Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: CHARLES DICKENS' A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Theatre Three

By:
Review: CHARLES DICKENS' A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Theatre Three

To paraphrase/customize the first line in the show... the show is wonderful to begin with; there is no doubt about that. Theatre Three's 38th annual production of the iconic Charles Dickens tale A Christmas Carol has certainly become a beautiful tradition on Long Island. Even with slight changes throughout the years, this ageless production is as spectacular as ever. Jeffrey Sanzel, the Artistic Director of the Port Jefferson venue, directs the dazzling play running through December 30th.

Mr. Sanzel, a pillar of the Long Island theater community, also stars as our favorite miserable miser, Ebenezer Scrooge. As we know, the story takes place on the night of Christmas Eve through Christmas morning when the... shall we say... frugal Mr. Scrooge is visited by three ghosts in an attempt to save his greedy soul from an eternity of shackles and chains. Among the ghosts that visit him are Jacob Marley (Mr. Scrooge's deceased business partner) and the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Present, and Yet To Come. Mr. Sanzel's outstanding performance of the role from being crotchety to ultimately finding the Christmas spirit is always inspiring; really the best around.

Also among the cast, Theatre Three regular Stephen T. Wangner, is excellent as Jacob Marley. Everything from Marley's appearance to entrance is slightly different from year to year and Mr. Wangner delivers with thrilling intensity. The Ghost of Christmas Past is strongly portrayed by Danielle Pafundi whose powerful and commanding performance is one you will remember for quite some time. Getting the most laughs indeed is Scott Hofer who is completely charming as the "cheeky" Ghost of Christmas Present. As for the The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come, that costume is operated this year by Theatre Three vet Sean Amato. And yes, I said operated. In one of the most elaborate and remarkable of costumes, the faceless undertaker-like ghost stands almost to the top of the stage. Surrounded by fog, a ragged black wrap drapes around him as he maneuvers and his arms open brusquely to the sound of thunder as he is taking Scrooge through his potential future. It is really jaw-dropping.

I really could go on and on (and on and on), but you can probably tell that the entire company is truly extraordinary with the vast majority of the hard working cast taking on several roles each.

On Mr. Sanzel's creative team, Randall Parsons' set is well done. The large stage has concealed sections and rolling pieces that make for seamless scene changes. Well, that and also because this production is a well-oiled machine after thirty eight years. This is cleverly enhanced by Robert W. Henderson, Jr's atmospheric lighting and Mr. Parsons' stunning costumes. You'll notice the costumes change very slightly from year to year, but you still get that 19th century aura. If you have seen previous productions, you will also notice that some music has been added which is a lovely touch.

And so, if you haven't seen Theatre Three's incarnation of Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol in a while - or if you haven't seen at all - go see it. And perhaps it could be a new tradition with your loved ones. The classic story and this superb cast will surely get you into the Christmas spirit.

Photo by Ana McCasland

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on Theatre Three
Recent Articles
Review: YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN at Theatre Three
Review: YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN at Theatre Three
5/19/2026

Reader Reviews

Don't Miss a Long Island News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


Ain't Too Proud - The Life and Times of The Temptations in Long Island Ain't Too Proud - The Life and Times of The Temptations
The Gateway Performing Arts Center of Suffolk County (6/19-7/19)
THE WEDDING SINGER in Long Island THE WEDDING SINGER
The John W. Engeman Theater (7/09-8/23)
Jessica Vosk: Sleigh in Long Island Jessica Vosk: Sleigh
Staller Center for the Arts (12/11-12/11)
Jennifer Frautschi & Christina Dahl in Concert in Long Island Jennifer Frautschi & Christina Dahl in Concert
Staller Center for the Arts (10/28-10/28)
Bonkers in the Boroughs in Long Island Bonkers in the Boroughs
Bay Street Theater (9/01-9/06)
Klea Blackhurst & Billy Stritch - Dreaming of a Song: The Music of Hoagy Carmichael in Long Island Klea Blackhurst & Billy Stritch - Dreaming of a Song: The Music of Hoagy Carmichael
LTV Studios (7/18-7/18)
Urinetown the musical in Long Island Urinetown the musical
South Shore Theatre (7/23-7/23)
Streetlight the Musical in Concert in Long Island Streetlight the Musical in Concert
Tilles Center Concert Hall (7/23-7/23)
Drinking Habits in Long Island Drinking Habits
Theatre Box (7/24-8/02)
Alison Krauss and Union Station at Flagstar in Long Island Alison Krauss and Union Station at Flagstar
Westbury Music Fair (7/10-7/10)