My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
Home For You Chat My Shows (beta) Register/Login Games Grosses

They say that falling in love is wonderful... and doesn't Broadway know it! Valentine's Day is here and love is all around us. At this most romantic time of the year, we can't help but wonder... what is the greatest Broadway love song ever? 

BroadwayWorld continues our great tradition of finding that consensus- and this year we have more answers than ever! We've gathered responses from over 1500 performers, composers, industry professionals, and entertainment personalities from all over the world.

Category:
Photo
Performer
Writer/Director: Camp | Director: 13 | Performer: Baby | Upcoming: Damn Yankees
"Make Our Garden Grow" from CANDIDE. It's not a romantic love song, it's not a starry-eyed love song. It's about the kind of love you earn. The kind you can trust. It's adult and hard-won, and yet ecstatic. With the most passionate, beautiful choral arrangement in the entire theatrical canon.
Photo
Performer
The Producers | Jekyll & Hyde
"My favorite Broadway love song is “Someone Like You” from the Broadway musical Jekyll & Hyde. I have performed the song on stage, and now in concerts around the world and it really resonates with me because it’s kind of the story of my life...the story of me and my wife, Hayley… "someone like you found someone like me."
Photo
Creative
City of Angels | The Goodbye Girl | The Woman In White | Princesses | Mulan | Hercules | Tarzan
Certainly one of the most romantic Broadways songs is "Lazy Afternoon" from THE GOLDEN APPLE. The music by Jerome Moross and the lyrics by John Latouche are so seductive. The 1975 Barbara Streisand recording is extraordinary.
Photo
Creative
The Confession of Lily Dare | The Third Story | The Tale of the Allergist's Wife | Die Mommy Die | Taboo
"Too Many Mornings" from Follies. I love the complexity of emotions in this song. Regrets for the past, present needs, fantasy for the future. And oh, that gorgeous lush melody.
Photo
Industry
Vocal Coach
In light of the fact that there is going to be a musical based on the music of John Lennon, I would have to say that my favorite love song is "Here There and Everywhere" by John Lennon and Paul McCartney. It has a vulnerability in its lyrics while at the same time, there is an extremely challenging vocal line happening. The lyric "running my hands through her hair" shows a softness of heart and intimacy that only Lennon and McCartney could expose, all the while singing a most dexterous musical passage. "But to love her is to meet her everywhere". This song inspires me to love more and more deeply each time I hear it. It also challenges me as a musician and teacher.
Photo
Industry
Theatre Writer
"People" from FUNNY GIRL, because when Barbra Streisand sang it, she was radiating love for Nicky Arnstein, humanity, musicals, and (most deservedly of all) herself!
Photo
Performer
Honeymoon in Vegas | The Producers | A View from the Bridge | 'Who's the Boss,' 'Taxi'
"I've Never Been in Love Before" from GUYS AND DOLLS
Photo
Performer
La Cage aux Folles | Moon Over Buffalo | Camelot | The Happy Time
For the most romantic Broadway song, my wife insists that I say "If Ever I Would Leave You", but if that is playing it too close to the vest, how about -- "If I Loved You" -- Both songs have great lyrics and great melodies.
Photo
Performer
State Fair | Beauty and the Beast | Starlight Express | Les Miserables | Annie
There are so many! I think that Irving Berlin's "I Got Lost In His Arms" is one of my all-time favorites.
Photo
Creative
(Composer) The Wedding Singer | The Rhythm Club | Wicked City; (Associate Conductor) Caroline | or Change | Nine | 42nd Street | Titanic | Miss Saigon | Les Miserables
"One Hand, One Heart" from WEST SIDE STORY. Everytime I hear it it gets me. The orchestration is a masterpiece. The melody is beautiful and unpredictable. Also, it was the song my parents first danced to at their wedding. So good!!!
Photo
Performer
Road to Mecca | Barnum | The Threepenny Opera | Candide | Me and My Girl | Scapino | ...Joe Egg
"If I Loved You" from CAROUSEL. It's just the best love song - I'm serious!
Photo
Performer
Colin Quinn: Long Story Short
"Maybe This Time" from Cabaret.
Photo
Creative
Composer/Lyricist - Opposite of Sex | No Way to Treat a Lady | Children's Letters to God
I'd have to say "OUR LOVE IS HERE TO STAY" is my favorite romantic song. It was Cathy and my wedding song and represents a beautiful marriage between music and lyrics. Also, knowing it was the last song George Gershwin wrote before he died gives the song an added poignancy. Ira was writing of his love for his brother and the hope that George's legacy would survive the test of time. Thanks to their brilliance, it's a timeless song.
Photo
Industry
CEO Of Blue Note Records
My songs would be "If I Loved You" from CAROUSEL and "On the Street Where You Live" from MY FAIR LADY.
Photo
Industry
The Cher Show
I think Irving Berlin's song "What'll I Do" from THE MUSIC BOX REVUE is terribly romantic and melancholy. And I love it when Bernadette (Peters) sings it!
Photo
Performer
Little Women | 3 Penny Opera | Nine | The Pirates of Penzance
I find Gershwin's music to be incredibly romantic. To me, his most passionate theater song is the 1935 PORGY AND BESS duet, "Bess, You Is My Woman Now," with lyrics by Dubose Heyward and Ira Gershwin. I have loved this score since I was a child -- it was ahead of its time in the '30s when it was written and in many ways it still is today.
Photo
Performer
The Visit | Curtains | Candide | The Full Monty
