Written by William Goldman
Based on the Novel by Stephen King
Directed by Scott Westerman
Romance novelist Paul Sheldon is rescued from a car crash by his obsessed fan, Annie Wilkes, and held captive after she discovers he killed off her favorite character. Forced to rewrite his novel under her watch, Paul finds himself trapped in a nail-biting cat-and-mouse game that will have you at the edge of your seat.
September 12 - October 12, 2025
Cast and Creative Team for Misery at Citadel Theatre
Cast
Ellen Phelps
Annie Wilkes
Co-Founder, Managing Director, Director, and Actor at Citadel Theatre. Ellen is so happy to be coming back as another Annie from her last performance A Jukebox for the Algonquin. Other past productions at Citadel Theatre include The Christians, It Runs In The Family, Annie, The Roommate, Vanya Sonia Masha and Spike, Elemeno Pea, ‘Til The Fat Lady Sings, Prisoner of 2nd Avenue, Something’s Afoot, Sirens, Other Desert Cities, and A Funny Thing Happened On The Way To The Forum. Other theatre credits include Company, Rumors, The Boy Friend, and The Glass Menagerie. Ellen is thrilled to be part of this production and so happy to be on stage with her husband Scott. Citadel and our life together has been an amazing ride.
Scott Phelps
Paul Sheldon
Scott is now in his 23rd year as the Artistic Director of Citadel, the North Shore theatre he co-founded in 2002 with his friend and lifelong companion, Ellen. Over the past 2.3 decades, he has acted in and directed dozens of Citadel productions, continuing to bring his passion and vision to the stage year after year. In 2023, Scott took on the leading role of Pastor Paul in The Christians. His career has also taken him to New York City and his home state of California, where he has both acted and directed. He trained as an actor at the Pacific Conservatory of the Performing Arts in Santa Maria, CA, pursued a BFA at the University of Utah, and completed an apprenticeship with the renowned Actors Theatre of Louisville. In addition to his theatre work, Scott spent 18 years with a promotional company while raising his three daughters and son in Lake Forest. Now entering a new chapter of life, he has embraced his latest role—“Beepa” to his growing crew of grandchildren (almost seven and counting). While he’s not entirely convinced he’s old enough for the part, he’s enjoying the challenge.
Jonathan Cortez
Buster
“A shining element…” Jonathan is excited to join the stage for his first production with Citadel Theatre. Jonathan is a University of Illinois in Urbana-Champaign alumnus, who studied Vocal Performance under Jerold Siena. Alongside this show, Jonathan is currently music directing Beautiful: the Carole King Musical and Hadestown. Jonathan keeps busy with his involvement in Second City, Chicago Fringe Opera’s premiere improv group OP*ERRATIC, previewing works with South Shore Opera, and vocal directing musicals in the Chicagoland area. Other credits include Tom Collins in RENT, Curtis in Sister Act, Leporello in Mozart’s Don Giovanni, and Fasolt in Wagner’s Das Rheingold. He also sings with Consonance - Chicago Choral Artists and the Chicago Gay Men’s Chorus. @thejonathancortez
Elizabeth Bushell
Annie Wilkes Understudy
Elizabeth Bushell (Understudy for Annie Wilkes)
Elizabeth is thrilled to return to Citadel where she most recently performed as Joan in Dames at Sea, Sylvia in The Cottage and Eleanor in Eleanor’s Very Merry Christmas Wish. Elizabeth is a Lake Forest-based actor / performer / producer and independent finance & strategy consultant. Recent theatre credits include the new musical, Red and the Wolf (Songbird Theatre); Gabby / Bobbi in City of Angels (JPAC) and Beverly in The Mad Ones (Towle Theatre). Elizabeth serves as Executive Producer of The Beautiful City Project, a charitable theatre organization, with production credits including Camp Rock The Musical, We Will Rock You and Jesus Christ Superstar. So much gratitude to Ellen and Scott, this wonderful team, and her loving husband, Joe!
Jason Clark
Paul Sheldon/Buster Understudy
Jason is delighted to be working back at Citadel Theatre albeit in a different capacity. Jason worked for many productions in the position of master carpenter, now he is working as an actor. He earned a BA in Theatre from Barat College in Lake Forest with an acting and directing emphasis. He served as the artistic director of Bowen Park Theatre Company for 11 years and was a founding member of the Theatre of the Mindless, a radio show reproduction group. The most recent production Jason was involved in was PM&L’s production of the Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime where he played ED. Before that Jason played George in Of Mice and Men at Bowen Park Theatre. Jason truly hopes that you enjoy the show.
Creative Team
Scott Westerman
Director
Bobby Lee
Stage Manager
Bob Knuth
Scenic Designer
Danielle Reinhardt
Costume Designer
Jodi Williams
Lighting Designer
Peter Wahlback
Sound Designer
Patrick McGuire
Properties Designer
Mitchell Pollitt
Technical Director
David Blixt
Violence and Intimacy Director
Alex Trinh
Stage Crew
Natalie Barowsky
Stage Crew
News About Misery at Citadel Theatre
We have no news on this show at the current time.
About the Theatre
Citadel Theatre Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ
Citadel Theatre is at 300 S Waukegan Rd., Lake Forest, IL.
Admissions (2/13/26-3/15/26)
Miracle on South Division Street (11/14/25-12/14/25)
Misery (9/10/25-10/12/25)
Admissions (2/13/26-3/15/26)
More Chicago Coverage
Videos