You guys act like Billie Joe and Melissa Etheridge aren't legitimate rock stars who might actually be appropriate for this kind of show. Billie Joe is absolutely electric as St. Jimmy. I am kind of shocked by how out of nowhere Melissa seems, but I can actually see this working out brilliantly.
Well, I for one might actually go see it again. I love Melissa.
"If this is going to be a Christian nation that doesn't help the poor, either we have to pretend that Jesus was just as selfish as we are, or we've got to acknowledge that He commanded us to love the poor and serve the needy without condition and then admit that we just don't want to do it." -Stephen Colbert
Whoa. I did not see this one coming!! Personally, I loved Billie Joe as St. Jimmy. He gave an electric performance each time I saw him.
However, I never thought of having a female St. Jimmy. Makes me wonder who else could play this role. I could see Juliette Lewis being kinda cool. Updated On: 1/18/11 at 03:04 PM
Saint Jimmy is an interesting role- it's more or less asexual and gender-neutral, and its only real requirement is a great rock voice and a true rock-star presence onstage.
It's already been noted the difference between Vincent and Armstrong in the role- Vincent has an element of seduction and pleasure to him, and his slithery, somewhat effeminate presence clearly shows him as the "other side" of Johnny in all ways (perhaps even a nod to Billie Joe's straight-leaning bisexual orientation). Armstrong himself is all about danger, destruction and just having a good time with death and chaos. Etheridge, in the same role, who knows what she'll be or do?
Country? Granted, I'm not a Melissa Etheridge fan at all, but I associate her with being the biggest voice in female blues-rock of the past two decades, with only Amy Winehouse as competition.
"I'm the Only One" and "I Wanna Come Over" are the only two songs I can think of with her off the top of my head. Color me curious if not convinced about her performance.
Seriously, I don't care who plays Jimmy. Idiot is the only musical left on Broadway with the slightest bit of an edge, so good on them for keeping it interesting (I haven't seen STOTD, so don't know if it qualifies as being edgy).
"The price of love is loss, but still we pay; We love anyway."