Skip to main content Skip to footer site map
Review: IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE At Beef & Boards: A Sparkling Holiday Classic

Review: IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE At Beef & Boards: A Sparkling Holiday Classic

On stage through December 23rd.

The holiday season brings with it many familiar sights, sounds, smells, and of course, beloved cinematic and stage treasures like IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE. Beef & Boards chose a true gem to get every audience member into the right spirit while always recalling what's truly important and truly worth fighting for: each other.

Celeste:

I must confess, IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE was never the chosen Christmas classic growing up at my house, so I came in with less nostalgic feelings and more a general sense of the themes. Most seasonal favorites have familiar elements, like family, friends, and kinship. But there's a reason this is the recipe for most holiday stories: it works! IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE brings a sense of empathy and warmth. It reminds its audience members that too many decisions are made with the bottom dollar in mind. And it also reminds us that our decisions, good and bad, have far more ripple effects than we can ever imagine.

The play rests heavily on the shoulders of whoever plays George Bailey, and Logan Moore is the perfect man for the job. He even perfected the iconic accent of Mr. Bailey. I've been lucky enough to see him in a few Beef & Boards productions now, and he has an impressive range and diversity in his onstage delivery. He brings the audience into his family and his psyche just as well as he grabs the attention of his guardian angel, Clarence.

Clarence is another pivotal role not only because he's an angel but also because he helps us as audience members create a connection with George. Don Farrell as Clarence handled this challenge with grace and a nice dash of humor. Farrell is childlike and effusive in his role but also grounded. That is a hard balance to strike when you need to be both wise and a little bumbling.

As an audience member, it pains me to mention Mr. Potter, but as a reviewer, I have to give a bow to the villain played so well by Dan Scharbrough. He was the character you loved to hate, and that's not always an easy task. He was so believable as a money-grubbing but seemingly level-headed businessman. After all, he wraps up his proposals in pretty packages with lots of money involved, but his complete disdain for the humanity around him makes him entirely abhorrent.

Beef & Boards has brought the spirit of the season to light-and they've done it so well that tickets are nearly all sold out! You can check their website for the coveted remaining seats, and you can also look ahead to their upcoming season.

Dylan:

The sentimental, emotional fantasy was originally produced and directed by Frank Capra and the movie was based on "The Greatest Gift," a Phillip Van Doren Stern short story. The movie, which starred Jimmy Stewart as George Bailey and Henry Travers as Clarence, has come to be one of the most cherished in American cinema. Remarkably, it was actually a financial flop at the movie box office, and only years later did it turn out to be mandatory Christmas TV watching.

It's a Wonderful Life was filled with emotion. From Mr. Gower (played by Douglas E. Stark) nearly losing everything with one blunder to George's (Logan Moore) final resolve that he's "worth more dead than alive". And I can't forget about Potter, the furious, merciless robber baron with a thorn in his side named Bailey. The show was at its best when Dan Scharbrough's Potter and Bill Book's Uncle Billy were on the stage together. Scharbrough played Potter with a growl and feeling appropriate to the character, and an earnestness of movement and conversation that instilled his superiority over, well, everyone else. On the other end of the field is Book's Billy, forgetful and unfocused, caring and loving, a character ultimately the most lovable of the group. Logan Moore had the most difficult challenge of the night, playing George Bailey, a role memorialized by the great Jimmy Stewart. And here's where I had actually the least trouble distinguishing the show from the film. Moore's Bailey was over the top emotionally but in the perfect way, from lassoing the moon to reaching his final breaking point. It's nearly difficult to replicate that kind of performance as an actor, especially when you're not, in fact, trying to duplicate it, but to make the character your own. I found myself very happy with the amount of despair, and I found Moore's performance entertaining. George Bailey is the guy you root for, and Moore definitely made him that.

It's a Wonderful Life was packed with nostalgia. There was a propensity to compare the play to the film, and it's reasonable. At a minimum, if you've seen the film, it's a satisfying revisiting of arguably the most popular Christmas movie. At it's best, the production of It's a Wonderful Life at Beef & Boards was a classical tale of family, friends, community, and underestimating how much impact a single human can have on the lives of so many others. If you go to see this production for either of these, you won't be disappointed.

It's an important anniversary for Beef & Boards in 2023: 50 years of bringing professional theater productions to Indianapolis! In honor of this incredible achievement, they have planned a diverse and exciting season lineup. There are familiar shows, like BEAUTY AND THE BEAST, and fun new additions, like CLUE. You can buy your tickets now, consider a gift certificate as a gift, or even invest in their VIP membership for perks like discounts on next season's holiday classic, WHITE CHRISTMAS. Don't miss out on your chance to enjoy what's sure to be a memorable season!



