Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: New Light Theater Project's MEANINGFUL CONVERSATION is a Raw, Realistic Snapshot of New York Life

Sometimes you know exactly what to expect based on the synopsis of a play, and sometimes, after leaving the theatre, you got a lot more than you bargained for. With New Light Theater Project's Meaningful Conversation, I definitely received the latter.

Meaningful Conversation is a play in two acts, that explores the relationships between pairs of people when facing tricky situations. The life of the city of New York is breathed into the play, right down to the fire escapes and paper-thin walls. It is within the walls of one apartment in Astoria that the characters learn about themselves, and those around them.

The play takes place in the bedroom of David (Denver Milord), a twenty-something real estate agent. Walking into the theatre, we immediately are greeting with a home-like, comfortable feeling of a bedroom. I immediately felt like I was in my own apartment, and the energy welcomed audiences into David's world before the show even began.

Review: New Light Theater Project's MEANINGFUL CONVERSATION is a Raw, Realistic Snapshot of New York Life
Bethany Geraghty and Denver Milord

During the 2006 blackout, David is alone. Well, seemingly so, until his upstairs neighbor, a quirky young woman named Nat (Bethany Geraghty), descends the fire escape and surprises David at his window. He invites her inside and she convinces him to build a blanket fort within minutes. Watching David and Nat build a blanket fort on stage, from regular sheets, was fascinating. It created a new dimension to their world. I almost felt like a fly on the wall in a real bedroom, almost as if I was listening in on a conversation I wasn't meant to hear.

Review: New Light Theater Project's MEANINGFUL CONVERSATION is a Raw, Realistic Snapshot of New York Life
Bethany Geraghty and Denver Milord

Within their newly crafted fort, the pair get to talking, about everything from intimate details of their childhoods, to past relationships, to Nat's seemingly past-tense alcohol addiction. They engage in a rousing game of Spit, in real-time, making the atmosphere of the play that much more realistic.

At one point, the pair hears a couple fighting outside and Nat takes matters into her own hands, threatening the man if he continues to bother the woman. She is clearly shaken by the encounter and makes David promise to call the police if he ever hears or sees a domestic dispute.

Nat prompts David to do something spontaneous and out-of-character, and, predictably, he kisses her. In the throes of passion, the pair knock down their fort and begin kissing more intensely, and eventually engaging in oral sex. Which, again, is so realistic it had the audience squirming.

Review: New Light Theater Project's MEANINGFUL CONVERSATION is a Raw, Realistic Snapshot of New York Life
Bethany Geraghty

Geraghty plays Nat as such a fun, bubbly, and carefree person, that she is instantly likeable. She immediately gets the audience on her side, despite her somewhat troubled past. We root for her. She gets David to open up, telling her that he always leaves people, right when they need him the most.

Act Two takes place two years in the future, and if I hadn't heard the person next to me read that from their program, I wouldn't have known. Despite the fact that David is clearly no longer in a blackout, and has a woman in his bed who was never mentioned in Act One, there is little evidence to indicate that it is the future.

Review: New Light Theater Project's MEANINGFUL CONVERSATION is a Raw, Realistic Snapshot of New York Life
Bertha Leal and Denver Milord

The woman in question is Lydia (Bertha Leal), a one night stand that David's best friend hooked him up with at the bar. The most unrealistic part of the play is just how comfortable the pair seem together despite having just met in a drunken encounter the night before. David tells Lydia all about the neighbors that he knows, including Nat, who he brushes off as someone with substance abuse who he's met once.

Lydia and David Are awoken by a couple in a neighboring apartment fighting. We hear snippets of their conversations when the actors press their ears to the wall. David calls the police, and we are instantly reminded that Nat told him to do so whenever he hears a couple fighting.

When the police show up and David goes downstairs to deal with them, Lydia is left alone in the room. We hear the familiar sound of footsteps on the fire escape, and Nat appears at the window. Despite her discomfort, Lydia invites inside an obviously intoxicated Nat, who proceeds to throw herself around the room and talk even more relentlessly than she did in Act One. When she alludes to what happened during the night she shared with David two years prior, Lydia gets uncomfortable and kicks her out, deciding to leave.

Review: New Light Theater Project's MEANINGFUL CONVERSATION is a Raw, Realistic Snapshot of New York Life
Bertha Leal and SJ Hannah

When David returns with the police, he convinces Lydia to stay until they get to the bottom of the issue. They are unable to determine where the fighting is coming from, but they hear Nat yelling upstairs and end up arresting her, saying that she assaulted them. Once they leave, David breaks down. Once again, he has let down a friend when they needed him the most.

