RJ Higton (Dance Edition, Season 2) was recently seen in Boop! The Musical on Broadway. He made his Broadway debut in the original cast of The Outsiders. 

Jackson Kanawha Perry (Season 3) starred in the pre-Broadway premiere of The Karate Kid Musical. He is now starring in the Sia musical Saturday Church at New York Theatre Workshop.

Brandon J. Large (Season 2) is currently starring in The Great Gatsby on Broadway. He also appeared in the National Tours of The Prom and Aladdin.

Erin Morton (Season 5) is currently starring in the off-Broadway revival of Heathers as 'Martha Dunnstock'.

Hosea Mundi (Season 1) is currently in the national tour of Hamilton where he understudies Hamilton, Burr, Washington, and Lafayette/Jefferson.

Tori Vagasy (Season 3) was a semi-finalist on the 16th season of America's Got Talent.

Willem Butler (Season 1) played 'Dimitry' in the 2nd National Tour of Anastasia.

Tommy Kaiser (Season 3)  most recently appeared in the Rent 25th Anniversary Farewell Tour, where he played both 'Mark' and 'Roger.'

Kodiak Thompson (Season 3) recently starred in Drag: The Musical off-Broadway.

Paul Amrani (Dance Edition, Season 2) starred in the National Tour of Chicago.

Oluchi Nwaokorie (Season 2) is currently playing 'Angela' in the National Tour of Parade.

Haile Ferrier (Season 2) was the 'Zoe/Alana' understudy on the First National Tour of Dear Evan Hansen.

Nick Cortazzo (Season 2) was recently a swing in the First National Tour of Hadestown, He also played 'Link Larkin' in the Hairspray National Tour.

Jack Ducat (Season 1) will be playing the lead role of Buddy the Elf on the 2025 National Tour of Elf the Musical.