That is a tough one. There are so many. I don't know if some of these were written for Broadway but, "Always", "I'll Be Seeing You", "So In Love" etc... are on the list and I'm sure there will be many who would include the same one I would if I were to do something typical. So, I don't know that this is the most romantic song ever written... but it's a newly discovered favorite of mine. Trying to avoid self promotion but... the song "I'll Buy You A Star" from A Tree Grows In Brooklyn is quite extraordinary.
Photo
Creative
Memphis | The Toxic Avenger
George & Ira Gershwin's "Someone To Watch Over Me," especially since it's about to be sung by the sublime Kelli O'Hara in "Nice Work If You Can Get It."
Photo
Performer
Spring Awakening | The Sisters Rosensweig | I'm Not Rappaport
The most romantic song to me is "Tonight" by Stephen Sondheim and Leonard Bernstein.
Photo
Performer
Funny Girl | Pippin | Irena's Vow | Golda's Balcony | Lend Me a Tenor | Yentl | Cyrano
The most romantic Broadway love song, for me, is "I'll Be Seeing You" (Sammy Fain-Irving Kahal) from the 1938 short-lived musical RIGHT THIS WAY. Though it was written right before the war, it resonated profoundly for all the Allies during WWII as boys were sent across the Atlantic to fight for the liberation of most of Western Europe from under the yoke of Nazi Germany. Maybe I am mindful of this because we are now a country at war and families are being torn apart. Indeed, I hope I will be seeing all of our soldiers in Iraq home safe and soon. Love to you from GOLDA'S BALCONY at the Wadsworth Theatre (on the grounds of the Veteran's Administration) in Los Angeles...
Photo
Creative
Composer of Ann E. Wrecksick | BARE
Depending on how you see 'love song', I would say there is a tie: "Somewhere" from WEST SIDE STORY because the music is a blueprint of unconditional love. Almost like a map that you hear; every lyric and note lead you there. And even thought it's not Broadway (yet), "Midnight Radio" from Hedwig and the Angry Inch because nothing is more romantic than the misfits and the losers finding their other halves. And the guitar in that song always gets me in the mood...
Photo
Performer
A Touch of the Poet | The Crucible | South Pacific | The Mary Tyler Moore Show | Emmy and Academy Award Winner
"Soliloquy" from CAROUSEL. "My boy Bill..."
Photo
Performer
The Prom | Minsky's | The Drowsy Chaperone
I was thinking, wistfully, about London the other day. I don't know why, and my iPod shuffle, which is uncannily in tune with my psyche, served up the perfect compliment to my mood: Vera Lynn singing "A Nightingale Sang in Berkeley Square". The song premiered on the London stage in 1940's NEW FACES. It is an unabashedly romantic tale of two people falling in love in Mayfair. There may be more romantic songs out there, but the age of the recording, coupled with the simple imagery and the sound of Vera Lynn's pure soaring voice singing "I know 'cos I was there" - well it gets me every time.
Photo
Performer
Wicked | The Drowsy Chaperone | Once Upon a Mattress | Hello Dolly | The Prince of Central Park
I think Ravel's Bolero is very sexy music, boring, but sexy.
Photo
Industry
Former President | The League of American Theatres and Producers | Inc.
"I've Never Been In Love Before" from GUYS AND DOLLS - a big bold shouting love to the world. "What Are You Doing New Year's Eve" - The song speaks to everyone's secret fear, being alone without a loved one on New Year's Eve...
Photo
Performer
Wicked
I have to say that my choice for most romantic song comes from the musical version of Faust. The song, "Feels Like Home", was how I first told my boyfriend I loved him. This may sound really sappy and dorky, but we were on the roof of my apartment building one night, and I just started singing it to him...because I was too chicken to just outright tell him how I felt! "A window breaks down a long dark street, and a siren wails in the night. But I'm alright 'cause I have you here with me, and I can almost see through the dark, there's light. If you knew how much this moment means to me, and how long, I've waited for your touch. If you knew how happy you are making me, I never thought I'd love anyone so much."
Photo
Performer
Wicked | BARE
I feel like I have a favorite love song from every Broadway show, but if I had to pick just one, I guess it would be "Last Night of the World" from MISS SAIGON. One of my favorite memories is of my high school voice teacher playing it for me and telling me how it was the PERFECT love song. He loved it so much, he filled a cassette tape with the song recorded over and over to fill the whole tape. I remember thinking it was kinda silly at the time, but that song really is so beautiful and the saxophone solo in the middle gets me every time!
Photo
Performer
Sister Act | Dreamgirls | Tarzan | Hairspray
"I Only Have Eyes For You". One of the best songs ever!!!
Photo
Performer
Mother Play | To Kill a Mockingbird | The Cherry Orchard | The Glass Menagerie | Peter & the Starcatcher | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
The first one that comes to my mind is "Love Song" from Pippin. I don't know how it holds up these days, but when I was in high school, that was my JAM.
Photo
Performer
Superior Donuts | The Pajama Game | Hairspray | Accomplice
"If I Loved You", from CAROUSEL, is written as a duet, and the drama of these two people denying what they are feeling is what makes it a great song. As a solo number it's just the loneliest thing you can imagine, and just as great. Runners-up: "Her Face", from CARNIVAL, "Never Will I Marry", from GREENWILLOW.

Videos