MCC Theater's "Miscast" benefit evening was held last night at the Hammerstein Ballroom to honor theater producer Carole Shorenstein Hays (Doubt, Julius Caesar, Gem of the Ocean) for her contribution to the
The star-studded show included solo and duet performances by Broadway celebrities Mario Cantone (Laugh Whore), Michael Cerveris (Sweeney Todd), Diana DeGarmo (Hairspray), Eden Espinosa (Wicked), Felicia Fields (The Color Purple) Julian Fleischer, Ana Gasteyer (Threepenny Opera), Deborah Gibson (Cabaret), Brian D'Arcy James (The Lieutenant of Inishmore), and Matthew Morrison (The Light in the Piazza). Each sang songs for roles they would never be cast for.
Also in attendance were MCC artistic directors Bernard Telsey, Robert LuPone, and William Cantler with honoree Carole Shorenstein Hays. MCC Theater, now in its 20th year, is one of

Matthew Morrison

Diana DeGarmo

Michael Cerveris


Ana Gasteyer and Michael Cerveris

Ana Gasteyer "accompanies" herself on violin

Deborah Gibson

Matthew Morrison and Eden Espinosa

Matthew Morrison and Felicia P. Fields

Felicia P. Fields gets up-close and personal with Matthew Morrison

Brian D'Arcy James

Ana Gasteyer with Julian Fleischer

Eden Espinosa


Julian Fleischer

Matthew Morrison and Brian D'Arcy James parody "Brokeback Mountain"


Deborah Gibson and Eden Espinosa


Mario Cantone

"Miscast" company bow

MCC Theater artistic directors Robert LuPone, Bernard Telsey, and Will Cantler

Robert LuPone, Carole Shorenstein Hays, and Will Cantler
Videos