Skip to main content Skip to footer site map
Review: THE FANTASTICKS at College Of The Desert

Review: THE FANTASTICKS at College Of The Desert

Try to Remember Your First Love

Many decades ago when I was working on my theatre arts degree at Cal State Fullerton, I would drive into Los Angeles two or three times per year to see The Fantasticks, a musical with music by Harvey Schmidt and book/lyrics by Tom Jones (no, not that one). Most of us know it is the world's longest running musical, clocking some 42 years off-Broadway in New York. What you might not know is that it also had quite a long run in Los Angeles. For me, it was a very Zen moment with gentle piano and harp music, simple haunting songs, a magnificently simple script and eight characters, each of whom was enjoyable and relatable. I'm happy to report that College of the Desert's current production of The Fantasticks fully brings back that breeze of joyous nostalgia.

The story deals with two fathers (Terry Mac Lemore-Mullins and Carlos Mendoza) who live next door to each other. One has a son (Diego Jimenez), the other a daughter (Shelby Victoria). The fathers scheme that the best way to get their children interested in each other is to build a wall between the houses so the kids feel that they are defying their parents when they fall in love.

The evening is presided over by The Narrator (Cameron Merrihew), props and stage effects are handled in full view by The Mute (Yuka Nishiguchi), and the adventures introduce us to a geriatric actor, Henry (Guest Artist Michael Immel) and his colleague Mortimer (Austin T. Berry), an actor who specializes in death scenes.

The tone of the evening is set when the Narrator sings "Try to Remember." Merrihew's voice is sweet but had some soft moments on lower notes. In the course of the play he becomes El Gallo, an irresistible actor who agrees to stage an abduction of the girl and to allow the boy to win a sword battle, thereby making the boy a hero in the girl's eyes. Merrihew is in top form as he dons a black hat and swirls a cape, but his strongest moments for me were the poetic comments The Narrator uses to comment on the action. Harvey Schmidt's verse and Merrihew's delivery were a terrific combination..

The girl and boy are both delights. Victoria's voice is sweet and her presentation of songs is wonderful, though again she could have used a mic. Jimenez as The Boy has the strongest voice in the show and he uses his acting chops to bring his songs to life. Together they bring immense enjoyment as they try to express the romantic feelings they are experiencing for the first time.

The two fathers are virtually a Vaudevillian song and dance pair, and Director/Choreographer Janet Miller has staged their musical numbers down front, as if they are appearing in front of a stage curtain. Both men had strong voices, and they worked well together as they milked their laughs.

Director Miller scored a major coup when she persuaded guest artist Michael Immel to play the old actor, Henry. There are no program notes about any of the actors, but IMDB lists several films he has appeared in, and his performance as a doddering old trouper who lives in remembrances of past glories is a delight. It sets a standard for the student actors he is appearing with. As his sidekick Mortimer, Austin T. Berry brings the silly, likeable humor that he has demonstrated in previous COD productions.

Accompaniment is provided by Kurt Jordan on piano and Dr. Vanessa Fountain on harp. The original score was written for just these two instruments but since many productions can't supply the harp, I was happy when I saw it in place before the show. They are both superlative musicians and it was a joy to hear the music as it was designed to be heard.

The set is - and always has been - a simple platform in front of black curtains with a bedsheet-sized curtain hanging in front of it with the words "The Fantasticks" inked on it. Set and Lighting designer has stuck with that traditional look and it all works very well. Peter Mins designed the costumes and they are all at his normal excellence except The Boy. Every other character in the play looks like they are in costume. The Boy looks like he has just stepped out of Kohl's wearing a blue shirt, an argyle sweater, a jacket, two-toned shoes and glasses. I wish that he had matched the simplicity of The Girl's blue dress. As it was, the layers of clothing and glasses seemed to act as a shield, and the patterned sweater and shoes were at odds with the simple honesty of the two lovers. Otherwise, top marks for all costumes.

I spoke with Director/Choreographer Janet Miller after the show. She agreed that the simplicity of the show is actually its greatest difficulty - especially with today's students. Convincing young folks in 2022 that every line doesn't have a sneaky subtext was a chore. The characters have no guile - that is the charm of the show. Her efforts paid off because the production successfully carries us through a memory of a time in our lives "When dreams were kept beside our pillow." Ah, if only we could.....

