A Case for the Existence of God at New City Players

Two fathers. One cubicle. And a loan application that becomes a lifeline.

When Ryan walks into Keith's mortgage office, they're strangers united only by desperation—one fighting to keep his foster daughter, the other scrambling to secure his baby's future. But as the housing market collapses and their personal lives unravel, these two men from opposite worlds discover something unexpected: each other.

What happens when two people decide to stop being strangers? Funny, heartbreaking, and surprisingly hopeful, the play is about what happens when masculine isolation finally cracks—and grace floods in through the break.