My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA at The Gaslight Theatre

This outstanding spooky season parody is now playing!

By:
Review: THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA at The Gaslight Theatre

THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA has taken over The Gaslight Theatre! Written by Peter VanSlyke and adapted by Katherine Byrnes and Mike Yarema, this parody is perfect for spooky season. The story is timeless and familiar: the creepy Phantom haunts the opera house in Paris and wants his favorite singer Christine to rise to the top. He is determined to get her there...at all costs! With toe-tapping tunes backed by the always stellar Gaslight Band, THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA is a crowd-pleaser and a must-see as we slide into the Fall months. This is family-friendly entertainment at its finest, and we even get to see The Phantom's boat travel on the lake!

Katherine Byrnes and Mike Yarema have knocked it out of the park again with their direction. They make great use of the proscenium with their staging, and I particularly enjoyed the use of trapdoors, sliding doors, rotating backdrops, and hilarious gags. The choreography by Katherine Byrnes is really entertaining, and it kicks (pun intended) into high gear during the Olio later in the show! My wife remarked to me as we left the show that the Gaslight truly is something unique to Tucson. Melodrama and parody are not done everywhere anymore, and we are fortunate to have such a fun destination right in our backyard.

The real star of this show is the vocals. The Gaslight Theatre often features classic and modern pop and rock tunes in their programming. This time around those were still in play, but we also got to hear some real legit classical singing, especially from Charlie Hall and Heather Stricker...more on that later. Josh Lamoreaux successfully achieved a polished sound from all the singers, and I particularly enjoyed seeing him shine on the electric keyboard. The 80's synth was really fun, and I absolutely loved hearing Josh Lamoreaux sing. He has a quality voice and belts those notes sitting down!

Todd Thompson brings the house down (literally) as The Phantom. Some of his ad-libs were especially good, and had the audience belly laughing. We love how much fun the actors have during their performances, because that is what makes theatregoers want to come back again and again! Kelly Coates is a triumph as Christine. I could see her playing this role in the traditional Broadway show with the same title as this one. Mike Yarema is more comedic than romantic as Raoul, but it works. His tongue-in-cheek character and line delivery are always entertainingly spot-on.

The real surprise of this show is Charlie Hall as Sorelli. Hall carries his tenor vocalist role with the poise of someone trained in legit singing. Knowing Hall's background in blues and never having heard him sing this classical style, I was very impressed. Heather Stricker shines as Carlotta, and she is also someone I would love to see play a role in...that other Broadway musical. Many times throughout this show, especially with Hall and Stricker, I found myself wanting to see more of them in Golden Age musicals or operas, singing with the legit style. It was an utter surprise and joy to hear "Funiculì, Funiculà" by Turco sung at the Gaslight and done WELL.

One of my favorite moments in the show was Samantha Cormier's rendition of "Que Sera, Sera." Samantha Cormier is one of the funniest performers in Tucson, and she killed it as Madame Giry. Jake Chapman, Jacob Brown, and Janée Page rounded out the cast excellently in their roles. THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA is another triumph for The Gaslight Theatre. Make this show part of your spooky season checklist. You won't regret it. Tickets are available at thegaslighttheatre.com. Photo: The Gawnes



More on The Gaslight Theatre

Reader Reviews

To post a comment, you must register and login.

Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best Orchestrations - Top 3
1. Anders Eljas, Brian Usifer - Chess
22.3% of votes
2. Ethan Popp, The Rescues - The Lost Boys
20.3% of votes
3. William David Brohn - Ragtime
11.8% of votes

Need more Phoenix Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...

Local Shows
Rush in Phoenix Rush
Desert Diamond Arena (12/01-12/01)
The Little Mermaid in Phoenix The Little Mermaid
Hale Centre Theatre Arizona (7/03-8/15)
Alison Krauss and Union Station in Phoenix Alison Krauss and Union Station
Pepsi Amphitheatre at Fort Tuthill (9/28-9/28)
Figment in Phoenix Figment
John Paul Theatre (6/12-6/27) PHOTOS
Plague Play in Phoenix Plague Play
Valley Players AZ (5/29-6/06)
Marlon Wayans in Phoenix Marlon Wayans
Fox Tucson Theatre (10/10-10/10)
I Love The '80s On August 29, 2026 in Phoenix I Love The '80s On August 29, 2026
Fox Tucson Theatre (8/29-8/29)
Yacht Rock Tribute Concert in Phoenix Yacht Rock Tribute Concert
Hale Centre Theatre Arizona (5/15-5/30)
Hi-Fi Holiday Concert in Phoenix Hi-Fi Holiday Concert
Hale Centre Theatre Arizona (12/04-12/19)
TUSK: The Classic Tribute to Fleetwood Mac in Phoenix TUSK: The Classic Tribute to Fleetwood Mac
Fox Tucson Theatre (10/28-10/28)


Videos