Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
Dear Evan Hansen show poster

Dear Evan Hansen at Bay Street Theater

Dates: 8/4/2026 - 8/29/2026

📍 Theatre: Bay Street Theater


1 Long Warf
Sag Harbor, NY

Tickets: 59.99 - 139.99


Share

Bay Street reimagines the Tony Award-winning musical.

Winner of six Tony Awards including Best Musical, Dear Evan Hansen is a powerful and deeply human story of high schoolers and their parents seeking connection in a world that so desperately needs it. Directed by Bay Street Theater Artistic Director Scott Schwartz and featuring a stunning contemporary pop score, this reimagined production fully embraces the intimacy of the Bay Street space, giving voice to the hope, fear, and longing of being seen.


Ages: Recommended for ages 13 and up. Contains mature themes including mental health and brief strong language.

Cast and Creative Team for Dear Evan Hansen at Bay Street Theater

Cast

Kenny Lee
Evan Hansen
Kenny Lee is overjoyed to be making his Bay Street Theater debut in Dear Evan Hansen! Last May, he received a BFA in Musical Theatre from The Boston Conservatory at Berklee. Select previous credits include: Evan (Dear Evan Hansen, ACT of CT); Bobby (Urinetown, Lyric Stage of Boston); Pippin (Pippin, Reagle Music Theatre); Daniel (Once On This Island, SpeakEasy Stage Company); Laurie (Little Women, Greater Boston Stage Company). A big thank you to DGRW and his family for their endless support! IG: @kennyleeiv
Alana Beck
Amaya White is thrilled to be making her Bay Street Theater debut! Previous credits include the national tour of SIX, An Officer and a Gentleman, Once On This Island (Theatre Raleigh), Beautiful (Ogunquit Playhouse), and Jelly’s Last Jam (Long Wharf Theatre). She would like to send extra love and gratitude to her family, friends, and the Collective IG: @yourstrulyamaya
Maya Days
Heidi Hansen
Maya, a New England native, reprises her performance as Heidi Hansen, direct from A.C.T. of CT’s run of DEAR EVAN HANSEN earlier this summer. Maya starred on Broadway in RENT (Mimi), JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR (Mary Magdalene), and as the tour-de-force role of Aida in AIDA. West End: RENT (Mimi). New York: AVALONA, NO STRINGS (Encores!), Carnegie Hall, Lincoln Center, New York Stage and Film. Maya developed and starred as Billie Holiday in GOOD MORNING HEARTACHE. Television: “The Blacklist”, “Law & Order”, “Blue Bloods”, with recurring roles on “Damages” opposite Glenn Close and “Barbershop”. Former Jive recording artist with three Top 10 international pop hits, including #1 "Feel It”, which was the promotional song for the World Cup and featured on Showtime's “Queer as Folk”. Maya celebrates her husband, Keith, and her son, Boston Quinn Flannery, who is easily her GREATEST accomplishment. @msmayadays
Josh Hoyt
Jared Kleinman
Josh Hoyt, is thrilled to be making his Bay Street Theater debut! Josh is a rising senior at The Hartt School, pursuing his B.F.A in Musical Theatre. Previous regional credits include: Will Parker in Oklahoma! and Aaron Shultz in Legally Blonde(Playhouse Stage Company). Josh would like to thank the entire team at Bay Street, The Hartt School Theater Division, and his friends and family for all their endless support! <3 IG: @joshshoyt
Zoe Murphy
Olivia Foght is so excited to be making her Bay Street Theater debut in Dear Evan Hansen! She is a graduate of The Boston Conservatory at Berklee with a BFA in Musical Theatre. Some recent credits include: Oklahoma and The Little Mermaid (Reagle Music Theatre), and Rapunzel in Into the Woods (Boston Conservatory). Thank you to the Collective and the Bay Street team, and endless love and gratitude to her family.
Larry Murphy
Bay Street debut! Off-Broadway: Sideways (Theatre at St. Clements), Shear Madness (Davenport Theatre), and National Pastime (Playwrights Horizons). National Tours: White Christmas, Annie. Selected Regional: Baskerville, A Midsummer Night's Dream (Syracuse Stage); Mamma Mia (Totem Pole Playhouse, Capital Rep -Berkshire Theatre Award Nomination); Sound of Music (Alabama Shakespeare, New Stage); The Addams Family (Gateway Playhouse); Grease (Fulton Theatre, Mill Mountain); Jesus Christ Superstar (Cape Fear Regional); Barnum (Colorado F.A.C.); Shear Madness (The Kennedy Center); and fifteen shows at Florida Studio Theatre including Don’t Dress For Dinner, Pictures From Home, The Play That Goes Wrong, Spamalot, and Outside Mullingar. TV: My Sordid Affair... (Lifetime Movie Network), All My Children, Law and Order: SVU. For Dad...who bought me my first baseball glove. www.Gil-Brady.com
Cynthia Murphy
Heather Ayers is so thrilled to be making her Bay Street debut! Her Broadway credits include Young Frankenstein, On a Clear Day You Can See Forever, A Little Night Music, Groundhog Day and Our Town. She played all of the “mature” ladies in the national tour of Mean Girls. Heather’s off-Broadway credits include Five Course Love, Sarah; Plain and Tall, Forbidden Broadway, and several Encores! productions. Some of her TV credits include American Vandal, Brockmire, Scandal and No Activity. She sends love and thanks to Mom, Dad, Becca, Joe and Steve. You can find her on Instagram @breathoffreshayers.
Erik Houch
Connor Murphy
Erik Houck, is thrilled to be part of Bay Street Theater’s production of Dear Evan Hansen! He is an Elon University’s Musical Theatre Graduate, his past credits include Tom of Warwick (Camelot National Tour), Roger (Rent), Drew (Rock Of Ages), Burger (HAIR). He would like to thank the entire production team at Baystreet for the opportunity to perform, as well as his wonderful agents at Nicolosi & Co., and especially his mom for her endless love and support. @erik_houck
Understudy for Cynthia Murphy and Heidi Hansen
Laura Elizabeth Flanagan is having a great day and here's why: She's back with this amazing production of Dear Evan Hansen after covering the roles of Heidi and Cynthia at A.C.T. of CT earlier this year. National Tours: Cabaret (Helga / Sally u/s), A Christmas Story (1st Nat'l), Annie, My Fair Lady (China Tour). Favorite regional: Once (Bucks County, Casa Mañana), Jekyll & Hyde (North Shore), Great Comet... (Capital City), and On The Town (Barrington Stage). Love to Chris and Hero! @lauraeflanagan
Understudy for Alana Beck and Zoe Murphy
Mackenzie Germain is thrilled to be back at Bay Street for her second summer! Last year she had the privilege of being an ensemble swing, dance captain, and Bonnie understudy for Bonnie and Clyde. She holds a BFA in Musical Theatre from Rider University, and has traveled the world singing in regional theatres and cruiseships! She would like to thank her parents and sister for always believing in her, and her amazing fiancé, Nick, for his constant love and support in her journey. She cannot wait for you all to experience this amazing story, and she hopes you enjoy! www.mackenziegermain.com, IG: @mackenzie.germain.official
Joseph Tortello
Understudy for Larry Murphy
NYC Credits: Show Boat(Carnival Barker) and Carousel(Policeman) at Lincoln Center with the NY Philharmonic (both aired on "Live From Lincoln Center" on PBS); Guys & Dolls(Mission Quartet) alongside Nathan Lane, Megan Mullally, and Patrick Wilson at Carnegie Hall; The Golden Apple(Ensemble) with City Center Encores. In his home state of CT, Waitress(Cal) and Dear Evan Hansen(Larry Standby)at A.C.T. of CT, The Little Mermaid(Triton) at Summer Theatre of New Canaan, and The Irish and How They Got That Way at Music Theatre of CT. He was a swing in the world premiere of Other World at Delaware Theatre Co, and was recently in his 11th production of The Music Man, with 3 alongside Shirley Jones. Other favorites: Sweeney Todd(Sweeney), Les Miserables(Bishop), Smokey Joe's Cafe(Fred), Billy Elliot(Big Davey) @torellojoe

