Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: Porchlight Music Theatre's FAR FROM HEAVEN Presents A Woman's Melodic Journey Towards Self-Discovery In 1950s America

Porchlight Music Theatre's production of FAR FROM HEAVEN marks the musical's Chicago premiere--the show debuted Off-Broadway at Playwrights Horizons in 2013 and takes the titular 2002 Todd Haynes-directed film as its source material. And while this musical from composer-lyricist team Scott Frankel and Michael Korie was written three years ago, FAR FROM HEAVEN touches on issues of gender, sexuality, and race in 1957 suburban Connecticut that poignantly resonant with the present moment. At the center of the musical is Cathy Whittaker (the superb and stunning Summer Naomi Smart), a 1950s housewife and mother--decked out in Bill Morey's outstanding period-authentic dresses and residing in Grant Sabin's charming set. At the top of the show, she catches her husband, Frank (Brandon Springman) cheating on her--with a man. Stunned by this secret, Cathy is forced to confront the reality of what happens when her life cannot conform to the societal pressures and ideals coming at her from both the media and friends--a matter which is further complicated when she strikes up an unexpected friendship with her black gardener, Raymond Deagan (Evan Tyrone Martin).

Richard Greenberg's lean book works nicely with Frankel and Korie's numerous musical numbers--the show is almost entirely sung-through. The score has a lush, tranquil feel to it, fitting of a show set in the 1950s American suburbs. Korie has crafted some similarly lovely lyrics to accompany it, especially in the show's act one finale--a beautiful duet for Cathy and Raymond. In some instances, however, I hoped for a bit more lyrical complexity--at one point, Korie rhymes "brang" and "clang' in a song the Whittaker children sing on Christmas morning. And while melodious, FAR FROM HEAVEN'S score could stand for some more variation in terms of song pacing--the musical stays firmly in ballad territory.

While FAR FROM HEAVEN has a far-reaching premise, the musical ultimately focuses on Cathy's own identity exploration. And similarly, Summer Naomi Smart carries this production with her performance. Despite the show's title, Smart's singing voice is truly angelic, and she seemingly melts into the many challenging high notes in Frankel's score. While the part is vocally challenging, Smart makes it seem easy. At the same time, Smart's acting is raw and real--we truly feel Cathy's growing pain and desperation as she finds her life falling apart in front of her. Smart owns the stage in each and every moment she appears, which is important considering that she rarely leaves it.

Smart's excellent performance finds good company in this Rob Lindley-directed production. Martin (who appeared this fall in Porchlight's production of Side Show) shines with sincerity as Raymond and has an extremely powerful voice. Any time Smart and Martin duet in this show, it quickly becomes a highlight-as in the compelling song "Miro," in which Cathy and Raymond contemplate a painting at an art show and the various meanings on which they can bestow it. Bri Sudia infuses some humor and warmth into the production as Cathy's best friend Eleanor. Candace C. Edwards has a poignant turn as the Whittaker's housekeeper Sybil, and Peyton Shaffer (at this performance) and Aaron Stone delight as the Whittaker children, Janice and David.

Porchlight's overall lovely production of FAR FROM HEAVEN both entertains and moves, and it comes at a moment when the musical's themes ring out loud and clear for audiences. And Smart's powerful take on Cathy is simply not-to-be-missed--she is divine in every way. Though Cathy feels burdened by the ceaseless pressure to conform to 1950s society, Smart does not let anything get in the way of her expert performance.

Porchlight Music Theatre's FAR FROM HEAVEN runs through March 13 at Stage 773, 1225 West Belmont Avenue. Tickets are $32-$48 and can be purchased online at or by phone at 73.327.5252.

Photo by Brandon Dahlquist

Marriott Theatre Launches 2023 Season With BIG FISH, The Musical Photo
The Marriott Theatre's 2023 season launches with the family-friendly musical adventure, BIG FISH, previewing Wednesday, January 25, opening Wednesday, February 1 at 7:30pm and closing March 19, 2023.