Broadway In Indianapolis & Sun King Announce Custom MR. PINKY Brew To Celebrate HAIRSP Photo
Broadway in Indianapolis and Sun King Brewery has announced the creation of Mr. Pinky, an exclusive Sun King brew to celebrate the upcoming engagement of HAIRSPRAY in Indianapolis February 21-26 at Old National Centre. 

Review: WILD HORSES at the Phoenix Theatre Photo
What did our critiA one-woman show starring two of Indy’s finest leading ladies, Wild Horses is a fascinating concept with a big payoff. Constance Macy and Jen Johansen rotate nights for their performances in the coming-of-age story. The one-act play flies by because it feels like chatting with an old friend who’s regaling you with stories from her past. From first crushes to alcohol concoctions only the underaged would dare to drink, the show captures the electric, reckless feel of youth.c think of WILD HORSES at Phoenix Theatre?

Art 4 Announces 2023 Season Featuring Three Full-Length Productions Photo
The word is out! Art 4 has announced their 2023 Season featuring three full-length productions. The company opens its 6th Season with GODSPELL by four-time Grammy winner, and Golden Globe winner Stephen Schwartz and John-Michael Tebelak.

Winners Announced For The 2022 BroadwayWorld Indianapolis Awards Photo
The winners have been announced for the 2022 BroadwayWorld Indianapolis Awards, honoring the best in regional productions, touring shows, and more which had their first performance between October 1, 2021 through September 30, 2022.


From This Author - The Marriage Matinee

The Marriage Matinee is the joint effort of Mr. and Mrs. Caraker, newlyweds who live in Indianapolis, Indiana. Now that they’ve formed the bond of holy matrimony, they’re hoping to form... (read more about this author)


Review: A CHRISTMAS STORY, THE MUSICAL Brings the Holiday Spirit at Civic TheatreReview: A CHRISTMAS STORY, THE MUSICAL Brings the Holiday Spirit at Civic Theatre
December 6, 2022

A Christmas Story, the Musical reimagines the 1983 holiday movie masterpiece with boisterous songs and dance that brought new life and excellent vocals to the season. Loving fans, rest easy. Joseph Robinette’s adaption, directed by Emily Rogge Tzucker, brightens iconic scenes and characters and enhances the humor. The lamp, the flag pole, and the turkey-mad Bumpus Hounds are all there.

Review: A (Happy) Holiday: A Festive Season ReimaginedReview: A (Happy) Holiday: A Festive Season Reimagined
December 6, 2022

It’s the holiday season and all reviewers are going to their required holiday shows... You know... Elf, A Christmas Story, A Christmas Carol. It's the same stuff, different year. Not this show. This is a brand new show by a unique writers' room collaboration called A (Happy) Holiday. Feeling down or out by the holidays while everyone one else around you has holiday cheer? This is the show for you. It's got everything -- singing, dancing, a unique story, and a drag queen. Who could honestly want more?

Review: IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE At Beef & Boards: A Sparkling Holiday ClassicReview: IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE At Beef & Boards: A Sparkling Holiday Classic
November 28, 2022

The holiday season brings with it many familiar sights, sounds, smells, and of course, beloved cinematic and stage treasures like IT’S A WONDERFUL LIFE. Beef & Boards chose a true gem to get every audience member into the right spirit while always recalling what’s truly important and truly worth fighting for: each other.

Review: Caves and Worlds of Wonder in ALADDIN at Clowes Memorial HallReview: Caves and Worlds of Wonder in ALADDIN at Clowes Memorial Hall
November 22, 2022

For all those growing up watching Disney movies, and for the kids who absolutely loved Aladdin, the Genie and Princess Jasmine or even Abu, this is a must-watch! Big band, big sound, big show — with enough energy to light up a few thousand lamps.

Review: Have You Heard? ANASTASIA Brings Indy Audiences to Their FeetReview: Have You Heard? ANASTASIA Brings Indy Audiences to Their Feet
October 20, 2022

The rumors are true: ANASTASIA has finally made its way to Indianapolis. You may be thinking it’s just another movie turned musical, but there are new twists and turns to this rendition of the beloved animated film. There’s the romance, the legend of Anastasia, the glittering costumes and crowns, but there’s also battles with personal principles and a sense of national pride that leaves people emotionally and morally torn. In short, it has it all.