Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: KEY LARGO Brings Andy Garcia into the Eye of the Storm at the Geffen Playhouse

A storm is raging inside The Geffen Playhouse with the arrival of KEY LARGO, a bold reimagining of Maxwell Anderson's 1939 Broadway hit that became the iconic 1948 American noir film directed by John Huston, starring Humphrey Bogart, Edward G. Robinson, Lauren Bacall, Lionel Barrymore and Claire Trevor.

Now playing in the Gil Cates Theater through December 10, 2019, the play adapted by Jeffrey Hatcher and Andy Garcia, produced in association with Frank Mancuso and Andy Garcia, and directed by Doug Hughes, honors the original story in which disillusioned World War II veteran Frank McCloud (Danny Pino) travels to a hotel in Key Largo to pay his respects to Nora (Rose McIver), the young widow of a fallen solider, who now runs the hotel with its owner, her blind father (Tony Plana) who claims to have "seen" and heard it all during his lifetime.

What McCloud doesn't count on is being confronted Review: KEY LARGO Brings Andy Garcia into the Eye of the Storm at the Geffen Playhouse by an entirely different type of battlefield with mobsters who have overtaken the hotel, led by the ruthless Johnny Rocco (Andy Garcia, who dominates the stage channeling Al Pacino in The Godfather to the hilt), who is waiting for the culmination of a drug deal for money exchange. As a hurricane barrels toward the Keys, tempers flare and gunfire blares, forcing McCloud to face his demons in order to take down a monster.

Along the way, McCloud meets the others based at the hotel, Review: KEY LARGO Brings Andy Garcia into the Eye of the Storm at the Geffen Playhouse including Rocco's long-time but past-her-prime moll Gaye Dawn (flame-haired Joely Fisher), who prefers to remain drunk rather than face the reality of her fading glory. Fisher makes the absolute most of her talents and Gaye's desperation while positioned on the staircase above everyone, accepting Rocco's challenge to sing "that song" in order to get another drink.

Rocco's band of mobsters who suffer rather rude awakenings during the storm, include dapper Toots (Stephen Borrello), Review: KEY LARGO Brings Andy Garcia into the Eye of the Storm at the Geffen Playhouse boorish and rotund Curly (Louis Mustillo) whose soft spot for Gaye winds up being his undoing. Drug dealer Ziggy is portrayed by handsome Bradley Snedeker. Another unfortunate soul who enters the premises in search of escaped convicts only to face very real ones is Sherriff Gash (Richard Riehle) who gladly accepts cash from Rocco to look the other way when evidence of the upcoming drug deal is discovered.

Another star of KEY LARGO is the wondrous Key Largo Hotel set, designed by John Lee Beatty to fall apart appropriately as the hurricane rages outside. Review: KEY LARGO Brings Andy Garcia into the Eye of the Storm at the Geffen Playhouse Especially effective is the glass dome ceiling through which the technical crew (Peter Kaczorowski, Alex Hawthorn, Kaitlyn Pietras, and Jason H. Thompson, accompanied by Arturo Sandoval's original music) brings the reality of the storm and threat of the hotel's destruction into reality. Doors fling open, shutters fall, while thunder and lightning strike, all of which seem to freak out Rocco way more than the threat of any gun pointed at him. That is, until McCloud finds his backbone and takes charge of the chaos around him.

Review: KEY LARGO Brings Andy Garcia into the Eye of the Storm at the Geffen Playhouse Thanks to the skill of Mr. Garcia to dominate the action with his presence, eye-catching, post-World War II period-perfect costumes designed by Linda Cho which certainly add lots of flash to character portrayals, and the skill of director Doug Hughes and fight choreographer Steve Rankin, the raging intensity both outside and inside the KEY LARGO Hotel will keep audiences on the edge of their seats throughout the production, even though most probably know how the story will end, given the popularity of the 1948 film. Review: KEY LARGO Brings Andy Garcia into the Eye of the Storm at the Geffen Playhouse Performances take place in the Gil Cates Theater at The Geffen Playhouse. 10886 Le Conte Avenue, Los Angeles, CA 90024, nightly (except Mondays) with weekend matinees through December 10. Tickets are priced at $30-$155, available in person at The Geffen Playhouse box office, by phone at (310) 208-5454 or online at

Photo credit: Jeff Lorch

From This Author - Shari Barrett

Shari Barrett, a Los Angeles native, has been active in the theater world since the age of six - acting, singing, and dancing her way across the boards all over town. After teaching in secondary schools,... (read more about this author)

Interview: Getting to Know Barry Pearl on his Third Time Directing 13 THE MUSICAL
August 11, 2022

Panic! Productions, along with Born To Perform Studios and BarCinBoo Productions, Inc. have announced that Barry Pearl will once again direct their late summer teen musical 13, this time at the Simi Valley Cultural Arts Center. This will be Pearl's third time working with Panic! Productions and also his third time directing the musical on the West Coast. I decided to speak with Barry about his connection to the teen musical and what inspired him to direct it for the third time, as well as how it may differ from his previous incarnations.

Interview: Meg Lin on Developing Her Solo Show WHAT AM I, CHOP SUEY?
June 29, 2022

Prior to pursuing her childhood dream of becoming an actor, Meg Lin was a former K-12 teacher, school principal, college professor, and non-profit CEO. But along the way, she struggled finding her true identity as a Chinese American as the first in her family born in the U.S. In her original solo play What am I, Chopped Suey? Meg shares how she struggled to defy cultural norms to 'save face' while coping with challenges she went through to overcome stereotypes and redefine what it means to be Asian in America. I decided to speak with Meg about how universal her first-generation American tale will resonate with so many, as well as her plans to continue presenting it as an Encore selection from this year's Hollywood Fringe Festival.

BWW Interview: Multi-Talented Actor Ron Bottitta on his roles in WAKINGS! at the Odyssey Theatre Ensemble
April 21, 2022

The ability to totally transform yourself into the physical, emotional and intellectual persona of another person so believably that audience members will see the character and not the actor is one of the most fascinating elements of live theatre to me. This is especially true for actors I follow, seeing them in several productions and always being surprised at the new person presented in front of me, often having nothing in common with the real personality of the actor. One such actor is Ron Bottitta, an English-born actor who has called the USA his home since 1980, who I spoke with about his characters in WAKINGS! at the Odyssey Theatre,

BWW Interview: Director Elisabeth Tsubota on the World Premiere of LIVE AT THE PURPLE LOUNGE
April 20, 2022

Crimson Square Theatre Company is presenting the world premiere of Live at the Purple Lounge, a drama by five talented female playwrights featuring a cast of five women (plus a few men) involved at a stand-up comedy club. I decided to speak with playwright/director Elisabeth Tsubota about her experience working with the all-female writing team and almost exclusively female cast to bring the production to the stage.

BWW Interview: Sona Tatoyan on her Multimedia Theatrical Experience AZAD at the Pico Playhouse
April 15, 2022

During the darkest of times, surprise discoveries of childhood joy can allow the sunshine in on even the bleakest of situations. And with Ukrainian refugees in the news daily, when I heard about Sona Tatoyan's Multimedia Theatrical Experience AZAD ('free' in Armenian) which offers 'one woman's magical, multi-generational, healing journey from the Armenian Genocide to the Syrian war,' I decided to speak with her about her creative journey to, as she shares, 'find the brightest light from the deepest shadows, while living in an upside-down world.' And we can all understand living in that type of situation given the past two years. Performances April 21-22-23 at the Pico Playhouse.