| Distinguished Performance Award | David Alan Grier | A Soldier’s Play |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Tom Hiddleston | Betrayal |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Danyel Fulton | Broadbend, Arkansas |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Annie Golden | Broadway Bounty Hunter |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Jeffrey Bean | Dublin Carol |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Edmund Donovan | Greater Clements |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Liza Colón-Zayas | Halfway Bitches Go Straight to Heaven |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Len Cariou | Harry Townsend's Last Stand |
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | Patrice Johnson Chevannes | In Old Age |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Jonathan Groff, Christian Borle | Little Shop of Horrors |
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | Rose Byrne | Medea |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Danny Burstein | Moulin Rouge! |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Danielle Brooks | Much Ado About Nothing |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Galen Ryan Kane | Native Son |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Patrice Johnson Chevannes | runboyrun |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Jake Gyllenhaal | Sea Wall/A Life |
|
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | Raúl Esparza | Seared |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Brittney Mack | SIX |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Ato Blankson-Wood | Slave Play |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Susannah Millonzi | The Crucible |
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | Francesca Faridany | The Half-Life of Marie Curie |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Paul Hilton | The Inheritance |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Halley Feiffer | The Pain of My Belligerence |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Ato Blankson-Wood | The Rolling Stone |
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | Kate del Castillo | the way she spoke |
| Distinguished Performance Award | David Acton | The Woman in Black |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Kathryn Hunter | Timon of Athens |
| Distinguished Performance Award | April Matthis | Toni Stone |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Donnetta Lavinia Grays | Where We Stand |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Blair Underwood | A Soldier’s Play |
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | Larry Owens | A Strange Loop |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Joe Ngo | Cambodian Rock Band |
|
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | Deirdre O'Connell | Dana H |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Michael Benjamin Washington | Fires in the Mirror |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Okwui Okpokwasili | for colored girls who have considered suicide/when the rainbow is enuf |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Michael Shannon | Frankie and Johnny in the Clair de Lune |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Michael Urie | Grand Horizons |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Elizabeth Rodriguez | Halfway Bitches Go Straight to Heaven |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Lauren Patten | Jagged Little Pill |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Chris Perfetti | Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow |
|
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | Karen Olivo | Moulin Rouge! |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Tom Sturridge | Sea Wall/A Life |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Brenock O'Connor | Sing Street |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Portia | Stew |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Kate Mulgrew | The Half-Life of Marie Curie |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Jonathan Pryce | The Height of the Storm |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Marisa Tomei | The Rose Tattoo |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Ben Porter | The Woman in Black |
|
|
| Distinguished Performance Award | Adrienne Warren | Tina: The Tina Turner Musical |
| Distinguished Performance Award | Isaac Powell | West Side Story |
|
| Outstanding Production of a Musical | A Strange Loop | A Strange Loop |
| Outstanding Production of a Musical | Girl from the North Country | Girl from the North Country |
| Outstanding Production of a Musical | Jagged Little Pill | Jagged Little Pill |
| Outstanding Production of a Musical | Moulin Rouge! | Moulin Rouge! |
| Outstanding Production of a Musical | Octet | Octet |
| Outstanding Production of a Musical | Sing Street | Sing Street |
|
| Outstanding Production of a Musical | Six | Six |
| Outstanding Production of a Musical | Soft Power | Soft Power |
| Outstanding Production of a Musical | The Secret Life of Bees | The Secret Life of Bees |
| Outstanding Production of a Musical | Tina: The Tina Turner Musical | Tina: The Tina Turner Musical |
|
| Outstanding Production of a Play | Cambodian Rock Band | Cambodian Rock Band |
| Outstanding Production of a Play | Dana H | Dana H |
| Outstanding Production of a Play | Grand Horizons | Grand Horizons |
| Outstanding Production of a Play | Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow | Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow |
|
|
| Outstanding Production of a Play | one in two | one in two |
| Outstanding Production of a Play | Sea Wall/A Life | Sea Wall/A Life |
| Outstanding Production of a Play | Seared | Seared |
| Outstanding Production of a Play | Slave Play | Slave Play |
| Outstanding Production of a Play | Stew | Stew |
| Outstanding Production of a Play | The Hot Wing King | The Hot Wing King |
|
| Outstanding Production of a Play | The Inheritance | The Inheritance |
| Outstanding Production of a Play | The Michaels | The Michaels |
|
| Outstanding Revival of a Musical | Enter Laughing | Enter Laughing |
| Outstanding Revival of a Musical | Little Shop of Horrors | Little Shop of Horrors |
| Outstanding Revival of a Musical | Rock of Ages | Rock of Ages |
| Outstanding Revival of a Musical | The Unsinkable Molly Brown | The Unsinkable Molly Brown |
| Outstanding Revival of a Musical | West Side Story | West Side Story |
| Outstanding Revival of a Play | A Soldier’s Play | A Soldier’s Play |
| Outstanding Revival of a Play | Betrayal | Betrayal |
| Outstanding Revival of a Play | Fires in the Mirror | Fires in the Mirror |
|
|
|
| Outstanding Revival of a Play | for colored girls who have considered suicide/when the rainbow is enuf | for colored girls who have considered suicide/when the rainbow is enuf |
| Outstanding Revival of a Play | Frankie and Johnny in the Claire de Lune | Frankie and Johnny in the Claire de Lune |
| Outstanding Revival of a Play | Judgment Day | Judgment Day |
| Outstanding Revival of a Play | Medea | Medea |
| Outstanding Revival of a Play | Native Son | Native Son |
| Outstanding Revival of a Play | The Rose Tattoo | The Rose Tattoo |
| Outstanding Revival of a Play | The Woman in Black | The Woman in Black |
