Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

SundanceTV Launches TRUE CRIME STORY Franchise

In six, one-hour episodes, It Couldn’t Happen Here will put a spotlight on fascinating small-town American crime stories.

SundanceTV Launches TRUE CRIME STORY Franchise

Building off of the recent success of critically acclaimed limited true crime series including The Preppy Murder: Death In Central Park, NO ONE SAW A THING and Jonestown: Terror In the Jungle and the continuing strong performance of off network crime dramas, AMC Networks' SundanceTV announced the commission of its first true crime franchise. The "True Crime Story" franchise will focus on telling a wide variety of true crime stories from unique perspectives.

The first two series announced under the "True Crime Story" banner are It Couldn't Happen Here hosted by New York Times Best-Selling Author Hilarie Burton Morgan (One Tree Hill, The Walking Dead, Friday Night in with The Morgans), which premieres Thursday, September 9, and Indefensible hosted by Academy Award nominee Jena Friedman (The Daily Show) premiering Thursday, October 14 on SundanceTV and AMC+, AMC Networks premium streaming bundle. AMC Studios Content Distribution is managing worldwide sales. In six, one-hour episodes, It Couldn't Happen Here will put a spotlight on fascinating small-town AMERICAN CRIME stories that demonstrate how crime impacts these tight-knit communities in unique and surprising ways. In six, 30-minute episodes, Indefensible looks into cases where the outcome is shaped by more than what initially meets the eye, and in the process brings something new and entirely unexpected to the genre.

In It Couldn't Happen Here, life-long small-town community member and advocate Hilarie Burton Morgan visits different small towns in an effort to shine a much-needed light on the unique ways in which crime impacts rural communities and their judicial systems. Too often the heartbreaking events in these towns are largely overlooked because they lack the national media platforms and advocacy resources found in larger cities. In each episode, Hilarie hears the facts of the case from family members and local insiders in an attempt to understand the challenges the community faced investigating the crime, learn the lasting impact the crime has had on the fabric of the town, and ultimately call attention to where justice currently stands. Hilarie embraces these communities, where many know not just the victims, but the perpetrators and those who enable them.

In Indefensible, Jena Friedman travels the country to unspool real cases on the ground, but unlike most true crime shows, this one doesn't end when the criminal gets locked up. Jena finds there's always more to the story and drives to a different outcome beyond the simple whodunnit. Using her unflinching comedic point of view and disarming interview skills, Jena uncovers the "why" and "how" not only of crimes themselves, but of our sometimes dysfunctional criminal justice system.

"Some of the most memorable programs on SundanceTV in recent years have focused on true crime stories, as we've built the category into an important part of the network's brand," said Blake Callaway, general manager of SundanceTV, IFC and BBC America. "Working with Hilarie Burton Morgan and Jena Friedman to bring their talents and points of view to this new franchise is an exciting next step. We can't wait to share these two new series that will offer a unique take on the genre this fall."

Hilarie Burton Morgan said, "Advocating for small towns has been the primary focus of my adult life, whether it's fighting for mom and pop shops, or public schools or facilities like Astor Services. I believe deeply in the value of these small communities. Last year, my husband and I were able to team with the AMC family to shed light on a number of the struggles our community was facing during Covid, as we had local friends and neighbors from the Hudson Valley on as guests for our show "Friday Night In with the Morgans." Continuing my relationship with the AMC family at SundanceTV and digging deeper into the issues that are specific to small towns is a mission that I'm honored to be part of."

Jena Friedman said, "Many Americans DON'T think about our criminal justice system until they're in it. I hope this show gives viewers insight into some of the ways in which the system is flawed, so at the very least, they'll be a little more prepared in the event they ever end up on a jury."

Hilarie Burton Morgan is the author of The New York Times best-selling book "The Rural Diaries" and runs the production company Mischief Farm with her husband Jeffrey Dean Morgan. She has also established a loyal fan base for her acting roles, including Peyton Sawyer on the hit CW series One Tree Hill, which she recently reunited with her co-stars Sophia Bush and Bethany Joy Lenz to launch "Drama Queens," a record-breaking Podcast for iHeartRadio. Additionally, Burton Morgan appeared in a highly-rated episode The Walking Dead, starred in and produced AMC's weekly talk show Friday Night with the Morgans, Council of Dads, Lethal Weapon, White Collar, Grey's Anatomy, and produced and starred in numerous Lifetime and Hallmark holiday films.

