My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
Home philadelphia For You Chat My Shows (beta) Register/Login Games Grosses

They say that falling in love is wonderful... and doesn't Broadway know it! Valentine's Day is here and love is all around us. At this most romantic time of the year, we can't help but wonder... what is the greatest Broadway love song ever? 

BroadwayWorld continues our great tradition of finding that consensus- and this year we have more answers than ever! We've gathered responses from over 1500 performers, composers, industry professionals, and entertainment personalities from all over the world.

Category:
Photo
Performer
On the Town | The Addams Family | Xanadu | Hairspray
I think it’s called “Make Believe” from Show Boat. Its just pretty.
Photo
Performer
The Notebook | In The Heights | The Full Monty | Beauty and the Beast | West Side Story Tour
I am currently obsessed with "Say it Somehow" from The Light in the Piazza. A perfect use of the old musical theater rule... "when words can no longer express..." Clara and Fabrizio's love scene is romantic and emotional despite the language barrier between them. The way the voices find each other in the music without lyrics is sexy, haunting and just beautiful.
Photo
Performer
Into the Woods | Waitress | Hello Dolly! | She Loves Me | The Book of Mormon | Hair | Thoroughly Modern Millie
"Something Wonderful." That lyric is about love, but it's an adult love. It's more complicated. It's not always smooth, and he doesn't always say what you want. It's hard, and he doesn't behave, but I know him and I know his soul and I know he's wonderful. That's my choice right now. When I was younger, it was all idealism and romance, but I'm a realist now!
Photo
Performer
The Ferryman | Torch Song | Marvin's Room
My favorite Broadway love song is “Bonnie” from Bonnie and Clyde The Musical. Bonnie and Clyde has a sound track that is just brilliant but that song particularly has always stuck with me. It’s a song that is short and very simple, but it’s so grounded and caring. It reminds me of a song that you’re average person would sit down and write for their own love and sing to them to express how much they adore the other one. It’s just incredibly honest.
Photo
Performer
The Notebook
My favorite Broadway love song is "Dulcinea" from Man of La Mancha. Music by Mitch Leigh, lyrics, by Joe Darion. One of the most beautiful pairings of music and lyrics that I have ever heard in a Broadway musical.
Photo
Performer
Les Miserables | The Book of Mormon | All Shook Up
'One Hand, One Heart' from West Side Story
Photo
Performer
The Band's Visit | Fiddler on the Roof | Avenue Q | Rent | The Last Five Years
There are too many to name. I've had the good fortune of singing some great ones like "Next Ten Minutes" from Last Five Years or "Perfect For You" from Next to Normal, and of course, "Miracle of Miracles" from Fiddler on the Roof. Happy V-Day X
Photo
Performer
Harmony | Music & Passion | Copacabana
"My Heart Is So Full Of You" by Frank Loesser from the musical THE MOST HAPPY FELLA.
Photo
Performer
Gypsy | Dames at Sea | Matilda
I love "Can’t Take My Eyes Off You" by The Four Seasons, which is of course in Jersey Boys. Look, I'm not saying someone has to hire an entire horn section to tell me that they love me, but it would help.
Photo
Performer
The Present
"This Nearly Was Mine," South Pacific. That optimistic flush of post-war America, a world of feisty-but-adorable sopranos and dashing Italian baritones, in the midst of impossibly lush tropical locations… Aah.
Photo
Performer
The Wizard of Oz | The Woman in White | Dance of the Vampires | The Phantom of the Opera | Barnum | Billy | Flowers for Algernon
I think "If I Loved You" from CAROUSEL is the most perfectly written love song. The matching of the lyric to the melody is sublime.
Photo
Performer
Recording and Concert Superstar
"Stranger in Paradise" from KISMET. It's just glorious.
Photo
Performer
Glee
"The Word of Your Body" from SPRING AWAKENING, and not just because I know the people who sing it.
Photo
Performer
Kiss Me Kate | Holiday Inn | In The Heights | Disney's High School Musical
"What is it About Her" from THE WILD PARTY. It is a really triumphant song and his turmoil is so beautiful.
Photo
Performer
Grease | Xanadu | Grammy Award-Winning Recording Artist
"Some Enchanted Evening" from SOUTH PACIFIC
Photo
Performer
Newsies | Follies | Chicago | Teddy & Alice | Show Boat
This is a very difficult question, but "This Nearly Was Mine" from South Pacific means a lot to me and my wife.
Photo
Performer
GLEE
"All I Ask of You" from PHANTOM OF THE OPERA.
Photo
Performer
Wicked | How to Succeed in Business | A Chorus Line | Promises | Promises | Company | On the Town | Can-Can | Annie Get Your Gun | State Fair | Follies | Babes in Arms
I thought this would be easy...it's not. Did I say "If Ever I Would Leave You" last time? "Always"? "My Heart is So Full of You"? "Some Enchanted Evening"? See what I mean? I should be more modern but I always think of the older shows. OK...I've just re-discovered "So Many People" from Saturday Night. So that's the one.
Photo
Performer
Jekyll & Hyde; Recording Artist & Concert Star
'On the Street Where You Live' from My Fair Lady
Photo
Performer
Titanique | Wicked | Hair
'As Long as You're Mine' because well.......duh!
Photo
Performer
Legendary Composer/Lyricist
"Something Wonderful" from THE KING AND I.
Photo
Performer
Disaster! | Memphis | Aida | Cabaret | Rent
"Anthem" form Chess. Not your typical boy/girl love song but rather a love song between a man and his country.
Photo
Performer
Saint Joan | A Doll's House Part 2 | Romeo and Juliet | The Trip to Bountiful | Stick Fly
It's not really a love song, but "Anyone Can Whistle." It's just such a touching song. I don't know, everytime I hear it I just well up. It's just a moving, tender, touching song.
Photo
Performer
Six Dance Lessons in Six Weeks | Follies | Cabaret | Love Letters | First Impressions | Champagne Complex | John Murray Anderson's Almanac. Commander In Chief. The Sopranos
"Something Wonderful" from THE KING AND I. I've always loved it, but I've never sung it.
Photo
Performer
New York | New York | Wonderland | In the Heights
"Dammit Janet" from THE ROCKY HORROR SHOW
Photo
Performer
Heartbreak House | Frozen | The Herbal Bed | The Real Thing
I've got two actually..."Somewhere" from WEST SIDE STORY and "Till There Was You" from THE MUSIC MAN.
Photo
Performer
Priscilla Queen of the Desert | La Cage Aux Folles | A Chorus Line
'Till There Was You' from The Music Man
Photo
Performer
Romeo and Juliet
That's a tricky one. My favorite Broadway love song... "Losing My Mind," I think. All of his music was so beautiful.
Photo
Performer
Bullets Over Broadway | Curtains | Contact | Steel Pier
I always get choked up on "If I Loved You" by Rodgers and Hammerstein. It's kind of a bittersweet love song, but it's one of my favorites.
Photo
Performer
The Wiz | Maggie Flynn
"Sarah Brown Eyes" from RAGTIME.

Videos