Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: STEVE SCHALCHLIN AND FRIENDS Shines at Don't Tell Mama

The singer-songwriter stopped by the Midtown cabaret bar to play some of what he's written recently

By:
Review: STEVE SCHALCHLIN AND FRIENDS Shines at Don't Tell Mama

Steve Schalchlin boasts an impressive work ethic – he claims to write a new song every week. His 3/7 show at Don’t Tell Mama was a showcase of his more recent compositions, mainly from the past year alone. The instrumentation and genre varies throughout the show – some numbers have multiple vocalists and the full band, some are purely piano and vocals. Schalchlin himself plays the keys on every song, although he sometimes cedes vocal duties to a rotating cast of guest singers.

"The Only Kind of Music," the show’s opener, is an ode to Schalchlin’s roots. Schachlin, who grew up in Texas before eventually moving to New York, chooses to sing this one himself. The full band takes the stage with him and they all give the number a bit of country flair. Music director Charlie Viehl takes a smooth violin solo to round it all out. The Oak & The Willow is another number that brings the full band into the equation. It’s a pleasant performance, all the instruments mesh together well. Notably, Charlie Viehl takes another violin solo that serves to elevate the song.

Schalchlin wrote "My New York Life" for Blake Zolfo, who sings the number. It’s a classic tale of New York as a city where the mom & pop shops are on hard times as the new luxury hotels boom, where the rent is too high and the people too busy. It’s hardly a new idea in the world of music, but Blake Zolfo’s emotive performance sells the song’s emotional core. Zolfo also co-wrote "Someone to Get Groceries With," a romantic tune about wanting a partner in life who makes the little things feel a bit more special – from lounging around in pajamas to getting groceries. It’s a heartwarming little tune, and a real highlight of the evening.

Review: STEVE SCHALCHLIN AND FRIENDS Shines at Don't Tell Mama Image
Sidney Myer. Photo credit: Stephen Hanks

"Vacationing in Syria" is a comedic number. Vocalist Sidney Myer sings to piano accompaniment (provided by Schalchlin) of all the things he’d rather do than see an ex-lover again, returning to the titular activity as the extreme example of preferred alternatives. Myer’s frenetic delivery is quite entertaining, varying his volume to great effect – by the end of the tune he’s nearly shouting, before falling back into a quieter register.

"Family Bash" is another humorous song, co-written by Schalchlin and Gavin Gold (who provides guitar and occasional vocals for the evening) for their project The Rebel Nerds. The song describes some teenagers getting in trouble for smoking marijuana at a house party, an event that naturally spirals out of control to dramatic effect. Gavin Gold also co-wrote "Sooner or Later," a pop-punk-y number performed with the Bonus Round Band for the same Rebel Nerds project. It’s a fun little tune about how finding true love requires being vulnerable, and perhaps a bit persistent. Gold’s voice embodies the nervous-yet-charming energy of the song, sometimes slipping into falsetto at the end of a line before the instrumental break.

Review: STEVE SCHALCHLIN AND FRIENDS Shines at Don't Tell Mama Image
Natalie Douglas. Photo credit: Stephen Hanks

Guest vocalist Natalie Douglas comes on stage for "All That and More," a quiet tune inspired by Schalchlin’s time on a cruise ship. It’s a romantic number, opining that the world’s majesty cannot compare to that of the singer’s lover. Backed by soft piano, Douglas lends her voice to the song well, making for another memorable love song in the setlist.

The full band returns for the finale, a song from the Beatles' Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band album. Schalchlin invites the audience to sing along to the classic number, which proved a real crowd pleaser. Bassist Jake Adams throws in some fun flourishes here and there, giving the tune a pleasant feel.

Overall, Schalchlin’s talent as a songwriter shines through, especially on the romantic numbers. Bouncing from genre to genre, he finds an interesting emotion or idea in each one, while maintaining his singer-songwriter charm throughout.


Follow Steve Schalchlin on Instagram here for more.

Find more upcoming shows at Don't Tell Mama on their website.

Header photo credit: Stephen Hanks

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on Don't Tell Mama
Upcoming Shows
Love or Death?
Love or Death?
4/19 - 10/10/2026
SPF! (Songs, Patter, and Fun!)
8/4 - 8/18/2026
Recent Articles
Video: Dana Chablis Carpenter Sings 'Flowers' (HADESTOWN) at Don't Tell Mama
Video: Dana Chablis Carpenter Sings 'Flowers' (HADESTOWN) at Don't Tell Mama
8/11/2026
Helane Blumfield Will Bring INVISIBLE TO INVINCIBLE Back to Don't Tell Mama
Helane Blumfield Will Bring INVISIBLE TO INVINCIBLE Back to Don't Tell Mama
8/11/2026

Reader Reviews

Don't Miss a Cabaret News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


Flame: The Songs of Brady & Browne in Cabaret Flame: The Songs of Brady & Browne
54 Below (8/23-8/23) PHOTOS VIDEOS
DiGangi With A “G” in Cabaret DiGangi With A “G”
The Green Room 42 (8/18-8/18) PHOTOS
Let's Get Schooled: The Broadway Community Returns to the Classroom in Cabaret Let's Get Schooled: The Broadway Community Returns to the Classroom
Green Room 42 (8/26-8/26)
Troy: Crooner to the Stars in Cabaret Troy: Crooner to the Stars
The Green Room 42 (8/21-8/21)
Ari Axelrod: L’chaim! To Life, To Love, To You in Cabaret Ari Axelrod: L’chaim! To Life, To Love, To You
54 Below (10/13-10/13)
Oh Em Gee, They Sang This on Glee! in Cabaret Oh Em Gee, They Sang This on Glee!
54 Below (9/27-9/27)
Flame: The Songs of Amara Janae Brady and Xander Browne in Cabaret Flame: The Songs of Amara Janae Brady and Xander Browne
54 Below (8/23-8/23)
54 Below! DEBUT! in Cabaret 54 Below! DEBUT!
54 Below (8/29-8/29)
Darwin Del Fabro Sings Torch Songs in Cabaret Darwin Del Fabro Sings Torch Songs
54 Below (9/27-9/27)
54 Sings Jeff Buckley: It’s Never Over in Cabaret 54 Sings Jeff Buckley: It’s Never Over
54 Below (10/01-10/01)