The Fantasticks plays through November 20 at COD's Theatre Too. Friday and Saturday are at 7 p.m., Sunday at 3 p.m. Tickets are $15 and $20, and available at the door. I urge you to come support these young actors



BETTI & BRUCE Make Hi-Desert Debut In Joshua Tree At FURSTWURLD, February 10 Photo
On Friday, February 10th at 8PM (Doors 7PM), Musical Comedy Duo, BETTI & BRUCE, make their High Desert and Joshua Tree debut at FURSTWURLD after a year of performing for audiences across the US, UK, Ireland and Mexico.

Review: Desert Ensembles Southern California Premiere of KILL THE EDITOR is a Great Produc Photo
Desert Ensemble Theatre is presenting the Southern California premiere of Aren Haun's comedic drama, KILL THE EDITOR. As is usual with DET, the directing, performances, and technical aspects of the production are top-notch. What lowers the presentation from a 'must see' to a B or B+ is that, in my opinion, the script has some flaws.

Winners Announced For The 2022 BroadwayWorld Palm Springs Awards Photo
The winners have been announced for the 2022 BroadwayWorld Palm Springs Awards, honoring the best in regional productions, touring shows, and more which had their first performance between October 1, 2021 through September 30, 2022.

Hollywood Comes To Palm Springs For UNSUNG MIDLER Photo
Popular (and most times infamous) podcaster, journalist, on-air personality, and former Palm Springs Pride Media Grand Marshal Alexander Rodriguez returns to the stage after a five-year absence (thanks to procrastination and COVID) for an irreverent night of storytelling and song with Unsung Midler, celebrating the great, lesser-known hits of the Divine Miss M from The Rose, For the Boys, and Beaches to her numerous albums and covers.


From This Author - Stan Jenson

STAN JENSON has been acting for 58 years since his high school debut at the age of 14. In those ensuing years, he has appeared in several hundred productions across the United States and Australia ... (read more about this author)


Local Playwright Returns With Palm Springs-Based MusicalLocal Playwright Returns With Palm Springs-Based Musical
January 20, 2023

Palm Springs Getaway keeps getting better as it presents Version 2.1 Local playwright Cara Van Dijk is a busy lady. Well, make that playwright, author, journalist, publicist, producer, actress, wife and mother. Her recent musical Palm Springs Getaway is currently in its second production at Palm Canyon Theatre (PCT), the Valley's longest-operating theatre company, and even though audiences are proclaiming the show to be 'A joy' and 'a pure delight,' every time she sees a rehearsal or performance she thinks, 'Next time we'll try....' It's certainly the happy sort of show you can sit through multiple times, and I know I enjoyed seeing what was kept from last year's production and what was new.

Review: THE LINCOLN DEBATE at The BentReview: THE LINCOLN DEBATE at The Bent
January 2, 2023

The Bent Theatre is coming to Palm Springs and their preview production was a knock-out!

Review: PALM SPRINGS GETAWAY at Palm Canyon TheatreReview: PALM SPRINGS GETAWAY at Palm Canyon Theatre
December 8, 2022

What did our critic think of PALM SPRINGS GETAWAY at Palm Canyon Theatre? Palm Canyon Theatre has revived a new, streamlined version of Palm Springs Getaway, their original 'musical romp' which they premiered last season. I'll start right out by confessing that I was in the original production so I know it well, though I never actually 'saw' it. I'm delighted to report that playwright Cara Van Dijk, aided by Eric Stein-Steele and Se Layne, has kept the best of the first production and replaced a few of the previously weak moments with some very strong scenes. The result is a tuneful, educational, nostalgic and totally enjoyable couple of hours.

Review: THE FANTASTICKS at College Of The DesertReview: THE FANTASTICKS at College Of The Desert
November 16, 2022

COD's production of THE FANTASTICKS is a simple joy -- something we can all use more of!

Review: BAREFOOT IN THE PARK at Desert TheatreworksReview: BAREFOOT IN THE PARK at Desert Theatreworks
November 9, 2022

What did our critic think of BAREFOOT IN THE PARK at Desert Theatreworks?