Skip to main content
Vote for the BWW Buffalo Awards
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
Grumpy Old Men - The Musical show poster

Grumpy Old Men - The Musical at O’Connell & Company

Dates: 2/23/2024 - 3/10/2024

📍 Theatre: O’Connell & Company


4110 Bailey Ave
Amherst, NY 14226

Phone: 716-848-0800

Tickets: $36-$38


Share

Grumpy Old Men the Musical is based on the 1993 Warner Bros. film Grumpy Old Men which starred Jack Lemmon, Walter Matthau and Ann-Margret. It tells the story of two childhood friends, John Gustafson and Max Goldman, now aging neighbors. An old grudge resurfaces when a mysterious woman moves in across the street.

Cast and Creative Team for Grumpy Old Men - The Musical at O’Connell & Company

Cast

Michael Starzynski
John Gustafson
Michael J. Galente
Max Goldman
Anne DeFazio
Ariel Truax
Christopher Wagner
Jacob Goldman
Sára Kovácsi
Melanie Norton
Pamela Rose Mangus
Sandra Snyder
John Kreuzer
Grandpa Gustafson
Christopher Andreana
Chuck Barrels
Mary Kate O’Connell
Punky Olander
Merrick Allen
Harry
Jason Francey
Tim
Bryan Sharry
Stan
Emory Redfearn
Karla
Taylor Lee Hall
Fran
Heather Casseri
Unis
Robert McKnight
Bo
Alexandra Grace Nowak
Lo

Creative Team

Steve Vaughan
Director
Terri Filips Vaughan
Choreographer
Nathanial Higgins
Music Director
Alley Griffin
Stage Manager
Scenic Designer
Elaine Heckler
Costume Designer
Jay Marks
Lighting Designer
Matt Mogensen
Props Designer

News About Grumpy Old Men - The Musical at O’Connell & Company


We have no news on this show at the current time.

About the Theatre

O’Connell & Company Instagram Facebook Twitter

4110 Bailey Ave
Amherst, NY 14226

Phone: 716-848-0800

🌙 Make a Night of It

Loading nearby places…

Similar Shows Nearby

BURN THIS

The Company Theatre of Rochester
11/8/2026 – 11/22/2026

Uncle Vanya

Road Less Traveled Theater
11/13/2026 – 12/13/2026

Epiphany

Road Less Traveled Theater
11/13/2026 – 12/13/2026

O’Connell & Company Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ

Where is O’Connell & Company located?

O’Connell & Company is at 4110 Bailey Ave, Amherst, NY.

What shows have played recently at O’Connell & Company?

What shows are coming up next at O’Connell & Company?


Alex Edelman's Just For Us in Buffalo Alex Edelman's Just For Us
CenterStage Theatre at the JCC (12/05-12/20)
SIX (Boleyn Tour) in Buffalo SIX (Boleyn Tour)
Shea's Performing Arts Center (6/08-6/13)
Broadway Bent, a fabulous benefit cabaret!  in Buffalo Broadway Bent, a fabulous benefit cabaret!
The Company Theatre of Rochester (12/18-12/18)
The Lion King in Buffalo The Lion King
Auditorium Theatre (4/28-5/16)
Songs For A Snowy Night: A Winter Cabaret in Buffalo Songs For A Snowy Night: A Winter Cabaret
Aurora Players (12/04-12/06)
Natasha, Pierre, and the Great Comet of 1812 in Buffalo Natasha, Pierre, and the Great Comet of 1812
Katherine Cornell Theatre (1/08-1/24)
David Blake Trio in Buffalo David Blake Trio
Jazz On Main (12/10-12/10)
Clifford The Big Red Dog: The Musical! in Buffalo Clifford The Big Red Dog: The Musical!
BMCC Tribeca Performing Arts Center (12/05-12/05)
The Nutcracker in Buffalo The Nutcracker
Shea's Buffalo Theatre (12/04-12/06)
Proof in Buffalo Proof
Shea's Smith Theatre (11/19-12/06)