The play ends with David deciding to try to bail Nat out, and Lydia leaving to go to her friend's house which is, conveniently, on the same block as the precinct. The pair leave together.

This is a play that I needed a night to sleep on before I could fully process what I had seen. The two acts, at first, seemed to be disconnected, aside from their shared characters. When Act One ended, I remember wondering where the play could possibly go because it felt complete at intermission. However, the second act is in place for David to redeem himself. I was happy to see him get that moment to contemplate doing the right thing, and ultimately go through with it.

Meaningful Conversation is raw and real. It depicts a snapshot of life like I've never seen on stage. It shows intimate relationships between pairs of people, and how they react differently to situations. By the end of the play, I felt like I had made new friends in these characters. I'd climb down my fire escape to hang out with them any day.

Photo Credit: Hunter Canning

TodayTix Black Friday

Related Stories
Actress and Fame Singer Irene Cara Passes Away at 63 Photo
According to a post on her official Twitter account, Broadway and film actress Irene Cara, who played the role of Coco Hernandez in the movie FAME, has passed away at age 63 in her home in Florida. The cause of death has not yet been released.

Tickets for BOB FOSSES DANCIN On Broadway Go On Sale November 27 Photo
Bob Fosse's DANCIN', the American show business legend's landmark musical tribute to the artform that defined his life, will return to Broadway 41 years after the original smash-hit production took its final bow. Bob Fosse's DANCIN' will begin previews at The Music Box Theatre on Thursday, March 2, 2023, with opening night set for Sunday, March 19, 2023.

Video: Hugh Jackman Returns to THE MUSIC MAN Today Photo
Watch a video of Hugh Jackman, as he returns to The Music Man at the Winter Garden Theatre!

Ben Platt and Noah Galvin Announce Engagement Photo
Ben Platt and Noah Galvin have announced their engagement! Platt and Galvin became a couple after Platt stepped down as 'Evan Hansen' in Dear Evan Hansen on Broadway and Galvin took over the role. The pair shared the news of their engagement on Instagram.


From This Author - Stephi Wild

Stephi serves as Managing Editor for BroadwayWorld, and has been a member of the team for over five years. Among many hats, she curates the daily "Wake Up With BWW" briefing,... (read more about this author)


Concert Review: ITZY Brings Charm and Charisma to New York City's Hulu Theater For Final North American Stop on the 'Checkmate' TourConcert Review: ITZY Brings Charm and Charisma to New York City's Hulu Theater For Final North American Stop on the 'Checkmate' Tour
November 14, 2022

Itzy wrapped the North American leg of their Checkmate World Tour in New York City at the Hulu Theater on November 13, where they were met with a sold-out theater brimming with over 5,000 MIDZYs. The five-member girl group under JYP Entertainment consists of Yeji, Lia, Ryujin, Chaeryeong, and Yuna, who all showed off their individual charms, as well as their solid group dynamic.

Words From The Wings: April Matthis of THE PIANO LESSON Shares Her Backstage RoutineWords From The Wings: April Matthis of THE PIANO LESSON Shares Her Backstage Routine
November 4, 2022

We're chatting with April Matthis of The Piano Lesson! She told us all about her backstage routine, must-haves, and more!

Take A Look Back at Gabriel Byrne's Journey on BroadwayTake A Look Back at Gabriel Byrne's Journey on Broadway
October 28, 2022

Internationally renowned actor and writer Gabriel Byrne has returned to Broadway in his acclaimed solo show, Walking with Ghosts, adapted from his best-selling memoir of the same name. Learn more about Byrne's journey on Broadway by taking a walk down memory lane through his past credits!

Words From The Wings: Shawna Hamic of 1776 Talks Pre-Show Rituals, Backstage Must-Haves, and More!Words From The Wings: Shawna Hamic of 1776 Talks Pre-Show Rituals, Backstage Must-Haves, and More!
October 27, 2022

BroadwayWorld is bringing you Words From the Wings, a new series of interviews that take fans behind the scenes of some of their favorite Broadway stars' backstage routines! Today we're chatting with Shawna Hamic who plays “Richard Henry Lee” in 1776! She told us all about her pre-show rituals, backstage must-haves, and more!

Concert Review: THE ROSE Brings K-Rock to Terminal 5Concert Review: THE ROSE Brings K-Rock to Terminal 5
October 20, 2022

The Rose, the four-piece Korean rock band consisting of Woosung, Dojoon, Jaehyeong, and Hajoon, are embarking on their first tour as a group since returning from their mandatory military service in South Korea.