Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Bay Street Theater

265 E. Main Street
East Islip, NY 11730

Upcoming Shows

Nancy Atlas: The Howl

Sep 19

Nancy Atlas returns to Bay Street Theater for a one-night-only concert benefiting Atlas For The Arts. The Howl brings together longtime friends and collaborators Johnny Blood, Brett King, Denny McDermott, Joe Delia and Greg McMullen, along with special musical guests including...

The Howl Concert

Sep 19

Nancy Atlas brings a one-night-only celebration of the musicians who have helped shape the sound and spirit of the East End. Created by Atlas for her nonprofit, Atlas For The Arts, the show is a freewheeling night of live music, collaboration and unexpected moments. Atlas is...

The Birdcage (Hamptons Pride Film Series 30th Anniversary Screening)

Sep 27

The Hamptons Pride Film Series returns to Bay Street with a special 30th anniversary screening of The Birdcage, starring Robin Williams and Nathan Lane. Audiences are invited to dress in their best '90s Miami-inspired style and join the community for a celebratory afternoon that...

The Chain - A Fleetwood Mac Experience

Oct 3

The Chain returns to Sag Harbor following a sold-out Bay Street performance last fall, celebrating the music of Fleetwood Mac and Stevie Nicks. The band features Bob Murray on vocals and guitars, Dennis Borro on lead vocals and bass, Damian Barker on vocals and drums, Mary...

Judy Carmichael: Swing the Night Away

Oct 10

Grammy-nominated swing-style pianist and vocalist Judy Carmichael returns to Bay Street to celebrate the joyful, swinging classics of the Great American Songbook of the 1930s and '40s. She is joined by guitarist John Merrill and Dan Block on saxophone and clarinet for an evening...

Review: BEYOND THERAPY at Modern Classics Theatre Company Of Long Island At BACCA

Review: BEYOND THERAPY at Modern Classics Theatre Company Of Long Island At BACCA

by Michelle Nielsen · July 16, 2026

As one can expect with any Christopher Durang play, you can never predict what will happen next in BEYOND THERAPY. Set in a time when therapy was becoming accepted in popular culture, the play is a statement on both the need for good therapy and the perils of bad therapy. The play follows Bruce and …

Review: HAIRSPRAY at The Noel S. Ruiz Theatre, CM Performing Arts Center

Review: HAIRSPRAY at The Noel S. Ruiz Theatre, CM Performing Arts Center

by Sam Desmond · July 15, 2026

Audiences are akin to being the “twelfth man” for theater in that their reactions can decide the level of a success for on any given night. CM Performing Arts Center’s run of “Hairspray,” this summer is a triumphant crowd pleaser, immersing you into an era of great music and great change.…

Review: BEAUTIFUL: THE CAROLE KING MUSICAL at The Argyle Theatre

Review: BEAUTIFUL: THE CAROLE KING MUSICAL at The Argyle Theatre

by Sam Desmond · July 7, 2026

A crowd favorite for its nostalgic song list from Carole King, “Beautiful” at the Argyle Theatre in Babylon has succeeded in transporting the cast, crew, and audience through the journey of chart-toppers from the 60s through the 70s.…

Review: SOUTH PACIFIC at Lighthouse Repertory Theatre Company

Review: SOUTH PACIFIC at Lighthouse Repertory Theatre Company

by Michelle Nielsen · June 10, 2026

In Lighthouse Repertory Theatre Company’s production of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s SOUTH PACIFIC, director Tony Chiofalo captured the essence of this classic show. Often perceived as problematic and racist when examined through a modern lens, the musical was actually written as a statement agains…

Review: CAMELOT at The John W. Engeman Theater

Review: CAMELOT at The John W. Engeman Theater

by Michelle Nielsen · May 21, 2026

Lerner & Loewe’s magical tale of CAMELOT has been brought to life at The John W. Engeman Theater in Northport by Director Drew Humphrey*. A rarely performed show on Long Island, this production was worth waiting for! Humphrey, a veteran director, choreographer, and performer, created a masterpiece…

Past Shows

103 total · showing 91–100

Funny Girl

Feb 16 – Mar 2, 2013

Funny Girl is the musical story of Fanny Brice, who rose from vaudeville comedienne to the Ziegfeld Follies to Hollywood stardom. Featuring hit songs like People and Don’t Rain On My Parade, Funny Girl is a wonderfully warm, life-affirming journey that you’re sure to love!

