Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

BWW Reviews: The Unsingable Blues

I wonder: were I to place a gardenia in my hair, could I be as beautiful as Billie Holiday? It's not very likely.

Now, the kind of beauty being spoken about here is not the superficial kind, or the kind that people "think" they see in others in order to offer some great appeal to their characters. Indeed, the way in which the late singer lived her life, and thus the person she became in the interim, left little but her music to serve as an indication of how great she truly was.

No, the beauty that Billie Holiday possessed was the kind that lies deep within a person- the kind which remains even when there is little reason to believe that it still exists. It is the kind which emboldens the souls of people who once loved her to love her still, and that which lived in the gazes and cheers of adoring fans who probably knew so little of the demons that plagued the woman who sang some of the most memorable songs of the 1920's.

Hers is a beauty that needs to be told in the fashion of a story, in a way that both glorifies and pays tribute to a legend while tastefully revealing the gradual downfall and demise of a woman who was so much more than the words she sang.

Beautiful Soup Theater's Shades of Blue: The Decline and Fall of Lady Day is an unconventional, almost chilling ode to Holiday that is careful not to emphasize and dwell upon the singer's musical accolades and success; in fact, it does little to promote her career and the person as seen through the eyes of her adoring public. This production, written and directed by the incredibly talented Steven Carl McCasland (who also founded Beautiful Soup and serves as the group's Artistic Director), wades in the realm of storytelling without the fantastical twist that people always enjoy adding to make their lives seem more interesting - to add drama where drama may sometimes be due.

McCarland, an accomplished playwright, director and actor whose talents can be seen both on and off stage, is responsible for quite a number of plays, including the critically acclaimed play Little Wars (which premiered this past April in New York). Shades of Blue can undoubtedly be added as yet another successful credit to his name.

Shades of Blue is an explanation of Holiday's demise - a story which gives a thorough look at the singer's tragic life and thereby proves just how brilliant a woman Holiday was because of the struggles she endured; it is the story that she so very much deserved to have told.

Billie Holiday was famous for her beautiful music which resonated in the hearts of those who admired her - music to which people still pay tribute to this very day. Songs like "Pennies from Heaven," "I'll Be Seeing You" and "Crazy He Calls Me" made Lady Day an unforgettable jazz icon. What is unique about Shades of Blue is that the show focuses very little on her music and career, but instead portrays a woman whose disregard forlife (whether an involuntary choice of not) caused her being to slip right through her fingers; as she poured herself another drink or shot up in the dark recesses of the stage, her life was gradually no longer her own.

Holiday does all of this with such an air of indifference that the audience fills in as her conscience - the inner voice which is no longer present to prevent her from inching closer and closer towards her death. The singer was typically so high or drunk that her addictions were becoming a major concern of those who cared for her most; while her feelings were numbed by drug and drink, the audience is compelled to feel for her - this tragic figure who, even with the pleas of those who wished her to stop on this path of self destruction, was very much alone. The audience almost serves as a second family, as it cannot help but want to help where no help can really be given.

McCasland's portrayal of the late singer's life can almost be described as brutal in its nature. He does not dart his way around the gritty details of her drug and alcohol addictions, her numerous relationships with women and men in each of the cities she visited, and her inability to escape those demons which plagued her until the very end - one of which was a consequence of her being raped.

No - this is the story of the woman who existed apart from the idolized Billie Holiday, yet shared the same name; this is the double life that was not glamorous or admirable. McCasland is almost ruthless in communicating to the audience just how beautiful Holiday was because of the burdens she was forced to carry throughout her life. This production is able to swoop in and get a firm grasp of Holiday's life, forcing the audience right in the middle of a story already in progress. It comes with the force of reality that is able to make those watching uncomfortable at certain moments, tearful at others and compels a person, after the show has concluded, to reevaluate his or her own life after watching another's deteriorate. The amount of control McCasland executes in the telling of Holiday's story in the course of ninety brief minutes is truly something brilliant.

Essentially, this show is an emotional roller coaster that shows the severity of the singer's addiction and ultimate deterioration in such a raw, tangible way. McCasland is a creative genius for writing a show that can affect his audience in such a way.

What would an amazing show be without an amazing cast? And amazing it truly was. Susanne Froix as Billie Holiday is simply astounding; describing her performances as such might actually be an understatement. Froix is an emotional wreck upon that stage, cussing at whomever it is who tries to steer her away from the wayward path she has been following and thus indicating how badly she just wants to be left alone - she is a caged animal that yearns for nothing than to be freed from the confines of this world. She is just so amazing to watch, as she knows how to navigate her way through each scene and new circumstance, whether it be playing on her desire for the seductive Tallulah Bankhead (played by Kristen Gehling), the distraught being she becomes when her agent Joe Glaser (Orlando Iriarte) attempts to cut off her supply of alcohol or the happy child who begins and ends the show who comes out and shows such potential all watching will know amounts to very little towards the singer's untimely end. Froix is the best person McCasland could have cast to play Billie Holiday, and she did the late singer so much justice in this spectacular portrayal.

Kristen Gehling as actress Tallulah Bankhead is equally as amazing, as both she and Froix basically took over the stage. Between the two of them, there was such energy present that only two confident, talented actors can bring to a performance; each one complimented the other's performance, which was so incredibly admirable and wonderful to watch. Gehling portrays the two sides of Bankhead with such ease. While she attempts to keep her relationship with Holiday in check, she still takes many moments to contemplate how much this woman has affected her; even after her death, Gehling takes such pride in explaining how she adored Billie.

