Bay Street Theater

Mister Halston

Jun 2 – Jun 21, 2026

Summer Season  June 2—June 21, 2026Mister HalstonSet against the glamorous and volatile worlds of 70s and 80s New York, Mister Halston explores the meteoric rise,...

Cagney - The Musical

Jun 30 – Jul 26, 2026

Cagney: The Musical explores James Cagney’s rise from vaudeville to Hollywood stardom, blending tap dance, music, and storytelling to reveal the man behind the legend.

Melissa Errico: The Streisand Effect | Bay Street Theater, Sag Harbor

Aug 17

Tony-nominated Broadway star and longtime Bay Street favorite Melissa Errico returns for Music Mondays with her acclaimed concert event, The Streisand Effect: Melissa Sings Barbra,...

Dear Evan Hansen

Aug 4 – Aug 29, 2026

 Bay Street reimagines the Tony Award-winning musical.Winner of six Tony Awards including Best Musical, Dear Evan Hansen is a powerful and deeply human story of high schoolers...

Bonkers in the Boroughs

Sep 1 – Sep 6, 2026

 Bonkers in the BoroughsWritten by Joy BeharBonkers in the Boroughs is a world premiere comedy comprised of five original short plays starring Joy Behar and friends....

Talk of The Town

May 23

Step into the glamour, ambition, and romance of 1920s New York in Talk of the Town, a new musical inspired by the true story behind the...

Ha Ha Hamptons Comedy Tour = Valentine's Edition

Feb 14

 Valentine’s Day Date Night, but Funnier Looking for a great Valentine’s Day plan? Treat your Valentine to a night of big laughs at Bay Street Theater.Join...

That Motown Band

Feb 8

THAT MOTOWN BANDHosted at Bay Street TheaterSunday, February 8, 2026 • 4:00 PMJoin us for a powerful afternoon of music and community as That Motown...

Radio Alanis

Feb 7

Experience an unforgettable night of live music in Sag Harbor when Radio Alanis, the premier Alanis Morissette tribute band, brings the iconic sound of the...

Fireside Sessions: Nancy Atlas with Jonny Rosch

Jan 31

Fireside Sessions: Nancy Atlas with Jonny RoschSoul Sonic Love January 31, 2026 • 8:00 PM Bay Street Theater – Sag Harbor Tickets availablehttps://www.baystreet.org/per.../nancy-atlas-ft-jonny-rosch/Bay Street TheaterGet ready for the...

Nancy Atlas with Randi Fishenfeld - Fireside Sessions

Jan 31 – Jan 24, 2026

Fireside Sessions January 24, 2026 8:00pmNancy Atlas with Randi FishenfeldRock and roll violinJoin Nancy Atlas and electrifying violinist Randi Fishenfeld for Week 3 of the...

Nancy Atlas with Brian Mitchell - Fireside Sessions

Jan 17

Fireside Sessions January 17, 2026 8:00pmNancy Atlas with Brian MitchellKeyboard, accordion and vocals for a night of New Orleans magicWeek two of the Fireside Sessions...

Nancy Atlas with Gene Casey and Eugene Chrysler A Country and Rockabilly Revue

Jan 10

Fireside Sessions January 10, 2026 8:00pmNancy Atlas with Gene Casey and Eugene ChryslerA Country and Rockabilly RevueNancy Atlas kicks off the 2026 Fireside Sessions with...

New Year’s LAUGHIN’ Eve ’25!

Dec 31

Laughin’ New Year’s Eve Tuesday, December 31 at 7 p.m. Ring in the new year with laughter! Bay Street’s Laughin’ New Year’s Eve Stand-Up Comedy

Christmas with Chris Ruggiero LIVE in East Islip, NY on December 21, 2025

Dec 21

PBS-TV star Chris Ruggiero returns with his new Christmas show, featuring fan favorites from his much-anticipated Christmas album—including “Sleigh Ride,” “Christmas (Baby Please Come Home),”...

Think You’re Funny? Graduation Show!

Nov 25

Comedy Series November 25, 2025 8:00pmThink You’re Funny? Graduation Show!Join us for the Think You’re Funny? Graduation Show! We’ve got a hilarious night of LIVE...

Ha Ha Hamptons Comedy Tour

Oct 25

Now in it’s third season, the HA HA Hamptons Comedy Tour has become a fan favorite on the east end!  Featuring an all-new lineup of...