Latest Standings Released For The 2022 BroadwayWorld Chicago Awards; The Little Theatre On Photo
The latest standings as of Monday, December 5th, have been released for the 2022 BroadwayWorld Chicago Awards! Nominations were reader-submitted and now our readers get to vote for their favorites.

League of Chicago Theatres Calls for Entries for Samuel G. Roberson Resident Fellowship Photo
The League of Chicago Theatres has announced the 2023 Samuel G. Roberson Jr. Resident Fellowship, an annual grant awarded to a Black Theatre Artist to fund a residency or collaboration with a Chicago area non-profit organization. This year the award will go to an Artivist – an individual who combines art with activism.

Photos: THE BUTTCRACKER: A NUTCRACKER BURLESQUE Now Playing At The Greenhouse Theater Cent Photo
See photos of The Buttcracker: A Nutcracker Burlesque, returning this holiday season with the sixth edition of Chicago’s favorite alternative holiday show, a twist on the original story and a live event not to be missed, directed by Miguel Long and choreographed by Dylan Kerr, now playing through December 31 at the Greenhouse Theater Center, 2257 N. Lincoln Ave. 

From This Author - Rachel Weinberg

Chicago native Rachel Weinberg has been one of the most frequent contributing editors and critics for BroadwayWorld Chicago since joining the team in 2014. She is a marketing professional specializ... (read more about this author)

Movies This Christmas Season for Broadway Fans — Old and NewMovies This Christmas Season for Broadway Fans — Old and New
November 17, 2022

Here’s our selection of brand-new, recent, and classic festive films featuring some of theater’s most iconic faces that you won’t want to miss.

Review: TROUBLE IN MIND at TimeLine Theatre CompanyReview: TROUBLE IN MIND at TimeLine Theatre Company
November 11, 2022

What did our critic think of TROUBLE IN MIND at TimeLine Theatre Company? TROUBLE IN MIND is a blistering portrait of racial and gender politics on Broadway.

Review: RENT at Porchlight Music TheatreReview: RENT at Porchlight Music Theatre
November 7, 2022

What did our critic think of RENT at Porchlight Music Theatre? Jonathan Larson’s 1996 Pulitzer Prize and Tony Award winning musical RENT comes to life in a Porchlight production that captures the ethos of the original Broadway production. It also the fresh energy of the musical’s message about love, acceptance, and living in the moment.

Review: SWING STATE at Goodman TheatreReview: SWING STATE at Goodman Theatre
October 24, 2022

What did our critic think of SWING STATE at Goodman Theatre? Rebecca Gilman shows her deftness at writing “slice of life” plays in SWING STATE at Goodman Theatre. In this latest collaboration with outgoing Goodman Theatre Artistic Director Robert Falls, Gilman introduces four characters at a crossroads in a small town in rural Wisconsin during summer 2021. It’s marketed as a play about the pandemic, and indeed, SWING STATE contains some references to the COVID-19 pandemic, masks, and vaccines. Ultimately, though, SWING STATE is a pure character study with the notions of pandemic and extinction of the human race in the background, and notions of mortality and despair in the foreground. Yes, it’s a post-pandemic play, but really it’s just allowing us to peer into the lives of these characters at a moment in time. That’s not to say that Gilman’s play isn’t moving, but I found the overall execution to not be as overarching as the set-up purports.

Review: CLUE at Mercury Theater ChicagoReview: CLUE at Mercury Theater Chicago
October 21, 2022

What did our critic think of CLUE at Mercury Theater Chicago? Mercury Theater’s CLUE is a comedic delight of a production. The laughs flow freely and easily in this stage adaptation of the farce-meets-murder-mystery based on the iconic 1985 film. Director L. Walter Stearns’s ensemble lands each and every moment, maximizing the laughs but maintaining the integrity. These actors understand the assignment of both farce and murder mystery: The characters in CLUE take themselves and the outrageous situations of the play deeply seriously, and the ensemble finds the comedy in playing those truths. It’s a near masterclass in how farce should be performed. The fact that the play is only 90 minutes also means the stage adaptation doesn’t overstay its welcome: There’s just enough time to set up the mystery, play the antics, and send audiences home after a delightful, hilarious time.