Her Inner Ariana to Sing 'God Is a Woman'Exclusive: Samantha Pauly Channels Her Inner Ariana to Sing 'God Is a Woman'
March 20, 2023

Samantha Pauly, from the original cast of SIX The Musical on Broadway, continues her monthly residency at Chelsea Table + Stage on March 27 and she is previewing her show for BroadwayWorld. Get a sneak peek with this video!

Video: Watch Jinkx Monsoon and Kristin Chenoweth Chat Queen to Queen at CHICAGOVideo: Watch Jinkx Monsoon and Kristin Chenoweth Chat Queen to Queen at CHICAGO
March 20, 2023

On Friday, March 17th, Chicago presented QUEEN TO QUEEN with Jinkx Monsoon & Kristin Chenoweth, a 'jazzy' post-show event at the Ambassador Theatre following the evening performance of Chicago, and BroadwayWorld was there to capture the event! Watch in this video!

Video: Watch HADESTOWN Celebrate 1000th Performance with Curtain Call SongVideo: Watch HADESTOWN Celebrate 1000th Performance with Curtain Call Song
March 20, 2023

Hadestown, the Tony® and Grammy Award®-winning Best Musical, celebrated both tomorrow’s first day of Spring and the beloved show recently achieving a milestone 1,000 performances at Broadway’s Walter Kerr Theatre (219 West 48th Street) with a surprise appearance by songwriter Anaïs Mitchell and director Rachel Chavkin. Watch the full video!

Video: Company of NEW YORK, NEW YORK Serenades John Kander for His 96th Birthday!Video: Company of NEW YORK, NEW YORK Serenades John Kander for His 96th Birthday!
March 17, 2023

Watch Susan Stroman, Lin-Manuel Miranda, Colton Ryan, Anna Uzele and the cast and creative team of NEW YORK, NEW YORK surprise John Kander with a Big-Apple-sized rendition of “Happy Birthday'!

Video: First Look at DESCRIBE THE NIGHT at Steppenwolf TheatreVideo: First Look at DESCRIBE THE NIGHT at Steppenwolf Theatre
March 16, 2023

Get a first look at footage of the Chicago premiere of Describe the Night at Steppenwolf Theatre Company.