Orlando Iriarte as Holiday's agent, Alana Inez as Laura Big Red Liingstone, Ron Denson as Louis McKay, Bettina Coley Denson as Sadie Fagan, Laurie Sammeth as Dorothy Parker and Somie Pak complete this beautiful cast and make this the fantastic show that it is.

Shades of Blue is an absolutely wonderful show. McCasland should be very proud as both writer and director of this deeply moving play. It is a raw, uninhibited show that provides the audience with an uncomfortable yet poignant experience - one that is truly unforgettable. It is a beautiful, beautiful show.

Shades of Blue: The Decline and Fall of Lady Day began performances on August 27th, and will continue running through September 6th at the Dorothy Strelsin Theater, located at 312 West 36th Street. The performance schedule is as follows: Wednesday (September 3rd) at 2:00 p.m., Friday (September 5th) at 8:00 p.m., Saturdays (August 30th ) at 8:00 p.m. and Saturday (September 6th) at 2:00 p.m., and Sunday (August 31st) at 2:00 p.m. Tickets are $18 and can be purchased at http://www.showclix.com/events/1307. Shades of Blue is also running in repertory with What Was Lost, a play about Laurette Taylor, so if you enjoy the story of Billie Holiday and are familiar with McCasland's other works, then you will definitely enjoy this play.

Beauty can truly be found in so many different forms, and Billie's is a soecial one that must be seen to be understood.

Enjoy the show!

Photo Credit: Samantha Mercado Tudda



Mystical Feet Company to Present SECRET OF THE POSSIBLE at 14th Street Y This Month Photo
Mystical Feet Company, in partnership with the Theater at the 14th Street Y, has announced December 2022 dance/theater performances of a new ensemble-created work from award-winning playwright/choreographer Yehuda Hyman, presented at the Theater at the 14th Street Y, 344 East 14th Street, Thursday, December 15 through Friday, December 23, 2022.

First Kiss Theatre to Close Out In-Person Season With A MIDDLE SCHOOL PLAY By Alice Nora Photo
A Middle School Play by Alice Nora, directed by Jacqueline Keeley - December 11th and 12th at 7pm Relive the wonder years with this comedic take on the messy & outlandish time that is the middle school experience.

La MaMa to Host PAINT2POWER Public Art-Making Event Photo
On Sunday, Dec. 4 at 2 p.m., LA MAMA will host PAINT2POWER,  the making of a large public art mural  at the company's Galleria in Manhattan.  The public is invited to participate.  Admission is free.

Benefit Reading Of BROS FOR HOES, a One-Act Comedy About SantaCon, To Take Place In West V Photo
Independent producers Emily Jeppesen, Rebecca Kane, and Taylor Thomson will present a reading of a new one-act comedy in a performance entitled 'Bros for Hoes: A SantaCon Play Benefit Reading' on December 12th, 2022.


From This Author - Kristen Morale

Kristen was born and raised in Brooklyn, and is a graduate of both Saint Francis College and Hunter College, with degrees in English and Musical Theatre. She enjoys going to any show, from com... (read more about this author)


Review: YOU'RE GONNA LOVE TOMORROW! at Theater2020Review: YOU'RE GONNA LOVE TOMORROW! at Theater2020
October 21, 2022

You're gonna truly love tomorrow, and it starts with what you're doing tonight!

Review: LET ME COOK FOR YOU: THE TRILOGY at TheaterlabReview: LET ME COOK FOR YOU: THE TRILOGY at Theaterlab
September 19, 2022

Family is truly everything, regardless of who you are or where you happen to come from. Sunday dinner at home with loved ones, sharing an end of the workweek meal with friends, or even among complete strangers - perhaps those who happened to attend the same show one evening, seated beside you in an intimate New York space with the intention of making their weekend count. People from all walks of life who have chosen to embrace a single perspective and similar scope of vision within the confines of a theater, ready to be swept away from reality for ever so brief a time.

Review: PANDEMONIUM at Theater For The New CityReview: PANDEMONIUM at Theater For The New City
September 9, 2022

Recently concluding its run at both the People’s Improv Theater (PIT) and Theater for the New City in New York City, Pandemonium is a new show written by Claude Solbik that, beneath its comical nature, questions whether our fate is truly written for us. A whimsical tale of swashbuckling pirates, trips to the stars and fairy tale romances, Pandemonium combines fact with fiction through the possibilities and new beginnings that reality brings.

Previews: THE FANTASTICKS at The Cape PlayhousePreviews: THE FANTASTICKS at The Cape Playhouse
September 3, 2022

The Cape Playhouse, the country’s longest running professional summer theater, will end its exciting 2022 summer season with its upcoming production of 'The Fantasticks'. What better way to round out a fantastic repertoire of shows, and who better than the Playhouse to bring the longest running musical in world history to a Cape Cod stage? Undoubted to leave as lasting an impression on Cape audiences, 'The Fantasticks' is set to run from September 7th -17th at the iconic Dennis, MA theater.

MURDER ON THE ORIENT EXPRESS at The Cape PlayhouseMURDER ON THE ORIENT EXPRESS at The Cape Playhouse
August 21, 2022

Based on Agatha Christie’s 1934 detective novel and adapted for the stage by Ken Ludwig, director Marcia Milgrom Dodge leads a cast and crew that brings what is considered one of Christie’s best works of mystery to a Cape Cod stage.