My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
Home For You Chat My Shows (beta) Register/Login Games Grosses

Matthew Wexler

46 reviews on BroadwayWorld  •  Average score: 6.89/10 Thumbs Sideways

Reviews by Matthew Wexler

Chinese Republicans Off-Broadway
5
Thumbs Sideways

‘Chinese Republicans’ bickers brilliantly. Until it doesn’t.

From: 1 Minute Critic  |  Date: 2/27/2026

But the “Republican” part of Chinese Republicans feels shoehorned into its structure, with references from Roosevelt to Reagan. And stylistically, when the action moves to a storage room to prep for a company-wide event, the slapstick physical comedy undermines the world that Lin has created. When Chinese Republicans trusts its characters, it’s electric. When it doesn’t, even the Louboutins can’t carry it.

The Unknown Off-Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

Sean Hayes turns the psychological thriller inside out in ‘The Unknown’

From: 1 Minute Critic  |  Date: 2/13/2026

At a brisk 75 minutes, Hayes remains captivating, even if Cale’s play meanders a bit in the brothers’ backstory, and plot points, such as a stolen set of apartment keys, feel lifted from an episode of Law & Order. But no matter. By the time the curtain closes, you won’t be sure who’s been writing the story all along. And that’s precisely the point.

Ulysses Off-Broadway
6
Thumbs Sideways

Review: ‘Ulysses’ compresses one day into a dense, demanding adaptation

From: 1 Minute Critic  |  Date: 1/26/2026

Ulysses—on the page or stage—isn’t for the intellectually fatigued or those not well-caffeinated. Compacted into a brisk two hours and forty minutes, co-directors John Collins and Scott Shepherd and their creative team employ a bevy of props, projections, and screeching sound cues (courtesy of Ben Williams) to indicate the passage of time. Recurring themes ranging from anti-Semitism and nationalism to repressed sexuality appear throughout Joyce’s text. The seven-person ensemble undertakes dozens of roles, and while plenty of captivating moments surface, the whole fails to be greater than the sum of the parts.

An Ark Off-Broadway
4
Thumbs Sideways

Heaven can wait: Ian McKellen elevates ‘An Ark,’ but mixed reality can’t bridge the digital divide

From: One-Minute Critic  |  Date: 1/23/2026

Director Sarah Krankcom attempts to wrangle a more intimate, humanistic approach, with varying success. McKellen’s vast film experience pays off, as does Golda Rosheuvel’s (Bridgerton), both understanding that this is, essentially, film work. But as for being a piece of theater, An Ark is lost at sea.

Bug Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

Review: Carrie Coon and Namir Smallwood scratch more than an itch in Tracy Letts’ ‘Bug’

From: One-Minute Critic  |  Date: 1/8/2026

Director David Cromer (Dead Outlaw, Meet the Cartozians) keeps the play’s focus tight and the performances brisk within the confines of scenic designer Takeshi Kata’s oppressive motel room-turned bunker. But it’s Coon and Smallwood’s performances that make us question how far we’ll go to not feel alone, regardless of the outcome.

Tartuffe (Hnath) Off-Broadway
7
Thumbs Sideways

Matthew Broderick’s ‘Tartuffe’: The gentleman con and how to spot him

From: One-Minute Critic  |  Date: 12/16/2025

Broderick, last seen on Broadway opposite his wife, Sarah Jessica Parker, in Plaza Suite, allows the madness to unfold around him gently. It’s a generous performance that speaks to Hnath’s take. “Cheaters are also easily cheated,” Elmire says as she prepares to trap the imposter, “because they assume they’re the only ones cheating.” We can only hope.

Anna Christie Off-Broadway
6
Thumbs Sideways

Michelle Williams navigates a problematic classic in ‘Anna Christie’ at St. Ann’s Warehouse

From: 1 Minute Critic  |  Date: 12/14/2025

Williams hovers on the crest of these shifting social tides with nearly too much expertise, delivering a polish to Anna’s emotional navigation that outshines her father, who blames all of life’s woes on the sea, and a verbally stunted lover-to-be, who brands her a slut when learning of her past.

Marjorie Prime Broadway
9
Thumbs Up

June Squibb in ‘Marjorie Prime’ asks if AI can ease grief or just complicate it

From: One-Minute Critic  |  Date: 12/8/2025

June Squibb and a superb company turn Marjorie Prime into an acting masterclass about mortality, memory, and why we love.