Jena Friedman is a comedian and filmmaker. Her credits include THE DAILY SHOW WITH JON STEWART and The Late Show with David Letterman. She's a contributing writer to The New Yorker and has appeared on such programs as The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, Conan on TBS, THE NIGHTLY SHOW WITH LARRY WILMORE and most recently in the Sundance hit movie Palm Springs, now on Hulu.

Produced by Bungalow Media + Entertainment, It Couldn't Happen Here's executive producers are Robert Friedman, Liz Yale Marsh, and Mike Powers for Bungalow Media + Entertainment as well as Hilarie Burton Morgan for Mischief Farm, Liz DeCesare and Meg Mortimer for Authentic Management Productions, and Po Kutchins.

Produced by Left/Right, Indefensible's executive producers are Jena Friedman, Ken Druckerman, Banks Tarver, Anneka Jones, and Eve Rodrick.

Related Stories View More TV Stories
Everything You Need to Know About the WICKED Movie Photo
It's a guide to the Wicked movie. The hit Broadway musical Wicked is officially coming to the big screen! BroadwayWorld collected all the information we could about the upcoming film - including who's starring, what roles haven't yet been cast, and what will change from stage to screen.

HOLLYWOOD UNEXPECTED With Jessica Ross Premieres April 21 On The XOTV Network Photo
Premiering April 21st, Hollywood Unexpected with Jessica Ross is an Award-winning reality show that follows the journey of actress Jessica Ross into her dramatic and often crazy life, which centers around Hollywood and what happens behind the scenes. It reveals the ambitions, the disappointments, the ups and downs of what people of every age may be experiencing.

Bravo Launches New SUMMER HOUSE Spin-Off in Marthas Vineyard Photo
Bravo heads north to an exclusive enclave with “Summer House: Martha’s Vineyard,” featuring Nicholas “Nick” Arrington, Jasmine Ellis Cooper, Silas Cooper, Jordan Emanuel, Bria Fleming, Shanice Henderson, Amir Lancaster, Jason Lyke, Preston Mitchum, Summer Marie Thomas, and Alex Tyree. Watch the video trailer now!

Scoop: FARMER WANTS A WIFE on FOX - Wednesday, April 5, 2023 Photo
Get all the scoop on FARMER WANTS A WIFE, airing on FOX on Wednesday, April 5, 2023! This week, the farmers and their dates head to South Carolina to attend a demolition derby and to catch up at the derby tailgate, where one of the women reveals she kissed her farmer before any of the others. Watch a video clip now!

From This Author - Sarah Jae Leiber

Lin-Manuel Miranda To Return For HIS DARK MATERIALS Season 3 On HBOLin-Manuel Miranda To Return For HIS DARK MATERIALS Season 3 On HBO
October 6, 2022

HBO has confirmed that award-winning composer and actor Lin-Manuel Miranda will return for the third season of the fantasy drama.

Development Halts On Disney+ BEAUTY AND THE BEAST Prequel SeriesDevelopment Halts On Disney+ BEAUTY AND THE BEAST Prequel Series
February 10, 2022

A planned Beauty and the Beast musical prequel series will not move forward at Disney+.

Tony & Grammy Winner Michael Cerveris' Loose Cattle to Stream Live Performance TonightTony & Grammy Winner Michael Cerveris' Loose Cattle to Stream Live Performance Tonight
January 5, 2022

Loose Cattle, fronted by two-time Tony Award & Grammy winner Michael Cerveris and Kimberly Kaye, will stream a performance live from New Orleans tonight!

Bertie Carvel Joins THE CROWN Season Five As Tony BlairBertie Carvel Joins THE CROWN Season Five As Tony Blair
October 28, 2021

The acclaimed Netflix series, 'The Crown' has added Tony Award-winning actor Bertie Carvel to its cast in the role of British Prime Minister Tony Blair.

September 17, 2021

Inspired by true events, Everybody's Talking About Jamie follows Jamie New (Harwood), a teenager from Sheffield, who dreams of life on stage.