My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

THE ARGYLE THEATRE

34 W Main Street
Babylon, NY 11702



Review: COMPANY at Manes Studio Theatre


by Michelle Nielsen - April 28, 2026

Stephen Sondheim’s powerful emotional musical about love, marriage, and being the last single person in a group of married friends, COMPANY, has been brought to life by director Rick Grossman at Manes Studio Theatre. First performed on Broadway in 1970, this groundbreaking show won 6 Tony awards a...

Review: THE MYSTERY OF EDWIN DROOD at Star Playhouse At Stage 74


by Michelle Nielsen - April 27, 2026

What did our critic think of THE MYSTERY OF EDWIN DROOD at Star Playhouse At Stage 74?...

Review: THE PRINCE OF EGYPT at The Argyle Theatre


by Sam Desmond - April 27, 2026

A sprawling, epic--literally biblical--story focusing on the deep-seeded bond of two brothers through the societal pressures both have to lead against each other, “The Prince of Egypt” at the Argyle Theatre in Babylon, is the musical for those who want to travel to another world but still feel t...

Review: THE 39 STEPS at Theatre Three


by Sam Desmond - April 24, 2026

Reverie Theatre Group presents ‘Edges,’ a funny, thoughtful, highly entertaining four-person song cycle, with no spoken dialogue or discernible plot, that explores the challenges of young adults, including family dynamics, career opportunities, and most significantly, the trials and tribulations...

Review: TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD at The Suffolk


by Michelle Nielsen - April 21, 2026

What did our critic think of TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD at The Suffolk?...

Review: JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR at James Street Players


by Michelle Nielsen - April 20, 2026

Powerhouse vocals, evocative choreography, and a deep emotional connection define director and choreographer Matthew I. Quinn’s vision of Andrew Lloyd Weber and Tim Rice’s timeless and timely rock opera, JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR....

Review: SCHOOL OF ROCK at Cultural Arts Playhouse-Merrick


by Sam Desmond - April 09, 2026

With a central character seemingly a charming, albeit selfish, peccadillo who goes on redemption journey to connect his passion with his dreams, “School of Rock,” brings humor, honor, and hype to the standing up for yourself no matter how “acceptable” the responsible path is presented....

Review: JAGGED LITTLE PILL: THE MUSICAL at Smithtown Performing Arts Center


by Sam Desmond - April 01, 2026

The sweeping music and frenetic choreography of a musical and the arrow-piercing drama of a straight play are rarely found together in the same production, but “Jagged Little Pill: the Musical” currently playing at the Smithtown Performing Arts Center through April 19, is a rare melding of those...

Review: THE BODYGUARD at John W. Engeman Theater


by Sam Desmond - March 29, 2026

What did our critic think of THE BODYGUARD at John W. Engeman Theater?...

Review: FIDDLER ON THE ROOF at The Lighthouse Repertory Theatre Company


by Sam Desmond - March 27, 2026

A bucolic tale of a small community—almost like the town square that Belle from Beauty and the Beast goes through—that makes a sharp turn into human rights violations, “Fiddler on the Roof” asks quite a bit from its actors to go from whimsical country life to a terrified ousted community dee...

Past Shows

A Bronx Tale
A Bronx Tale
Apr 25 – Jun 16, 2024

Based on the critically acclaimed play that inspired the now classic film, this streetwise musical will take you to the stoops of the Bronx in...

Cabaret
Cabaret
Mar 12 – Apr 19, 2020

In a Berlin nightclub, as the 1920s draw to a close, a garish Master of Ceremonies welcomes the audience and assures them they will forget...

Disney's The Little Mermaid
Disney's The Little Mermaid
Jan 16 – Feb 23, 2020

Based on one of Hans Christian Andersens most beloved stories and the classic animated film, Disneys The Little Mermaid is a hauntingly beautiful love story...

Harry Connick, Jr.'s the Happy Elf
Harry Connick, Jr.'s the Happy Elf
Nov 23 – Dec 29, 2019

The Argyle Theatre presents a holiday new-classic Children's Theatre production, Harry Connick Jr.'s The Happy Elf, Sponsored by Good Samaritan Hospital.A new musical comedy by...

Shadows of the 60's: A Holiday Tribute to Motown
Shadows of the 60's: A Holiday Tribute to Motown
Dec 23

Shadows of the 60s pays tribute to the tremendous legacy of Motowns Super Groups, in a salute to the legendary stars of Motown such as...

Miracle on 34th Street
Miracle on 34th Street
Nov 14 – Dec 12, 2019

A holiday classic from the writer of the musical theatre classic, The Music Man!, and based on the movie of the same name, Miracle on...

Long Island Comedy Showcase
Long Island Comedy Showcase
Nov 9

Long Island Comedy and The Argyle Theatre proudly present a Special Long Island Comedy SHOWCASE!Enjoy an evening of non-stop laughter and hilarious fun featuring a...

David Clark's Songs In The Attic, The Music of Billy Joel
David Clark's Songs In The Attic, The Music of Billy Joel
Nov 3

Since the release of Piano Man in 1973, Billy Joel has had 33 Top 40 hits spanning 3 decades, all written by the man himself....

Rainere Martin's: Tribute to Donna Summer ft. The Electric Co.
Rainere Martin's: Tribute to Donna Summer ft. The Electric Co.
Nov 2

Don't miss Rainere's Donna Summer Tribute's triumphant return to the Argyle after her sold out show last April. With opening tribute group The Electric Company,...

Fleetwood Macked/Refugee
Fleetwood Macked/Refugee
Nov 1

"Hailed as the most authentic Fleetwood Mac tribute band in the U.S., Fleetwood Macked brings your favorite songs like...Go Your Own Way, Dont Stop, Rhiannnon...

Playball: Batboy Returns
Playball: Batboy Returns
Oct 27

"If you loved Munson and Jackson, Murcer and Martin or want to know about George Steinbrenners big heart, then my play 'Batboy' is for you....

The Fast Lane: Tribute to The Eagles
The Fast Lane: Tribute to The Eagles
Oct 26

The Fast Lane has been heralded by the International Press Association. "If you didn't know better, you'd swear you were really at an Eagles concert!"...

Gloria's Miami Nights: The Nikki Torres Experience
Gloria's Miami Nights: The Nikki Torres Experience
Oct 25

Travelling with a 10 piece band, Nikki Torres performs the music of Gloria Estefan & Miami Sound Machine in this vibrant, explosive, exciting eruption of...

The Full Monty
The Full Monty
Sep 12 – Oct 20, 2019

Based on the cult hit film of the same name, The Full Monty, a ten-time Tony Award nominee, is filled with honest affection, engaging melodies...

The Wizard of Oz
The Wizard of Oz
Sep 21 – Oct 20, 2019

The great American classic, sponsored by Good Samaritan Hospital, is back to be brought to life once again, right here in Babylon. A true delight...

The Producers
The Producers
Mar 14 – Apr 20, 2019

When The Producers came to Broadway starring Nathan Lane and Matthew Broderick as the infamous characters Max Bialystock and Leo Bloom, it had audiences laughing...

Videos