11 to Midnight
Closing: May 31, 202611 to Midnight - 2026 Off-Broadway History , Info & More
Orpheum Theatre New York
126 Second Avenue New York, NY 10003
Seven friends – some old, some new, all tangled up in the messy magic of friendship – come together to toast the New Year. Whether it’s 1921 or 2025, the ritual remains the same – we make a wish, promise big, and hopefully score a midnight kiss.
With high-energy theatrical street-style dance and a genre-hopping soundtrack, 11 to Midnight lets movement do the talking – capturing those big, buzzy feelings that words just can’t touch. Joy. Nostalgia. That electric moment when the countdown begins.
Sure, it’s a party—but beneath the confetti and countdowns, it’s also a celebration of who we are, who we’re trying to be, and the beautiful chaos of figuring it all out before the clock runs out.
PREVIEW 11 to Midnight - 2026 - Off-Broadway
Photos
Videos
FEATURED REVIEWS FOR 11 to Midnight
In ’11 to Midnight,’ TikTok’s Cost n’ Mayor deliver the year’s best dance party
9 / 10
Whether Cost n’ Mayor’s social media following translates to box office success remains uncertain, but here’s what’s definitive: in a cultural moment defined by isolation, cynicism, and endless scroll, 11 to Midnight offers something genuinely subversive: communal joy.
'11 to Midnight' Off-Broadway review — TikTok dance sensations Cost n’ Mayor bring the party
5 / 10
The show has its high points. A dance number lit by phone flashlights has a uniquely 2020s feel, and the choreography tells a clear story about how our relationship to our phones can keep us from focusing on real life. However, this dance, in the show's second half, is the first time we learn that this issue is one of the couple’s marital struggles, and there’s no resolution. But for theatregoers who aren’t too pressed for story, the nonstop dancing — with a Post-it-themed climax, of course — is entertaining enough.
Category
by A.A. Cristi - May 1, 2026
Conner Leavitt, known for THE SECRET LIVES OF MORMON WIVES, will make his Off-Broadway debut in 11 TO MIDNIGHT at the Orpheum Theatre, joining a cast that includes Heather Morris and Nia Sioux.
by A.A. Cristi - April 30, 2026
JJ Niemann, who was previously set to join Cost n' Mayor's 11 to Midnight on April 30th for a strictly limited engagement, has dropped out of the production. Niemann addressed the news on his Instagram story.
by Chloe Rabinowitz - April 28, 2026
JJ Niemann, who was previously set to join Cost n' Mayor's 11 to Midnight for a strictly limited engagement, has dropped out of the production.
by Chloe Rabinowitz - April 20, 2026
Nia Sioux joins viral dance duo Cost n' Mayor in 11 To Midnight Off-Broadway for a limited 3-week run at The Orpheum Theater starting May 15th.
by Chloe Rabinowitz - March 31, 2026
Actor, dancer, and social media creator JJ Niemann will join viral dance duo Austin and Marideth Telenko (Cost n' Mayor), in the cast of 11 to Midnight on April 30th for a strictly limited engagement.
by Stephi Wild - March 23, 2026
Actress and dancer Heather Morris will join viral dance duo Austin and Marideth Telenko (Cost n' Mayor), in the cast of 11 to Midnight on Thursday, April 9th for a 5-week limited engagement.
by Stephi Wild - March 16, 2026
Social media creator Melissa Becraft is set to join the cast of Cost n' Mayor and Hideaway Circus' off-Broadway production of 11 to Midnight, for a limited engagement beginning March 26.
by Nicole Rosky - February 12, 2026
11 to Midnight, the world premiere dance story from the minds of Cost n’ Mayor (Austin & Marideth Telenko) and Hideaway Circus (Josh & Lyndsay Aviner), is officially open at the historic Orpheum Theatre in the heart of New York City’s East Village. Check out photos from inside opening night!
by A.A. Cristi - February 11, 2026
11 to Midnight, the world premiere theatrical dance experience from the minds of Cost n’ Mayor (Austin & Marideth Telenko) and Hideaway Circus (Josh & Lyndsay Aviner), is in performances now at Off-Broadway's Orpheum Theatre. Read the reviews!
by Nicole Rosky - February 5, 2026
You can now get a first look at photos of 11 to Midnight, the world premiere dance story from the minds of Cost n’ Mayor (Austin & Marideth Telenko) and Hideaway Circus (Josh & Lyndsay Aviner). Check out first photos of the cast!
by Nicole Rosky - January 15, 2026
BroadwayWorld's Richard Ridge spoke with Cost n’ Mayor (Austin & Marideth Telenko) about their world premiere dance story, 11 to Midnight, premiering at the historic Orpheum Theatre in the heart of New York City’s East Village this spring. Watch in this video!
by Jennifer Broski - January 13, 2026
You can now get a first look at photos of 11 to Midnight, the world premiere dance story from the minds of Cost n’ Mayor (Austin & Marideth Telenko) and Hideaway Circus (Josh & Lyndsay Aviner), ahead of its first performance.
by Chloe Rabinowitz - January 13, 2026
Ahead of its first performance, 11 to Midnight, the world premiere dance story from the minds of Cost n’ Mayor (Austin & Marideth Telenko) and Hideaway Circus, has revealed a seven week extension at the historic Orpheum Theatre.
by Stephi Wild - November 12, 2025
11 to Midnight, the world premiere theatrical dance experience from the minds of Cost n’ Mayor (Austin & Marideth Telenko) and Hideaway Circus (Josh & Lyndsay Aviner), will premiere at the historic Orpheum Theatre.
by Chloe Rabinowitz - September 3, 2025
Cost n’ Mayor (Austin & Marideth Telenko) and Hideaway Circus' new theatrical dance production, 11 to Midnight, will premiere in Spring 2026 off-Broadway in New York City. Learn more!
11 to Midnight History
Other Productions of 11 to Midnight
| 2026 | Off-Broadway |
Off-Broadway |
Videos
