My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
Murder At Mosquito Cove: The murder of Elfreda Pike, 1870. show poster

Murder At Mosquito Cove: The murder of Elfreda Pike, 1870. at Alumnae Theatre

Dates: 4/10/2026 - 4/19/2026

📍 Theatre:
Alumnae Theatre

Walnut Productions
570 Bay Street
Toronto, ON M5A 2W6

Phone: 7096832467

Tickets: 11.98 - 65.23


It is said that disturbed spirits with an unjust action foisted against them can’t achieve their eternal rest until the truth has been told. 

16-year-old Elfreda Pike's body was discovered on January 6th 1870 on Featherbed Road behind a blood-soaked boulder, her clothes torn from the waist down and disfigured.

Horror spreads through the communities of Mosquito Cove and nearby Harbour Grace; with an invasive, police investigation probing into the lives of the townsfolk.

Was it Thomas Pike [no relation], Elfreda’s beau? Elfreda’s brother-in-law Ray Thomey who shortly before his marriage to Elfreda’s sister Harriet was caught kissing Elfreda in the stable loft? Or a mysterious man in a long black coat seen walking Featherbed Road with Elfreda shortly before she was killed?

It will take 50 years before the true murderer is discovered. 

A drop dead mystery you won’t want to miss.

-Emerging Artists | Quality Entertainment | Immersive | Visually Exciting- 


News About Murder At Mosquito Cove: The murder of Elfreda Pike, 1870. at Alumnae Theatre


We have no news on this show at the current time.

About the Theatre

Alumnae Theatre

570 Bay Street
Toronto, ON M5A 2W6

Phone: 7096832467

Facebook Instagram

Alumnae Theatre Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ

Alumnae Theatre is at 570 Bay Street, Toronto, ON.

More Toronto Coverage

Videos