I Think We're Lost at Theatre Exile
Dates: 4/10/2026 - 4/19/2026
📍 Theatre: Theatre Exile
Pier Players Theatre Company
Philadelphia, PA
Philadelphia, PA 19147
Tickets: $20.00 General Admission, Student and Industry discounted tickets available at the door
Pier Players Theatre Company presents the world premiere of I Think We’re Lost, a darkly comedic reimagining of Peter Pan.
It’s 2026. Wendy is gone, and Peter considers leaving Neverland. To keep her fantasy alive, a scheming Tinker Bell recruits two new arrivals from Philadelphia—a “Lost Boy” and a “Wendy 2.0.” But as the newcomers confront their existential baggage, they uncover unsettling truths buried in Neverland’s past.
I Think We’re Lost is written by Peter Fenton, directed by Madison Caudullo, and produced by Chelsea Cylinder. The world premiere production is scheduled for April 10th-19th at Theatre Exile.
I Think We're Lost at Theatre Exile Schedule
Saturday, April 11th at 8:00pm
Sunday, April 12th at 2:00pm
Thursday, April 16th at 7:30pm
Friday, April 17th at 8:00pm
Saturday, April 18th at 8:00pm
Sunday, April 19th at 2:00pm
Cast and Creative Team for I Think We're Lost at Theatre Exile
Cast
Creative Team
News About I Think We're Lost at Theatre Exile
We have no news on this show at the current time.
About the Theatre
Theatre Exile Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ
What shows are coming up next at Theatre Exile?
Where is Theatre Exile located?
What shows have played recently at Theatre Exile?
Long Live the Queen (a her-story of drag) (04/30/26-04/30/26)
Philly GRIT: Camp Cookie (03/26/26-03/26/26)
Philly GRIT: The Dangers of Tobacco (03/19/26-03/29/26)
Philly GRIT: A Vacation (03/18/26-02/28/26)
Philly GRIT (03/18/26-03/29/26)
JOB by Max Wolf Friedlich (10/30/25-11/16/25)
A Puppeteer with The Palsy Performs Scenes from Shakespeare or, the Ghost in the Machine (08/07/25-08/24/25)
Glitter in the Glass by R. Eric Thomas (05/29/25-06/15/25)
Theatre Exile presents: Camp Cookie (03/15/25-03/15/25)
|
What The Constitution Means To Me Neighborhood House (8/01-8/01) |
|
Forever Simon & Garfunkel Bristol Riverside Theatre (5/12-5/16) |
|
Romeo and Juliet Labuda Center for the Performing Arts (7/08-8/02) |
|
Mark Zacharia ♦ Mystifying Magic & Mentalism Smoke & Mirrors Theater (8/08-8/08) |
|
The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show The Dinner Detective Philadelphia (9/12-9/12) |
|
The Vampire Circus Keswick Theatre (10/10-10/10) |
|
Ghostbusters In Concert Keswick Theatre (10/19-10/19) |
|
The Moth Storyslam: Schooled Punch Line Philly (8/04-8/04) |
|
"Summer of Kaos" by Stephen Murray DCP Theatre (8/15-8/15) |
|
Joan Dukore ♦ Elegant Magic Smoke & Mirrors Theater (8/14-8/15) |