Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
The Sister I Never Had show poster

"The Sister I Never Had" at Producers Club

Dates: 10/3/2026 - 10/4/2026

📍 Theatre: Producers Club

Genoveva Productions
New York
New York City, NY 10036

Phone: N/A

Tickets: $20


Share

Genoveva Productions Presents:

"The Sister I Never Had" - A New Play written and directed by Julia Genoveva

Featuring a cast that includes Shannon Bell, Dawn Marcelliano, Mariah Muehler, and Gustavo "Gus* Ferrari

Sat, 10/3 @4pm AND Sun, 10/4 @4pm

Producers Club - Prince Theater - 358 W 44th Street, NYC 10036

One short flight of stairs. No Elevator.

"The Sister I Never Had", is a new drama that will premiere at The Producers Club in the beginning of October for two performances. This is a play that centers around the turbulent relationship between Deborah and Sophia. Two sisters that have each built somewhat happy lives without knowing each other existed. However, everything changes when their mother Rachel passes away, and her last wish is for Deborah to find her sister. Deborah, who would do anything for her mother, even though she was never the best mother in the world, immediately starts her search to find Sophia. But their explosive meeting exposes many secrets about Rachel, and these sisters cannot seem to give their relationship a new beginning.

Unfortunately, Sophia rejects Deborah 's affection and kindness as she still harbors alot of pain from Rachel's abandonment when she was growing up. As things go from bad to worse, Deborah's daughter, Melissa who loves and idolizes her mother dearly, worries that this is all taking a toll on Deborah's health and takes a stand that they must stay away from each other. Meanwhile, Sophia's loving husband Tom, is a calming, and growing force that advises Sophia to allow the situation to take it's natural course, and not let her emotions get the best of her. But are all these efforts enough to bring harmony back into their lives? This play begs the question: Can these two sisters ever come together, or should they have never met in the first place?

About Julia Genoveva (Playwright/Producer/Director) Julia Genoveva has been in the entertainment industry for nearly over two decades. Born in Ecuador and raised in the Bronx, she transitioned from studying at The Fashion Institute of Technology to pursuing a career in acting, writing, producing, and directing. In 2009, she founded Genoveva Productions with the mission to produce compelling original, classical and contemporary plays that will make a lasting impact on our audiences. Julia has had several of her plays produced in various festivals: The Secret Theatre Festival, SPF: Boo!, Lav2025, NYC2025 (Which runs at The Players Theatre), Summer/Winter NY Festival (Hudson Guild Theatre). Recently, Julia wrote the short, father and daughter drama "Esteban" which was directed by her long time friend/collaborator KM Jones and was part of the Summer One-Act Festival in the Secret Theatre. Julia continues to provide a safe, encouraging, and fun environment for playwrights and actors to come together and create. Genoveva Productions is dedicated to Julia's late Grandfather, renowned Chilean filmmaker Sigifredo Salas. He was a pioneer in contributing to bringing sound to moving pictures during the Golden Age of films in Latin America.

Cast and Creative Team for "The Sister I Never Had" at Producers Club

Cast

Voni Kengal
Voni Kengal
Lizzie Borden
Jessica Tidd
Jessica Tidd
Emma Borden
Tia Lempert
Tia Lempert
Alice Russell

Tia Lempert is an actor and classically trained soprano based in Portland with a Bachelor's in Music from Oregon State University. She has a background in musical theatre and opera and has been performing around the Portland area for many years. You may recognize her from NWCT’s Robin Hood (Maid Marian) and The Lightning Thief (Sally/Oracle), Stumptown Stage’s The Prom (Shelby) and Oliver (Bet), or Lakewood Center for the Arts' Groundhog Day (Joelle). Tia has competed in numerous national vocal competitions over the years, such as NATS and CS Music, and consistently receives high marks. She also teaches voice lessons and works for American Immersion Theatre as a birthday party princess. 

Tia is so excited to be a part of such a rockin’ show, acting alongside three other powerhouse women to tell this story. Follow along with her at tialempert.com or on instagram at @tialempertsoprano.

Ashley Moore
Bridget Sullivan

Creative Team

Director
Joshua Hegg
Music Director
Steven Hrubes and Kelsey Nisbett
Choreographers
Julianne Bodner
Set Designer
Laura Helgeson
Sam Kemp
Lighting Designer
Marcus Storey
Sound Design
Projection/Video Designer

News About "The Sister I Never Had" at Producers Club


We have no news on this show at the current time.

About the Theatre

Producers Club

New York
New York City, NY 10036

Phone: N/A

🌙 Make a Night of It

Loading nearby places…

Similar Shows Nearby

Producers Club Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ


Andrea McArdle's Broadway On Deman in Off-Off-Broadway Andrea McArdle's Broadway On Deman
The Laurie Beechman Theatre (10/10-10/10) PHOTOS
Broadway Magic Hour in Off-Off-Broadway Broadway Magic Hour
Broadway Magic Hour: Magic Show (7/25-1/02)
Dominant Animals in Off-Off-Broadway Dominant Animals
Teatro LATEA (10/02-10/04) PHOTOS VIDEOS
Eileen Barnett: Back Again...For The Very First Time! in Off-Off-Broadway Eileen Barnett: Back Again...For The Very First Time!
The Laurie Beechman Theatre (10/06-10/06)
From America, With Love in Off-Off-Broadway From America, With Love
28th Street Theatre (10/11-10/11)
PANGEA: UNLEASHED in Off-Off-Broadway PANGEA: UNLEASHED
KnJ Theater (10/10-10/11) PHOTOS
Peribáñez y el Comendador de Ocaña in Off-Off-Broadway Peribáñez y el Comendador de Ocaña
Teatro Círculo (9/18-10/04) VIDEOS
ShakesBEER in Off-Off-Broadway ShakesBEER
Prospect Bar and Grill (9/19-10/10)
Sophocles' Electra in Off-Off-Broadway Sophocles' Electra
Symphony Space (10/11-10/11) PHOTOS VIDEOS
Sparks! in Off-Off-Broadway Sparks!
Reverie Room (10/21-10/21)