Skip to main content Skip to footer site map
Review: ROGER WATERS' THIS IS NOT A DRILL at Nationwide Arena

Review: ROGER WATERS' THIS IS NOT A DRILL at Nationwide Arena

Despite political undertones, Pink Floyd co-founder puts on amazing production

So ya thought ya might like to go to the show?

A little mini drama took place at the will call window moments before Roger Waters was scheduled to take the stage for his "This is not a drill" concert on Aug. 10 at Nationwide Arena (200 West Nationwide Boulevard in downtown Columbus). A mother and son were trying to straighten out a ticket purchase and she repeatedly asked her son, "Do you really want to see this? Do you really want to see this?"

One sincerely hopes they stuck it out. Waters, the architect and co-founder of Pink Floyd, put on another spectacle that bounced across the realms of a rock concert, a musical theater production, and a political rally. And by the end of it, most who attended were glad they came.

Midway through his 23-song, two-hour-plus concert, Waters noted there were only patches of attendees up in the Nationwide Arena nosebleed sections. The 78-year-old singer mused wryly, "Well this may not have been a sell-out, but at least, we never sold out."

Pink Floyd followers who decided not to attend the show may regret it for years to come. The theater-in-the-round staging of the show was brilliant. By placing the stage in the middle of the floor of Nationwide Arena, the audience always had a musician performing right in front of them regardless of where their seats were.

Waters put together an excellent supporting cast of guitarists Dave Kilminster and Jonathan Wilson, bassist Gus Seyffert, keyboard player and guitarist Jon Carin, sax player Seamus Blake and backup singers Amanda Belair and Shanay Johnson as well as a stunning multi-media screen show. The band charged through the Pink Floyd catalog with Waters' solo works dispersed throughout the setlist. Fittingly, a wave of audience produced smog descended around the stage as Waters opened the show with "Comfortably Numb." He then followed that with "The Happiest Days of Our Lives" and "Another Brick in the Wall, Part 2 and Part 3" before throwing in "The Powers That Be" from his 1987 solo album "Radio K.A.O.S." Waters and company closed out the first set with a quartet of can't miss classics, "Have a Cigar," "Wish You Were Here," "Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts VI-IX)" and "Sheep." During "Sheep," the last song of the front end of the concert, a gigantic floating wooly dirigible was set free to bounce around the concert hall.

The sheep, a nod to the mindless followers of Snowball in George Orwell's Animal Farm, was not the only floating farm animal to make an appearance. In the second half of the show, a soaring sow hovered above the crowd as the band powered through "In the Flesh," "Run Like Hell," "Money" and "Us and Them."

While the show was a musical and visual masterpiece, it was not without a fair share of irony. This goes well beyond the fact Waters blasts greed on songs like "Money" and yet has ticket prices for his front row seats ranging in the four digits and concert jackets for sale for over $200.

Introducing the first part of his new song "The Bar," Waters said he wanted this show to be like a neighborhood pub where people could gather and discuss the news of the day. And yet, before the show, an enormous message board announced, "If you're here because you like Pink Floyd but you can't stand Roger Waters' politics, f*ck off to the bar." It's easy to have an open-minded exchange of ideas when you're the only one holding a microphone.

Throughout the concert, the audience was exposed to images of politicians as diverse as Ronald Reagan to Joe Biden with accounts of their various "war crimes." Underneath the picture of Barack Obama was the accusation that he increased the use of drone warfare. Later, Waters called for the end of the use of drones as weapons. However, both his flying sheep and pig were powered by ... drones.

In a concert filled with images of police violence and nuclear war, perhaps the darkest moment was Waters' parading in Gestapo-like gear to portray a character for the song, "In the Flesh." The persona sings about "who let all the riff raff" into the concert hall and then he closes the song with the line, "If I had my way, I'd have all of them shot." Then he took out a prop machine gun and open fired on the crowd. (Afterward, the audience applauded.) One concert goer joked with a friend, "I can't imagine that going over well during his Berlin concert." The friend retorted, "I can't imagine that going over well ... anywhere."

Waters left the arena with his merry band marching through a section of the crowd, playing the fitting "Outside the Wall:" And some gathered together in bands/The bleeding hearts and the artists make their stand/And when they've given you their all/Some stagger and fall/after all it's not easy/Banging your heart against some mad bugger's wall." Whether one agrees with Roger Waters' politics or not, one truth remains firmly in place: the guy puts on an unforgettable show.




From This Author - Paul Batterson


Interview: HAMILTON at Ohio TheaterInterview: HAMILTON at Ohio Theater
October 3, 2022

When Tyler Belo looks at his final transcripts from Five Towns College in Dix Hills, New York, it is always the D+ in general economics that makes him smile. Belo barely passed the class because he opted out on the final to crash an equity-only tryout for HAMILTON.

Review: REVIEW: DISNEY'S NEWSIES at Southern TheatreReview: REVIEW: DISNEY'S NEWSIES at Southern Theatre
September 26, 2022

What did our critic think of REVIEW: DISNEY’S NEWSIES at Southern Theatre? Aristotle is credited with coming up with the phrase, 'the whole is greater than the sum of its parts.' Had he witnessed the Columbus Children Theatre's production of DISNEY'S NEWSIES, the philosopher may have reversed the quotation to 'the parts are greater than the sum of the whole.' An energetic cast, sharp management by director Joe Deer and choreographer Vincent Sylvester, and tight orchestration by musical director Lara Brooks lifted a cheesy musical to stellar heights.

RENT Comes To Short North Stage October 6thRENT Comes To Short North Stage October 6th
September 21, 2022

No day but today! Rent is the landmark, groundbreaking rock musical that defined a generation and Short North Stage is staging an exciting new production for Columbus audiences. In the East Village of New York City we follow an unlikely group of bohemians as they struggle with gentrification, love, loss and legacies amidst the HIV/AIDS crisis. Winner of the Tony Award® and the Pulitzer Prize, Jonathan Larson's songs like 'Seasons of Love,' 'One Song Glory,' and 'I'll Cover You,' allows the characters and audiences to embrace hope, find strength and survive. You won't want to miss Larson's phenomenon that redefined musical theater and is just as poignant today. Light a candle and join us for the catered Opening Night Reception Friday, October 7th following the performance! Get your tickets at www.cbusarts.com or call 614-469-0939 Monday thru Friday 9am - 5pm.. Single tickets range between $37 and $55, $20 student rush tickets and pay what you can tickets are also available. Showtimes are 7pm Thursdays through Saturdays and 2pm Sundays October 6 - November 6. Learn more at www.shortnorthstage.org.

Review: TICK, TICK … BOOM at Garden TheaterReview: TICK, TICK … BOOM at Garden Theater
September 12, 2022

What did our critic think of TICK, TICK … BOOM at Garden Theater? Rarely can one sum up the message of an entire musical in three words. However, composer and lyricist Jonathan Larson sums up the message of TICK, TICK ... BOOM! in three words found in the middle of the song, 'Johnny Can't Decide:' compromise or persevere.

Review: ERIC CLAPTON at Schottenstein CenterReview: ERIC CLAPTON at Schottenstein Center
September 9, 2022

What did our critic think of ERIC CLAPTON R at Schottenstein Cente? In Rolling Stone's countdown of the top 100 guitarists, the late Eddie Van Halen described Eric Clapton as 'basically the only guitar player who influenced me - even though I don't sound like him. There was a basic simplicity to his playing, his style, his vibe and his sound. His solos were melodic and memorable - and that's what guitar solos should be.'