Night Watch

Jan 26 – Feb 10, 2013

Unable to sleep, Elaine Wheeler is troubled by unsettling memories and vague fears. A moment later, Elaine screams as she sees (or believes she sees) the body of a dead man in the window across the way. From this point on, the plot moves grippingly as the suspense and mystery of...

Alice In Wonderland

Jan 5 – Feb 2, 2013

Join Alice’s madcap adventures in Wonderland as she chases the White Rabbit, races the Dodo Bird, gets tied up with the Tweedles and beats the Queen of Hearts at her own game!

The Little Mermaid

Jan 21

For tickets and more information, visit the website. Performed at YouthFront Auditorium 4715 Rainbow Blvd, Shawnee Mission KS 66205.

Shirley Valentine

Jan 5 – Jan 20, 2013

For Shirley, the years have gone by too fast, and she is now mired in an “unused life.” Unhappy in her doldrums, she jumps at the chance to escape. Shirley commits subtle anarchy and has the adventure of a lifetime, but what does she do when it is time to head home? Heartwarming...

Bob's Your Elf

Dec 8 – Dec 23, 2012

An elf named Bob gets banished from the North Pole to learn a lesson about co-operation. Because of his bad attitude, Santa sends him to a small town to help out with their Christmas Pageant. Here Bob is faced with a group of bumbling actors who are doing their best to put on...

42nd Street

Nov 17 – Dec 2, 2012

Peggy Sawyer, a star-stuck chorus girl from Allenstown, gets her big break when the star of Pretty Lady breaks her ankle - sending Peggy on to become a star on 42nd Street. The musical features tons of tap dancing as well as the hit songs “We’re in the Money,” “Shuffle Off to...

Over The River and Through The Woods

Mar 17 – Apr 1, 2012

Get ready to laugh out loud as Nick, a young, single Italian-American from New Jersey announces his plan to move away to both sets of grandparents, whom he visits for dinner every Sunday. As the grandparents cook, conspire and cajole to get him to stay, Nick gets to know and...

Nine

Feb 25 – Mar 11, 2012

Nine is based on Fellini’s classic film 8 ½. This spectacular musical is the story of celebrated film director Guido Contini and his attempts to come up with a plot for his next film. He is pursued by hordes of beautiful women, all clamoring to be loved by him and him alone.

Is this your theatre? Claim it to manage listings and submit updates.

BroadwayWorld TV


Dear Evan Hansen in Long Island Dear Evan Hansen
John W. Engeman Theater at Northport (9/12-10/25)
Sesame Street Live: Elmo’s Got the Moves in Long Island Sesame Street Live: Elmo’s Got the Moves
Patchogue Theatre (10/14-10/14)
The Addams Family-A Musical Comedy in Long Island The Addams Family-A Musical Comedy
Lighthouse Rep Theatre Company (9/18-9/27)
The Who's TOMMY in Long Island The Who's TOMMY
Tilles Center for the Performing Arts Long Island University (1/06-1/06)
Jaime Lozano & Florencia Cuenca’s Broadway en Spanglish in Long Island Jaime Lozano & Florencia Cuenca’s Broadway en Spanglish
Tilles Center for the Performing Arts Long Island University (11/19-11/19)
An Evening with David Sedaris in Long Island An Evening with David Sedaris
Staller Center for the Arts (10/04-10/04)
Man of La Mancha in Long Island Man of La Mancha
The Noel S. Ruiz Theatre (3/19-3/21)
Jersey Boys  in Long Island Jersey Boys
Tilles Center for the Performing Arts Long Island University (7/06-7/06)
The Figs in Long Island The Figs
Little Theater (10/23-10/25)
Long Island Music and Entertainment Hall of Fame Music Documentary Film Festival Day 1 in Long Island Long Island Music and Entertainment Hall of Fame Music Documentary Film Festival Day 1
Long Island Music and Entertainment Hall of Fame (9/25-9/25)