My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: MAMMA MIA Says Farewell at Saenger Theatre

By:
Say goodbye to Mamma Mia, because after this weekend, it's slipping through our fingers after all. (We'll see.) Grab your girlfriends, a glass of wine, and your platform shoes because you don't want to miss out on the fun of belting out your favorite hits like "Dancing Queen" and, of course, "Mamma Mia."

Walking into the theater last night, I was armed only with the experience of the film version. You know, the one where they tried to convince us that Pierce Brosnin could sing? So, I was prepared for the campy, cheesiness of this show. I knew the storyline, so I couldn't be disappointed by it. So really, I was there for the singing, the dancing, and the girl power.

In these elements, the show did not disappoint. While I felt the first few scenes were a little slow, once the familiar chords of "Mamma Mia" started, I was hooked. Betsy Padamonsky is dazzling as Donna Sheridan. She wears the overalls well and hits the power notes flawlessly. Cashelle Butler and Sarah Smith also stole the show as Donna's sidekicks, Tanya and Rosie. Their harmonies in "Chiquitita" were seamless and I couldn't stop laughing as they frolicked around the stage, reminiscent of Galinda during "Popular."

This is not a show that you attend for the storyline. If you're looking for a plot that makes sense, please skip out on this one. The premise is that Sophie Sheridan is getting married, but doesn't know who her father is. She invites her three potentials to the wedding - because weddings are not stressful enough - and the story unfolds from there. It's silly. It's messy. It's a lot of fun, all in all.

Other notable points of this show that I can't forget to mention are the dancing scenes. In particular, the "Voulez Vous" number is fantastic. I kept my attention on Betsy Padamonsky this entire scene, because she was just that impressive. I didn't laugh for much of this show, but when Sarah Smith performed "Take a Chance on Me," I couldn't help it. She has a Melissa McCarthy physical humor that is so fun to watch.

If you're in need of some girl time and are an ABBA fan, get to the Saenger before this show leaves. And also, stay until the end. You'll miss out if you don't!

Reader Reviews

To post a comment, you must register and login.

Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best Direction of a Musical - Top 3
1. Michael Arden - The Lost Boys
24.6% of votes
2. Michael Mayer - Chess
14.5% of votes
3. Lear deBessonet - Ragtime
11.8% of votes

Need more New Orleans Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...


Videos


The Lion King in New Orleans The Lion King
Saenger Theatre (10/21-11/08)
Hadestown: Teen Edition in New Orleans Hadestown: Teen Edition
Sullivan Theater (8/13-8/16)
Come From Away in New Orleans Come From Away
Jefferson Perf Arts Center (9/11-9/20)
Blithe Spirit in New Orleans Blithe Spirit
Sullivan Theater (9/25-10/04)
The Rocky Horror Picture Show in New Orleans The Rocky Horror Picture Show
Rivertown Theaters for the Performing Arts (10/23-10/31)
John Cameron Mitchell: Hedwig 25th Anniversary Movie Tour in New Orleans John Cameron Mitchell: Hedwig 25th Anniversary Movie Tour
Fillmore New Orleans (11/11-11/11)
The Marvelous Wonderettes in New Orleans The Marvelous Wonderettes
Westwego Perf Arts Theatre (1/08-1/24)
Hurricane Diane in New Orleans Hurricane Diane
Pallas Players Theatre Company (5/29-6/07)
A Mardi Gras Carol in New Orleans A Mardi Gras Carol
Westwego Perf Arts Theatre (12/04-12/13)
Finding Neverland in New Orleans Finding Neverland
Rivertown Theaters for the Performing Arts (9/11-9/27)