Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: BUDDY: THE BUDDY HOLLY STORY at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre

Playing now through February 15!

By:
Review: BUDDY: THE BUDDY HOLLY STORY at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre

Broadway Palm's production of BUDDY: THE Buddy Holly STORY tells the story of Buddy Holly's rise to fame, through the creation of some of his biggest hits. 

Review: BUDDY: THE BUDDY HOLLY STORY at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre ImageBuddy Holly is played by Hunter Henrickson, who was excellent in this role. He embodied Buddy's personality, and had a wonderful voice as well. His performance was fabulous. Maria Elena, who becomes Buddy's wife, is played by Natalie Carrera. I really enjoyed her performance and felt her emotion through it. Other cast members include Kyle Wells Lahr as Joe B. Mauldin, Robert Brandon as Jerry Allison, Jack Supan as the Fourth Cricket, Matt Smolko as Hipockets Duncan, Mike Brennan as Norman Petty/The Big Bopper, Miranda Simonne Lipes as Vi Petty, Santos Sanchez as Ritchie Valens, and Ruthgena Faraco, Gregory Holmes, and Maya Senecharles as the Apollo Singers. Buddy's bandmates, the "Crickets" (Joe Mauldin and Jerry Allison) were great alongside him, and every cast member did a wonderful job performing all of the music - it is all performed live, which is really delightful. This was an incredibly strong cast, and they each were great in bringing this story to life.

Review: BUDDY: THE BUDDY HOLLY STORY at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre ImageIt's so much fun to hear the audience react to each popular song as it starts to play, such as "Peggy Sue," "Everyday," "That's All Right," "That'll Be The Day," and many more. With such a talented cast, this production more than did justice to all of these infamous songs. 

Directed by Matt McClure (who is also the Music Supervisor), other creative team members include Choreographer Natalie Hershman, Scenic Designer Dominic Lau, Technical Director Cody O'Dell, Technical Manager and Sound Designer Abbey Dillard, Lighting Designer Russell Thompson, Video Designer Chris McCleary, Music Director Loren Strickland, Costume Designer John P. White, Stage and Deck Manager Sean Rodrigo Royal, Props Designer Nate Rush, and Artistic Producer/Casting Brian Enzman. Each did a great job bringing this rock n' roll story to life. The technical and creative aspects were lovely and effective for the story, and the music sounded fantastic.

Review: BUDDY: THE BUDDY HOLLY STORY at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre ImageI highly recommend seeing BUDDY while it's playing at Broadway Palm. It's a fun, upbeat, music-filled show with a wonderfully talented cast. Although Buddy Holly tragically died very young, this show is a great way to recognize and honor all he contributed to the music industry at such a young age.

For more information and tickets, follow the link below. 

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre
Recent Articles
Review: THE WIZARD OF OZ at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre
Review: THE WIZARD OF OZ at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre
7/15/2026

Reader Reviews

Need more Ft. Myers/Naples Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


Guys & Dolls in Ft. Myers/Naples Guys & Dolls
Gulfshore Playhouse (3/03-4/11)
Constellations in Ft. Myers/Naples Constellations
The Naples Players (3/31-5/02)
What Springs Forth in Ft. Myers/Naples What Springs Forth
Theatre Conspiracy at Off-Broadway Palm (8/14-8/30)
Play Reading- Ladies Night by Kristyn Estes in Ft. Myers/Naples Play Reading- Ladies Night by Kristyn Estes
Arts Center Theatre (8/23-8/23)
Little Bear Ridge Road by Samuel D Hunter in Ft. Myers/Naples Little Bear Ridge Road by Samuel D Hunter
The Studio Players (3/05-3/21)
Rocket Man in Ft. Myers/Naples Rocket Man
The Naples Players (10/21-11/22)
Tom Briscoe’s “It’s Not Mansplaining, It’s Old Mansplaining” in Ft. Myers/Naples Tom Briscoe’s “It’s Not Mansplaining, It’s Old Mansplaining”
Arts Center Theatre (9/27-9/27)
Over the River & Through the Woods in Ft. Myers/Naples Over the River & Through the Woods
The Naples Players (10/07-10/25)
Doublewide, Texas in Ft. Myers/Naples Doublewide, Texas
Belle Theatre (3/19-3/27)
FLOAT by Patricia Kane in Ft. Myers/Naples FLOAT by Patricia Kane
Arts Center Theatre (12/09-12/20)