Cagney - The Musical at Bay Street Theater
Dates: 6/30/2026 - 7/26/2026
📍 Theatre: Bay Street Theater
1 Long Warf
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Phone: 631 725-9500
Tickets: 59.99 - 139.99
June 30—July 26, 2026
Cagney
A Hollywood-Inspired Dance Musical
Produced in association with Riki Kane Larimer
Explosive and electric, Cagney brings Hollywood legend James Cagney to the stage through rhythm, song, and movement, celebrating his classic cinematic style. Directed by Bay Street’s Associate Artistic Director Will Pomerantz (Evita and Ragtime), this high-energy dance musical celebrates the grit, charisma, and swagger that made Cagney an icon of the silver screen. The score blends original songs with beloved tunes by George M. Cohan, paying tribute to Cagney’s vaudeville roots and patriotic flair.
News About Cagney - The Musical at Bay Street Theater
July 07, 2026
Video: Watch Highlights from CAGNEY THE MUSICAL at Bay Street Theater
July 02, 2026 CAGNEY THE MUSICAL is now on stage at Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor, with Robert Creighton starring as Hollywood legend James Cagney through July 26. Watch in this video.
CAGNEY THE MUSICAL to Offer Pay What You Can Performance at Bay Street Theater
June 25, 2026 Bay Street Theater announced a Pay What You Can performance for CAGNEY THE MUSICAL, starring Robert Creighton and Melissa Manchester, available day-of and in-person only at the Sag Harbor box office.
Video: Robert Creighton Gives an Inside Look Into CAGNEY THE MUSICAL at Bay Street Theater
June 18, 2026 Bay Street Theater is presenting Cagney The Musical, the high-energy musical celebration of Hollywood legend James Cagney, on the Mainstage in Sag Harbor. Get a sneak peek inside the production from star Robert Creighton.
Cast Set For CAGNEY at Bay Street Theater
June 17, 2026 Bay Street Theater announced Robert Creighton and Grammy winner Melissa Manchester will lead the cast of CAGNEY THE MUSICAL in Sag Harbor, with Creighton reprising his role as James Cagney in the musical he co-created.
Bay Street Theater Launches 'Going Solo' Initiative for Solo Theatergoers This Summer
May 06, 2026 Bay Street Theater announced 'Going Solo,' a new initiative offering solo attendees a complimentary wine reception and hosted pre-show gathering on select Friday evenings, beginning with MISTER HALSTON.
CAGNEY THE MUSICAL Adds Melissa Manchester To Cast At Bay Street Theater
April 14, 2026 Grammy Award-winning singer and actress Melissa Manchester will join the cast of CAGNEY THE MUSICAL at Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor, NY, playing the role of Ma Cagney in the 2026 Summer Mainstage Season.
DEAR EVAN HANSEN And More Set for Bay Street Theater 2026 Summer Mainstage Lineup
February 10, 2026 Bay Street Theater has announced its lineup for the 2026 Summer Mainstage Season, featuring a series of compelling productions set to captivate audiences in Sag Harbor.About the Theatre
🌙 Make a Night of It
Loading nearby places…
Bay Street Theater Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ
What shows are coming up next at Bay Street Theater?
The Streisand Effect: Melissa Sings Barbra (08/01/26-08/01/26)
Harlem Gospel Choir: Music Mondays (08/01/26-08/01/26)
Dear Evan Hansen (08/04/26-08/29/26)
Melissa Errico: The Streisand Effect | Bay Street Theater, Sag Harbor (08/17/26-08/17/26)
Bonkers in the Boroughs (09/01/26-09/06/26)
Where is Bay Street Theater located?
What shows have played recently at Bay Street Theater?
Cagney The Musical (06/30/26-07/26/26)
David Koechner Live Comedy (06/27/26-06/27/26)
Mister Halston (06/02/26-06/21/26)
Talk of The Town (05/23/26-05/23/26)
Dazed & Confused: A Tribute to Led Zeppelin (02/28/26-02/28/26)
Ha Ha Hamptons Comedy Tour = Valentine's Edition (02/14/26-02/14/26)
That Motown Band (02/08/26-02/08/26)
Radio Alanis (02/07/26-02/07/26)
|
Ain't Too Proud - The Life and Times of The Temptations The Gateway Performing Arts Center of Suffolk County (6/19-7/19) |
|
THE WEDDING SINGER The John W. Engeman Theater (7/09-8/23) |
|
I Hate Hamlet by Paul Rudnick South Shore Theatre (8/16-8/16) |
|
Disney Pixar’s Coco in Concert – Live to Film Staller Center for the Arts (10/30-10/30) |
|
I Hate Hamlet South Shore Theatre (8/14-8/14) |
|
The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show The Dinner Detective Long Island (8/22-8/22) |
|
Tilles Jazz Fest 2026 Tilles Center for the Performing Arts Long Island University (7/18-7/18) |
|
The 31st Annual Stony Brook Film Festival Staller Center for the Arts (7/16-7/25) |
|
South Shore Theatre Experience present 15th Annual One Act Festival South Shore Theatre (9/03-9/03) |
|
|
Cagney - The Musical Bay Street Theater (6/30-7/26) |