The Joni Project - Celebrating the Music of Joni Mitchell

Oct 18

The Joni Project formed as a tribute in sound and spirit to Joni Mitchell, one of music’s greatest and most innovative artists.The band is fronted...

The Jackie Mason Musical

Sep 6 – Sep 7, 2025

Laughter takes center-stage in this story based on the 10 year whirlwind romance of legendary comedian Jackie Mason and the playwright of the show, featuring their...

Gilbert & Sullivan's 'HMS Pinafore'

Jun 21 – Jun 29, 2025

‘H.M.S. PINAFORE’ SAILS INTO LONG ISLAND  H.M.S. Pinafore, the classic comic opera that made Gilbert & Sullivan world famous almost 150 years ago, returns to Long Island...

SWEENEY TODD

Apr 26 – Apr 27, 2025

The legendary tale of a barber who returns from wrongful imprisonment to 1840s London, bent on revenge for the death of his wife,….

The Moondogs Mystery Tour

Apr 25

Roll up, roll up!The Moondogs have been faithfully covering the music of the Beatles for decades—everything from Love Me Do to The End. Over the...

The Main Event: A Barbra Streisand Tribute

Apr 19

Prepare to be captivated by The Main Event, a spectacular tribute to the legendary Barbra Streisand, starring the phenomenal Jill Gioia. With a voice that has been...

Kissed by a Prince

Apr 12

“All of the performers have been inspired by, and have performed Prince’s music for decades,” said guitarist Mike Mazzaraco. “We are honored to have the...

Joseph Vecsey's All Star Comedy Show

Apr 5

Comedian Joseph Vecsey has led ALL STAR COMEDY since its 2010 inception. Stand-up veterans and fresh faces alike have headlined the series, and it has...

Women of Rock

Mar 29

The show is a unique blend of Rock n Roll’s iconic female artists and bands from classic rock history through today! Some of their most...

Soul Spectacular

Mar 8

A SOUL SPECTACULAR!with THE HOODOO LOUNGERS&MIGHTY RAMON & THE PHANTOMS OF SOUL and special guests to be announcedAN EVENING OF CLASSIC SOUL FEATURING TWO OF THE MOST...

The Paumanok Stompers

Mar 1

The Paumanok Stompers Traditional Jazz Band is a collective jazz band founded and run by trumpeter, vocalist and band leader Marc Johnson of Brightwaters, NY....

Winter Jazz Series: CocoMama

Feb 22

CocoMama is a Global Fusion of Fierce and Beautiful SoundsA virtual United Nations of musicians, members of CocoMama hail from around the globe gathering their influences...

Nancy Atlas Fireside Sessions

Jan 18 – Feb 15, 2025

Turn up the heat this Winter as Nancy Atlas returns with her highly acclaimed series, The Fireside Sessions. Join Nancy Atlas and the special guests she...

Motown Night

Feb 8

A benefit for The Butterfly Effect Project, Saturday February 8th at 7pmThe event includes a dazzling performance by The Motown Band, a 50/50 raffle, a merch table...

Literature Live

Nov 11 – Dec 1, 2024

All Star Comedy

Nov 2

The return of All Star Comedy features comedians Chris Clarke, Brendan Sagalow, and Aiko Tanaka, and as always is hosted by New York-based comedian Joseph...

Hamptons Comedy

Oct 26

Divaria Opera

Oct 18 – Oct 19, 2024

Bobby Collins

Oct 13

Bobby Collins is an eternal favorite with Music Hall patrons. A comedian for grown ups, making astute observations about life and people around him....

All Star Comedy

Oct 5

The return of All Star Comedy features comedians Chris Clarke, Brendan Sagalow, and Aiko Tanaka, and as always is hosted by New York-based comedian Joseph...

Sag Harbor American Music Festival

Sep 27 – Sep 28, 2024

Ha Ha Hamptons Comedy

Sep 14

Black Film Festival

Sep 7

Mel Brooks' Young Frankenstein

Aug 1 – Aug 25, 2024

In Association with Berkshire Theatre Group & Geva TheatreMusic & lyrics by Mel BrooksBook by Mel Brooks & Thomas MeehanOriginal direction & choreography by Susan StromanDirected...

Kyle Barisich Special

Sep 21 – Aug 21, 2024

Music Mondays with Erich Bergen

Aug 12

Music Mondays Return! The hit summer concert series that invites artists to perform for audiences and share stories of their time on and off the...

Music Mondays with Harlem Gospel Choir

Aug 5

Music Mondays Return! The hit summer concert series that invites artists to perform for audiences and share stories of their time on and off the...

