Skip to main content
Vote for the BWW Columbus Awards
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Columbus Theater Reviews

The latest reviews and critic recommendations from Columbus.

Feature: INTO THE WOODS at Short North Stage

Feature: INTO THE WOODS at Short North Stage

by Paul Batterson — March 9, 2023

After reciting the 'The Witch's Entrance' for 19 shows in Short North Stage's production of INTO THE WOODS, Diana DeGarmo may never look at a salad the same way again.

Review: SLAVE PLAY at Short North Stage

Review: SLAVE PLAY at Short North Stage

by Paul Batterson — February 5, 2023

What did our critic think of SLAVE PLAY at Short North Stage? People always ask critics two questions: “did you like it?” and “is it worth seeing?” When it comes time to discuss SLAVE PLAY, these two questions are going to be tough to answer.

Review: THE PRICE OF POWER at Abbey Theater Of Dublin

Review: THE PRICE OF POWER at Abbey Theater Of Dublin

by Paul Batterson — January 17, 2023

What did our critic think of THE PRICE OF POWER at Abbey Theater Of Dublin? As the director of THE PRICE OF POWER, Abbey Theater of Dublin director Joe Bishara is up against an interesting challenge.

Interview: ELF: THE MUSICAL at Palace Theater

Interview: ELF: THE MUSICAL at Palace Theater

by Paul Batterson — December 7, 2022

Most Christmas shows seem to follow a simple pattern: Someone doesn't have that festive spirit meets someone who does, a miracle happens, and the bah humbuger sees the joy in the holidays.

Review: VETSAID at Nationwide Arena

Review: VETSAID at Nationwide Arena

by Paul Batterson — November 16, 2022

What did our critic think of VETSAID at Nationwide Arena? When the Eagles appeared in Columbus for the 'The History of the Eagles' tour, the members of the band appeared in nearly identical black suits.

BWW Review: HAIRSPRAY at Ohio Theatre - An Inspiring Musical with Blazing Energy

BWW Review: HAIRSPRAY at Ohio Theatre - An Inspiring Musical with Blazing Energy

by Christina Mancuso — November 9, 2022

The audience was thrilled to welcome home Columbus’s own sextuple superstar, Andrew Levitt aka Nina West, who has successfully conquered the entertainment genres of TV, film, theatre, music, web series, and most recently as an author of children’s book, “The You Kind of Kind.

Review: THE WHO at Schottenstein Center

Review: THE WHO at Schottenstein Center

by Paul Batterson — October 12, 2022

What did our critic think of THE WHO at Schottenstein Cente? When the Who, a 1990 inductee to the Rock-N-Roll Hall of Fame, announced their current 'The Who Hits Back' tour, the response of many 'fans' on one website was a hard pass.

Review: HAMILTON at Ohio Theatre

Review: HAMILTON at Ohio Theatre

by Paul Batterson — October 10, 2022

What did our critic think of HAMILTON at Ohio Theatre? Before the lights fade and the curtain parts on HAMILTON at the Ohio Theatre, the audience receives a message from King George (Peter Matthew Smith) reminding them to shut off their cell phones and to enjoy 'MY show.

Review: REVIEW: DISNEY'S NEWSIES at Southern Theatre

Review: REVIEW: DISNEY'S NEWSIES at Southern Theatre

by Paul Batterson — September 26, 2022

What did our critic think of REVIEW: DISNEY’S NEWSIES at Southern Theatre? Aristotle is credited with coming up with the phrase, 'the whole is greater than the sum of its parts.

Review: ERIC CLAPTON at Schottenstein Center

Review: ERIC CLAPTON at Schottenstein Center

by Paul Batterson — September 9, 2022

What did our critic think of ERIC CLAPTON R at Schottenstein Cente? In Rolling Stone's countdown of the top 100 guitarists, the late Eddie Van Halen described Eric Clapton as 'basically the only guitar player who influenced me - even though I don't sound like him.

Feature: TICK, TICK … BOOM at Garden Theater

Feature: TICK, TICK … BOOM at Garden Theater

by Paul Batterson — September 6, 2022

What did our critic think of TICK, TICK … BOOM at Garden Theater? No actors will be waiting in the wings when the curtain goes up on the Short North Stage's production of TICK, TICK .

Review: ROGER WATERS' THIS IS NOT A DRILL at Nationwide Arena

Review: ROGER WATERS' THIS IS NOT A DRILL at Nationwide Arena

by Paul Batterson — August 15, 2022

What did our critic think of ROGER WATERS' THIS IS NOT A DRILL at Nationwide Arena? A little mini drama took place at the will call window moments before Roger Waters was scheduled to take the stage for his 'This is not a drill' concert on Aug.

Review: OTTERBEIN'S PIRATES OF PENZANCE  at Cowen Hall

Review: OTTERBEIN'S PIRATES OF PENZANCE at Cowen Hall

by Paul Batterson — July 14, 2022

What did our critic think of BWW REVIEWS: OTTERBEIN’S PIRATES OF PENZANCE at Cowen Hall? Otterbein University offers a much-needed refresher course in Gilbert and Sullivan with its presentation of THE PIRATES OF PENZANCE for its final production of the summer season.

BWW Review: WICKED Flies High at the Ohio Theatre

BWW Review: WICKED Flies High at the Ohio Theatre

by Christina Mancuso — May 20, 2022

Winning more than 100 international awards including three Tony Awards and a Grammy Award, WICKED has managed to cast its spell on more than 60 million people across the globe for nearly two decades, and is still going strong today.

BWW Review: AJR at Value City Arena

BWW Review: AJR at Value City Arena

by Paul Batterson — May 16, 2022

At AJR's May 13 concert at Value City Arena, Jack Met estimated he and his brothers Ryan and Adam Brett have played Columbus the second most out of any city behind their native home, New York City.

BroadwayWorld TV


The Launch: A Senior Cabaret in Columbus The Launch: A Senior Cabaret
Fritsche Theatre at Cowan Hall (12/06-12/06)
Mr. Scrooge in Columbus Mr. Scrooge
Riffe Center Studio One (12/04-12/23)
Holiday Hoopla in Columbus Holiday Hoopla
Shadowbox Live (11/19-12/26)
Dinner Detective Columbus in Columbus Dinner Detective Columbus
Embassy Suites Columbus (12/05-12/05)
Disney's Beauty and the Beast in Columbus Disney's Beauty and the Beast
Ohio Theatre (1/30-2/07)
Dinner Detective Columbus in Columbus Dinner Detective Columbus
Embassy Suites Columbus (12/12-12/12)
Rock of Ages in Columbus Rock of Ages
Fritsche Theatre at Cowan Hall (11/19-11/22)
The Ultimate Holiday Game Show in Columbus The Ultimate Holiday Game Show
Roth/Resler Theater (12/10-12/13)
Wicked in Columbus Wicked
Ohio Theatre (7/28-8/15)
Romeo and Juliet in Columbus Romeo and Juliet
Fritsche Theatre at Cowan Hall (2/11-2/20)