Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: BEAUTIFUL: THE CAROL KING MUSICAL at Olney Theatre Center

A sparkling Summer blockbuster starring Natalie Weiss

By:
Review: BEAUTIFUL: THE CAROL KING MUSICAL at Olney Theatre Center

Beautiful: The Carole King Musical has the look and feel - and certainly the sound - of a summer blockbuster for Olney Theatre Center, running now through August 25th.

Review: BEAUTIFUL: THE CAROL KING MUSICAL at Olney Theatre Center Image
Natalie Weiss as Carole King and Michael Perrie Jr.
as Gerry Goffin in Beautiful: The Carole King Musical
at Olney Theatre Center.
Photo: Teresa Castracane Photography

Beautiful tells the story Carole King and Gerry Goffin, of one of the greatest songwriting duos in pop music history, tracking their collaboration (and marriage) from the late 1950's through King's emergence as a solo superstar in the early 1970's. Highlighting the friendly rivalry between King and Goffin and fellow songwriters Barry Mann and Cynthia Weil, the show features a cavalcade of the biggest hits of the golden age of Rock and Roll. Along the way, Douglas McGrath's book interweaves many of the standard elements of a jukebox musical - teen pregnancy, artistic differences, mental breakdowns and marital infidelity among them. Fortunately, Beautiful is heavy on the oldies, with just enough behind-the-scenes drama to make it a robust and compelling musical.

And what a musical it is! Musical director Christopher Youstra leads a tight, 10-piece orchestra backing a cast that features superb singers, from top to bottom. From the moment Natalie Weiss (King) takes the stage to sing So Far Away, it's a buffet of stellar renditions of classic hits like Take Good Care of My Baby, Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow, Up On the Roof, The Loco-Motion, It's Too Late, and You've Got a Friend - all perfectly executed by this talented ensemble.

Review: BEAUTIFUL: THE CAROL KING MUSICAL at Olney Theatre Center Image
Calvin McCullough as Barry Mann and Nikki Mirza
as Cynthia Weil in Beautiful: The Carole King
Musical
at Olney Theatre Center.
Photo: Teresa Castracane Photography

Standout performances abound. Donna Migliaccio (Genie Klein) brings just the right touch as King's prototypical New York Jewish mother, without ever going over the top. She has a wry, dry delivery that provides both comic relief and some of the show's most poignant moments. Michael Perrie Jr (Gerry Goffin) foreshadows the tortured artist personality that will eventually lead to Goffin's mental breakdown, along with the serial infidelity that ultimately results in King divorcing him. Nikki Mirza (Cynthia Weil) brings a sparkling energy to every scene, and her chemistry with Calvin McCullough (Barry Mann) across the arc of the story is genuine and believable. Bobby Smith (legendary producer Don Kirshner) is by turns gruff and business like, but with a soft spot in his heart for the young songwriters in his employ.

The creative and technical elements perfectly compliment the talent on stage. Director Amy Anders Corcoran moves the actors smoothly around on the minimalist set designed by Debra Kim Sivigny. Kendra Rai's costume are period perfect - the matching outfits for the Motown vocal groups are appropriately sophisticated and flashy, and the everyday fashions are spot on. Lighting Design by Colin K. Bills flows seamlessly between the performance segments and the office/home scenes, and the sound design (by Matthew Rowe) and execution were flawless - every note of music and line of dialogue was crisp and clear.

A show this polished on opening night is only going to get better as the run goes on, and it is sure to sell very well. Make plans now to spend an evening humming along to some of the greatest rock and roll songs ever written, before this stunning show closes. It's a wonderful trip down memory lane for boomers, and a great introduction to classic oldies for everyone else.

Beautiful: The Carol King Musical runs through August 25th, and is suitable for audiences of all ages. Running time is 2:35, with one intermission. For more information about Olney Theatre Center, click here.

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on Olney Theatre Center
Upcoming Shows
A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder
A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder
7/2 - 8/23/2026
Recent Articles
Review: A GENTLEMAN'S GUIDE TO LOVE AND MURDER at Olney Theatre Center
Review: A GENTLEMAN'S GUIDE TO LOVE AND MURDER at Olney Theatre Center
7/7/2026
Review: PLEASE UNDERESTIMATE ME at Olney Theatre Center
Review: PLEASE UNDERESTIMATE ME at Olney Theatre Center
6/15/2026

Reader Reviews

Need more Washington, DC Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...

Local Shows
Misery in Washington, DC Misery
Aldie Mill Historic Park (8/20-8/30)
Ford''s Theatre presents: Come From Away in Washington, DC Ford''s Theatre presents: Come From Away
Ford's Theatre (9/10-10/18)
Murder at the Mansion presents "Funeral for a Gangster" in Washington, DC Murder at the Mansion presents "Funeral for a Gangster"
Glenview Mansion (11/06-11/08)
Gershwin, Bernstein & American Mosaic in Washington, DC Gershwin, Bernstein & American Mosaic
Wolf Trap (8/15-8/15)
Mamma Mia! in Washington, DC Mamma Mia!
National Theatre (10/27-11/15)
Hamlet in Washington, DC Hamlet
Folger Shakespeare Library (3/02-4/11)
The Jersey Four A Tribute to Frankie Valli and The 4 Seasons, featuring original member Gerry Polci in Washington, DC The Jersey Four A Tribute to Frankie Valli and The 4 Seasons, featuring original member Gerry Polci
F. Scott Fitzgerald Theatre (9/13-9/13)
The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show in Washington, DC The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show
The Dinner Detective Washington DC (9/26-9/26)
Body Language in Washington, DC Body Language
The Allan Lefcowitz Theater at The Writer's Center (9/25-9/27) PHOTOS
Josh Groban in Washington, DC Josh Groban
Wolf Trap (8/22-8/22)

BroadwayWorld TV