8
Thumbs Up

‘Gotta Dance!’ proves Broadway’s best choreography lives on

From: 1 Minute Critic  |  Date: 12/4/2025

Still, Gotta Dance! lives up to its name, featuring a seven-piece band, live vocals, and an exacting attention to detail, thanks to stagers like Baayork Lee, Stephanie Pope, and Donna McKechnie, who are passing along the legacy to the next generation of dancers.

3
Thumbs Down

‘Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)’ delivers more crumbs than confection

From: One-Minute Critic  |  Date: 11/20/2025

Some may find Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) a pleasant enough holiday confection, but as Robin says to Dougal to squelch his movie fantasy of NYC, “You know how much it costs to go for dinner in midtown Manhattan? To see a Broadway show? New York is just money, that’s all it is.” Consider, instead, seeking out one of the best cake slices in New York City and calling it a night.

This World of Tomorrow Off-Broadway
4
Thumbs Sideways

Tom Hanks’ time travel romance gets stuck idling at The Shed

From: One-Minute Critic  |  Date: 11/18/2025

Director Kenny Leon, who has recently had a string of Broadway hits, pulls out all the stops to keep this time-traveling misfire in the right galaxy. Even with brisk pacing and seamless scenic and projection design by Derek McLane, the play spins out of orbit, unable to connect its multiverse themes with the intimate relationship at its core.

9
Thumbs Up

‘Spelling Bee’ revival spells it out: J-O-Y

From: One-Minute Critic  |  Date: 11/17/2025

Twenty years later, this charming Off-Broadway revival proves Spelling Bee‘s blend of silly wordplay and surprising heart remains unbeatable.

Chess Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

‘Chess’ returns to Broadway with a Cold War that feels white hot

From: 1 Minute Critic  |  Date: 11/16/2025

Pinkham, along with a deliciously dry performance by Sean Allan Krill as CIA agent Walter de Courcey, balances the above-the-title star power, including Aaron Tveit as clinically depressed and bipolar US chess champion Freddie Trumper, his coach/lover Florence Vassy (Lea Michele), and their Soviet opponent Anatoly Sergievsky (Nicholas Christopher). Christopher, joined by an electric Hannah Cruz as his estranged Russian wife Svetlana in Act II, leans into Michael Mayer’s direction with the highest stakes, navigating the political and personal with the kind of urgency that kept us glued to The Americans for six seasons.

Archduke Off-Broadway
6
Thumbs Sideways

Patrick Page commands ‘Archduke’ as history’s most persuasive assassin

From: 1 Minute Critic  |  Date: 11/13/2025

For some, the historical details may be a bit dense to follow, despite Joseph’s succinct writing and Page’s clarion delivery. In contrast, Berne, Roulette, and Sanchez, as the three sickly recruits, never quite reach the stylistic ease of their more seasoned counterparts. 6

4
Thumbs Sideways

‘The Queen of Versailles’: Even Kristin Chenoweth can’t save this Broadway house of cards

From: 1 Minute Critic  |  Date: 11/10/2025

Even Kristin Chenoweth’s desperate charm can’t salvage this cringy musical about building America’s largest home—a Broadway construction site that never finds its foundation.

Queens Off-Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

Martyna Majok’s ‘Queens’: Where a basement becomes urgent refuge for immigrant women

From: One-Minute Critic  |  Date: 11/5/2025

Knockout performances across the board get to the heart of Majok’s play with little pity but plenty of humor. If the moments of magical realness feel less than inspired on Marsha Ginsberg’s bifurcated set with billowing curtains to indicate the passage of time, this found sisterhood has plenty in its tank to fuel the evening. References to 9/11 and Trump’s first presidential term ocassionally feel forced, though the spiraling xenophobia creates a chilling backdrop for the women’s intersecting lives.

Bat Boy Off-Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

Can a tabloid legend soar onstage? Taylor Trensch makes ‘Bat Boy’ believe it can

From: One-Minute Critic  |  Date: 11/4/2025

Scenic designer David Korins (Ragtime) amps up the production value, and a rousing supporting cast, including Andrew Durrand (Dead Outlaw) and Alex Newell as The God Pan, helps Bat Boy take flight, even when its wacky plot threatens to strand you in a dark cave without a flashlight.