Master Class

Jun 25 – Jul 20, 2024

By Terrence McNallyA Comedy with MusicDirected by Lisa PetersonMaster Class is a virtuoso exploration of art, ego, and the pursuit of perfection. In the waning years...

What I Know, Now.

Jul 15 – Jul 20, 2024

A one-woman play by and starring Julia Motyka.Life isn't lived by the numbers. As she awaits the answer to one of life's big questions, a...

Music Mondays with Patti LuPone

Jul 8

Music Mondays Return! The hit summer concert series that invites artists to perform for audiences and share stories of their time on and off the...

The Subject Was Roses

May 28 – Jun 16, 2024

Like roses, family relationships are beautiful but thorny. This Pulitzer Prize and two-time Tony Award-winning play is a poignant drama set in The Bronx in...

All Things Equal: The Life and Trials of Ruth Bader Ginsburg

Nov 3 – Nov 27, 2022

Written by Tony Award Winning playwright RUPERT HOLMESDirected by LALEY LIPPARDStarring MICHELLE AZAR Supreme Court Justice “RBG” welcomes a friend of the family to her cozy...

Sip & Sing LIVE with Kyle Barisich and Special Guests: Music Mondays

Aug 29

What good is singing alone in your room? Kyle Barisich brings his acclaimed Sip & Sing show to the stage, with special guest stars from...

Ragtime

Aug 2 – Aug 28, 2022

The Great American Mousical Directed by Julie Andrews: Music Mondays

Aug 22

Below the bright lights of Broadway, in the depths of the historic Sovereign Theatre, an acting troupe of mice rehearse their new musical. When the...

The Ali Stroker Effect: Music Mondays

Aug 15

Ali Stroker won the Tony Award for Best Featured Actress in a Musical for her role as Ado Annie in a revival of Oklahoma! Before...

The Lillias White Effect: Music Mondays

Aug 8

In her latest show, Lillias White pulls back the show curtain to tell humorous, poignant and inspiring stories from both her personal and show business...

Anna in the Tropics

Jun 28 – Jul 24, 2022

Nilo Cruzs Pulitzer Prize-winning play, Anna in the Tropics, centers on a sultry and steamy cigar factory in 1929 Tampa, Florida, where the lives of...

Marilyn Maye: Music Mondays

Jul 18

Known for her powerhouse delivery, electric stage presence, and chatty rapport with the audience, Manhattans Queen of Cabaret most recently sold out four nights at...

Mike Birbiglia Live!

Jul 11 – Jul 16, 2022

Comedian, storyteller, director, podcaster, producer, and actor Mike Birbiglia makes his first appearance at Bay Street for a six-night run of stand-up comedy....

Titanic: The Musical

Mar 4 – Mar 20, 2022

In a stunning chamber musical as massive as the ocean liner that shares its name, Yeston and Peter Stones musical, Titanic, tells the stories of...

Guess Who's Coming To Dinner?

Feb 4 – Feb 20, 2022

A progressive white couple's proud liberal sensibilities are put to the test when their daughter brings her black fianc home to meet them in this...

The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee

Jan 7 – Jan 23, 2022

An eclectic group of six mid-pubescents vie for the spelling championship of a lifetime. While candidly disclosing hilarious and touching stories from their home lives,...

Rodgers and Hammerstein's Cinderella

Nov 19 – Dec 19, 2021

The timeless enchantment of a magical fairy tale is reborn with the Rodgers & Hammerstein hallmarks of originality, charm and elegance. Cinderella continues to transport...

Wonder/Wall

Jul 6 – Jul 31, 2021

Wonder/Wall is an exciting and new immersive video performance series. The installation will bring the work of four unique, cutting-edge video artists to Sag Harbor,...

Becoming Dr. Ruth

Jun 4 – Jun 27, 2021

Becoming Dr. Ruth chronicles the life of noted psychologist Dr. Ruth Westheimer, from her early years fleeing Nazi Germany, living as an orphan in Switzerland,...

All Star Comedy

Jan 28

The return of All Star Comedy features comedians Chris Clarke, Brendan Sagalow, and Aiko Tanaka, and as always is hosted by New York-based comedian Joseph...

Obama-ology by Aurin Squire

Aug 9 – Aug 11, 2018

In OBAMA-OLOGY, African-American college graduate Warren is hired by the 2008 Obama campaign and lands in the streets of East Cleveland. Somewhere between knocking on...