News About Dear Evan Hansen at Bay Street Theater

About the Theatre

Bay Street Theater Instagram Facebook TikTok

1 Long Warf
Sag Harbor, NY

Visit Website

📍
Bay Street Theater
1 Long Warf , Sag Harbor, NY
Bay Street Theater is a premier professional theater located in the heart of historic Sag Harbor, New York. Known as Broadway on the East End of Long Island, Bay Street brings acclaimed performers, award-winning artists, and exciting new productions to audiences in an intimate setting where every seat feels close to the stage. Bay Street’s year-round programming includes Broadway musicals, plays, concerts, comedy, special events, educational programs, and new works. The theater has earned a reputation for presenting exceptional live entertainment in the Hamptons while creating unforgettable experiences for residents and visitors to the East End. Located just steps from the waterfront in Sag Harbor, Bay Street Theater offers audiences the opportunity to experience Broadway-caliber theater and world-class entertainment in one of Long Island’s most distinctive cultural destinations.

Similar Shows Nearby

Macbitches

Joan and Donald Schaeffer Black Box Theater, Joseph G. Shapiro Family Hall, Hofstra University
10/2/2026 – 10/11/2026

Bay Street Theater Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ

What shows are coming up next at Bay Street Theater?

Winslow: An Evening of Eagles (10/17/26-10/17/26)

Where is Bay Street Theater located?

Bay Street Theater is at 1 Long Warf , Sag Harbor, NY.

What shows have played recently at Bay Street Theater?


Dear Evan Hansen in Long Island Dear Evan Hansen
John W. Engeman Theater at Northport (9/12-10/25)
Sesame Street Live: Elmo’s Got the Moves in Long Island Sesame Street Live: Elmo’s Got the Moves
Patchogue Theatre (10/14-10/14)
Sing-A-Long Santa, Presented in Partnership with TRW in Long Island Sing-A-Long Santa, Presented in Partnership with TRW
The Noel S. Ruiz Theatre (11/28-12/30)
Pinkalicious - The Musical in Long Island Pinkalicious - The Musical
Patchogue Theatre (10/25-10/25)
42nd Street in Long Island 42nd Street
The Noel S. Ruiz Theatre (5/08-5/23)
Broadway Fright Night in Long Island Broadway Fright Night
Tilles Center for the Performing Arts Long Island University (10/25-10/25)
Gravity & Other Myths Presents: Ten Thousand Hours in Long Island Gravity & Other Myths Presents: Ten Thousand Hours
Staller Center for the Arts (10/18-10/18)
Stony Brook Symphony Orchestra in Long Island Stony Brook Symphony Orchestra
Staller Center for the Arts (11/07-11/07)
The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show in Long Island The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show
The Dinner Detective Long Island (10/24-10/24)
Jaime Lozano & Florencia Cuenca’s Broadway en Spanglish in Long Island Jaime Lozano & Florencia Cuenca’s Broadway en Spanglish
Tilles Center for the Performing Arts Long Island University (11/19-11/19)