Review: THE SOUND INSIDE By Adam Rapp Directed by Stella Reid at Circa Theatre

The Sound Inside is a critically acclaimed play by Adam Rapp, first premiering on Broadway at Studio 54 in October 2019.

The play centers on Bella Baird, a reclusive and introspective creative writing professor at Yale, who is grappling with a recent cancer diagnosis. Her life takes a turn when she begins mentoring Christopher, a brilliant but enigmatic student. Their relationship evolves from a professional mentorship into a deeply personal and emotionally complex bond.

As they share their literary passions and personal stories, Bella makes a startling and morally ambiguous request of Christopher—one that tests the boundaries of their connection and the limits of what one person can ask of another.

Adam Rapp’s The Sound Inside is a masterclass in subtlety and emotional precision, and this latest iteration delivers it with remarkable finesse. The set design is deceptively simple yet incredibly clever—transforming seamlessly between the sterile world of academia and the intimate, shadowy corners of Bella Baird’s inner life. It is designed in small square areas and each portray an area integral to the play. One square is simply green with some white dusting and mimics being out in Central Park in winter, I almost felt the cold myself.The lighting design is equally masterful, using stark contrasts and soft glows to mirror the play’s shifting emotional tones and the characters’ psychological landscapes.

At times I felt the sound effects to be overwhelming and detracting from the whole experience, though overall it was successful.

At the heart of this production are two stellar performances. Dulcie Smart is mesmerizing as Bella Baird, a Yale professor whose quiet intellect masks a deep well of vulnerability. Her portrayal is layered and restrained, drawing the audience in with every measured word and glance. Opposite her, Kieran Charnock brings a magnetic intensity to the role of Christopher Dunn, a brilliant yet enigmatic student whose presence disrupts Bella’s carefully ordered world. Their chemistry is electric, and their scenes together crackle with tension, wit, and unspoken longing.