Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: Susan Mack Celebrates the MUSIC IN THE AIR at Birdland Theater

Susan Mack and her band return to Birdland with a musical tribute to music.

Review: Susan Mack Celebrates the MUSIC IN THE AIR at Birdland Theater

Surrounded by the modern design sensibilities of the Birdland Theater, Susan Mack spent a Sunday night taking the audience back in time. With a 16-song setlist comprised of jazz classics from the early-to-mid 20th century (with a few more modern songs up to the 1980s), Mack's "Music in the Air" was meant to be a celebration of the impact of music as it surrounds us in our day-to-day lives. At one point joking that, with everything else that's been in the air of late, music is a good thing to be touched by, Mack interlaced the songs with some explanations and a few hints at her life behind the curtain.

Each of Mack's 16 songs fell along the same theme - music, and its importance in everything from our love lives to our entertainment - and the setlist boasted a good mix of pensive, slow ballads with some upbeat tunes. One standout performance was "Spain (I Can Recall)," a slower song that gives the impression, both through the lyrics and Mack's performance of it, that this is a sad recollection... until, that is, the music speeds up and the narrator starts to recall better times. The song was very interesting on a vocal level, allowing Mack to showcase her skills, and was overall impressive. On the whole, though, the night was a slow one. Most of the songs leaned more traditional, and I found it easy to lose myself in my own thoughts as I listened - imagining, perhaps, that I was the narrator of "The Midnight Sun," dancing all night long with a beautiful stranger. There's a quality to Mack's singing and the songs she has chosen which allows the listener to be fanciful, to indulge in outlandish inventions.

The oldest song on the list was 1928's "I Got Rhythm," during which Mack introduced her band, prefacing each name with, "my man," a nod to the song's lyrics. On the flip side, the most modern selection of the night was "Gotta Get Me Some ZZZ's" from 1981, which Mack altered slightly to include some "lyrical enhancements" and make it more relevant to 2021. At multiple points throughout the show, Mack almost took a backseat and allowed her band - Tedd Firth on the piano; David Finck on bass; and Eric Halvorson on the drums - to shine in their own solos; she took genuine delight, it appeared, in letting them have a chance to show off their own prowess. Truly, though hers was the name on the playbill, it was a group effort, and you could tell Mack appreciated her band.

Throughout the night, the curtains behind her changed colors according to the spotlight colors, each change often reflecting the song's mood or ambiance.

Though many of the selections were standards of jazz and the show was intended to be a celebration of music, in some ways the night plodded rather than danced. The lack of any music created later than the 1980s was, in the end, a hindrance to the overall intended effect - while there is great merit and value in older music, there are also excellent new arrangements and compositions put to music in the past 40 years that do their own part in celebrating the "dancing, romancing and loving that music inspires in all of us," as the show description put it. The show could have benefited from a greater marriage of the traditional and the contemporary.

One thing that's not up for debate is Mack's talent as a singer - one who shines, especially, when holding long notes and finishing out songs, a perfect showcase for her vocal prowess.

Find great shows to see at Birdland HERE.


Join Team BroadwayWorld

Are you an avid Cabaret fan in NYC? We're looking for people like you to share your thoughts and insights with our readers. Team BroadwayWorld members get access to shows to review, conduct interviews with artists, and the opportunity to meet and network with fellow theatre lovers and arts workers.

Interested? Learn more here.


Regional Awards


From This Author - Karis Rogerson

Karis Rogerson is a writer and blogger with a passion for telling stories about art and those who make it. She writes novels, poems, essays, and articles for various online magazines.

... (read more about this author)

BWW Review: Megan Hilty Sparkles in DIAMOND SERIES: MEGAN HILTY at Feinstein's/54 BelowBWW Review: Megan Hilty Sparkles in DIAMOND SERIES: MEGAN HILTY at Feinstein's/54 Below
November 3, 2021

The stunning show runs through Sunday, Nov. 7

BWW Feature: Jennica McCleary is the Swiss Army Knife of PerformersBWW Feature: Jennica McCleary is the Swiss Army Knife of Performers
October 31, 2021

The Bette Midler tribute artist returns to NYC with Winnie's Rock Cauldron Cabaret

BWW Review: Natalie Douglas Defies Explanation in BEST OF TRIBUTES: THE WOMEN at Birdland TheaterBWW Review: Natalie Douglas Defies Explanation in BEST OF TRIBUTES: THE WOMEN at Birdland Theater
October 5, 2021

Natalie Douglas was excited to be on stage. She was returning to Birdland Theater on Oct. 1, 2021 in 'Best of Tributes: The Women', with a show that sampled songs from tribute shows she had previously created for Dolly Parton, Nina Simone, and Roberta Flack. The award-winning performer was in excellent spirits as she came onto the stage and greeted the audience. Missing a cue at the beginning of the first song, she laughed it off, restarted, and dove into Dolly Parton's '9 to 5,' which was a perfectly exuberant and jaunty song to kick off the evening.

BWW Review: Stacey Kent is Transportive in SONGS FROM OTHER PLACES at Birdland Jazz ClubBWW Review: Stacey Kent is Transportive in SONGS FROM OTHER PLACES at Birdland Jazz Club
October 2, 2021

Staey Kent's voice teleports listeners to a different era

BWW Feature: Will Nolan Returns With LEOLA'S LADY LAND LOUNGE at The Green Room 42BWW Feature: Will Nolan Returns With LEOLA'S LADY LAND LOUNGE at The Green Room 42
September 30, 2021

I could introduce Will as the creator of Leola, a 'senior citizen redneck diva' who wows audiences with her sketch comedies. I could talk about how he dreamed up Leola as the complete opposite of his own great-aunt Leola - his character is a 70-year-old Southern lesbian who just 'wants to save the whole world.'