9
Thumbs Up

Samuel D. Hunter’s ‘Little Bear Ridge Road’ proves real people aren’t always desperately doing things

From: One-Minute Critic  |  Date: 10/30/2025

Little Bear Ridge Road’s melancholy softens with the introduction of graduate student James (John Drea), a potential hookup that evolves into dating despite Ethan’s curmudgeonly exterior. The unlikely threesome overlaps like a Venn diagram, its central point illuminated in the awkward, everyday language of people just trying to survive and communicate the best way they know how..

Ragtime Broadway
9
Thumbs Up

‘Ragtime’ returns to Broadway with undeniable urgency and uncomfortable truths

From: One-Minute Critic  |  Date: 10/16/2025

Ragtime, one of the great musical theater scores of the late 20th century, steps up to bat on Broadway in its third major production. And if some of its design elements feel sparse in Lincoln Center Theater’s 1,050-seat Vivian Beaumont, its glorious cast of 34 and “the music of something beginning” land with a visceral impact that marks a uniquely American art form.

Caroline Off-Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

Chloë Grace Moretz navigates tough love as a recovering addict in ‘Caroline’

From: One-Minute Critic  |  Date: 9/30/2025

Director David Cromer (Good Night, and Good Luck; Prayer for the French Republic) has a knack for extracting a kind of distilled specificity from his actors, and this trifecta rises to the occasion. Though a bit slowly paced in a preview performance I attended, the production has already been extended twice, perhaps driven by Moretz’s 23.8 million Instagram followers.

Twelfth Night Off-Broadway
9
Thumbs Up

Free Shakespeare in the Park roars back to life with Lupita Nyong’o & Sandra Oh in a dazzling ‘Twelfth Night’

From: One-Minute Critic  |  Date: 8/21/2025

A triumphant gender-defying curtain call, costumed in glorious technicolor by Oana Botez, further challenges the recent assault on creative expression and the arts, demonstrating that joy is an act of resistance. And there’s nothing more joyful than the return of Shakespeare in the Park.

5
Thumbs Sideways

Roastmaster Jeff Ross offers a sentimental simmer in his Broadway debut

From: One-Minute Critic  |  Date: 8/18/2025

The show’s title pays tribute to Ross’s late grandfather, Pop Jack, who said, “You never know what’s going to happen…” An apt saying, which comes to fruition when Ross works the audience during the evening’s final moments. But this banana is more of a snack than a feast, leaving audiences hungry for the full-course roasting they likely came for.

8
Thumbs Up

Elizabeth McGovern peels back the glamour in ‘Ava: The Secret Conversations’

From: 1 Minute Critic  |  Date: 8/8/2025

McGovern acutely embodies Gardner’s magnetism and toxicity. Foul-mouthed and flirty in her youth, frail and ferocious in later years, the Oscar-nominated actress (both subject and star) is a force to be reckoned with.

Heathers: The Musical Off-Broadway
6
Thumbs Sideways

“What’s your damage, Heather?” More than you think, even as a musical

From: One-Minute Critic  |  Date: 7/11/2025

Heathers 2.0 isn’t so much a reimagining as a high-polish paint job. But this is no “Greased Lightning.” While Grease depicted late-50s nostalgia and the kind of gang warfare that didn’t escalate much beyond chewing gum on the underside of a desk, Heathers‘ Gen X timestamp goes for the jugular, with a triple homicide, fat jokes, fag jokes, a potential date rape and an attempted suicide. Meanwhile, an audience dotted with Gen Zers dressed like the three popular Heathers (a powerhouse trifecta of McKenzie Kurtz, Olivia Hardy, and Elizabeth Teeter), squealed at decibel-shattering levels, equally mesmerized by Lorna Courtney (& Juliet) as Veronica and Casey Likes (Back to the Future) as J.D.

Call Me Izzy Broadway
7
Thumbs Sideways

Jean Smart trades stand-up for stanzas in Broadway’s ‘Call Me Izzy’

From: 1 Minute Critic  |  Date: 6/13/2025

Smart’s performance lives up to her name: measured and nuanced, both vulnerable and full of rage, depending on which of the handful of characters she’s inhabiting. Her adjustments, under the direction of Sarna Lapine, shift seamlessly from one to the next. Perhaps it’s the clipped cadence of friend Rosalie, or a broadening of the shoulders as she embodies Izzy’s menacing husband. Smart pulls us into the conversation—not an easy task in a 1,000-seat theatre.

Videos