Island City Stage presents The Fantasticks, a newly reimagined production of the beloved musical that features an LGBTQ+ twist, marking its South Florida premiere. Directed by Andy Rogow, this version tells the story of two young gay men, Matt and Lewis, as they navigate love amidst a backdrop of familial deception. The cast includes Jonny Lee Jr. as Lewis, Kevin Hincapie as Matt, Jesse Luttrell as El Gallo, and Margot Moreland as Mildred, bringing fresh voices to a timeless narrative. The show runs from November 6 through November 24, 2024.
Cast and Creative team for The Fantasticks at Island City Stage
Cast
Jonny Lee Jr.
Lewis
Kevin Hincapie
Matt
Jesse Luttrell
El Gallo
Margot Moreland
Mildred
Michael Gioia
Henry
Rayner Gabriel
Mortimer
Louie San Luis
Mute
Jeni Hacker
Bessie
Creative Team
Tom Jones
Director
Michael Mullins
Co-Producer
Terry Gaw
Co-Producer
Mark Loeser
Co-Producer
The Opening Doors Charitable Trust
Co-Producer
Scott Bennett
Lights and Sound Sponsor
Glenn Goldberg
Set Sponsor
Fran Folic
Press Representative
Andy Rogow
Artistic Director
SUBMIT UPDATES
Island City Stage Frequently Asked Questions FAQ
At The Wedding (8/21/25-9/14/25)
The Dying Gaul (5/22/25-6/15/25)
Fat Ham (4/3/25-5/4/25)
Island City Stage Presents The Fantasticks, A Love Story Reimagined (10/17/24-11/17/24)
The Finstrom Follies (9/23/24-9/23/24)
Island City Stage Presents Die, Mommie, Die! by Charles Busch (8/22/24-9/22/24)
Which Way to the Stage by Ana Nogueira (1/18/24-1/11/24)
Rotterdam (1/19/23-2/19/23)
Suddenly Last Summer (3/17/22-4/17/22)
The goal of Island City Stage is to create quality theatrical experiences that focus on the LGBTQ community, but have a heart and soul that is truly universal. Island City Stage is a 501 (c) 3 non-profit organization.
At The Wedding (8/21/25-9/14/25)
Videos
 |
Strictly Murder
Delray Beach Playhouse (1/30 - 3/22) | |
 |
ALWAYS: The Love Story of Irving Berlin (Starring KT Sullivan & Mark Nadler)
Delray Beach Playhouse (2/16 - 2/19) | |
 |
FIRST DATE
Pompano Beach Cultural Center (2/6 - 2/15) | |
|
Man of La Mancha
Maltz Jupiter Theatre (3/17 - 4/5) | ||
|
Menopause The Musical 2: Cruising Through ‘The Change’®
The Parker (2/7 - 2/8) | |
|
The Phantom of the Opera
Sunrise Civic Center Theater (2/12 - 2/15) | |
|
Palm Beach Symphony Masterworks Series Concert Featuring Guest Violinist Vadim Repin
Kravis Center for the Performing Arts (3/2 - 3/2) | |
|
Experience the “Egg-cellent” Broadway Hit: Something Rotten! at Richey Suncoast Theatre
Richey Suncoast Theatre (2/13 - 2/22) | |
|
South Florida Symphony Orchestra Presents Joachim, Simon, Mozart and Rimsky-Korsakov at The Parker
The Parker (Parker Playhouse) (2/18 - 2/18) | |
|
Beetlejuice
The Raymond F. Kravis Center for the Performing Arts (6/2 - 6/7) | |
| VIEW SHOWS ADD A SHOW | ||
Get Miami Metro's #1 Theatre Newsletter
All the show news & discounts for Miami Metro & beyond.
