Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: NEXT TO NORMAL at Mac-Haydn Theatre

Proof that NORMAL is Nothing More Than a Cycle on a Washing Machine

By:
Review: NEXT TO NORMAL at Mac-Haydn Theatre

Tucked away in the town of Chatham, NY, The Mac-Haydn Theatre has been producing regional productions of Broadway Musicals for over 50 years. The theatre was founded in part to preserve musical theatre as the one individually American theatre form. As musicals are my "jam", I have seen a handful of standards there over the past few years. Mac-Haydn truly is a "hidden-gem" that presents a series of 8-10 productions each summer. Strolling between the wooden buildings on the campus, I have often thought of it as a sort of hybrid that would occur if you combined summer camp with summer-stock. They do great work, and the program attracts seasoned professionals, and up-and-coming performers, along with newbies often young and from the local area. Readers may be slightly aware of one such youngster named Joe then. He is now better known as Nathan Lane.

Review: NEXT TO NORMAL at Mac-Haydn Theatre Image
Beth Kirkpatrick, Eric Van Tielen,
Amber Mawande-Spytek
Photo by Ann Kielbasa

Mac-Haydn often programs tried-and-true ever popular pieces sure to generate an audience and sell tickets. This season, Artistic Director, John Saunders, who also directs NEXT TO NORMAL, is making some bold choices. Programing Urinetown between A Chorus Line and Kiss Me Kate is not what I am referring to.

NEXT TO NORMAL played over 700 shows on Broadway, was nominated for seven tony awards, won three including Best Musical. The show was a success, but there is a good possibility that if you are not a significantly committed theatre "nerd" you've never even heard of it. Its contemporary, different. and very far from the formulaic boy meets girl stories the industry has cranked out for decades. It is considered a "rock musical" the likes of Superstar or RENT.

A typical American family to the outside world, the Goodmans secretly struggle in their suburban home as they deal with the effects of their mother's worsening mental health. As they navigate their changing world, they deal with the pressing contemporary issues of trauma, loss, mental health treatment, and what it means to be a family.

Review: NEXT TO NORMAL at Mac-Haydn Theatre Image
Beth Kirkpatrick as Diana
Photo by Ann Kielbasa

In their promotional materials for NEXT TO NORMAL, Mac-Haydn, advised it would be "unlike anything you have seen on our stage. Trust us when we tell you, this show is not to be missed." I am very happy to say they were correct. This production is phenomenal.

The cast of six includes Beth Kirkpatrick as Diana, Eric Van Tielen as Dan, Amber Mawande-Spytek as Natalie, Kylan Ross as Gabe, Andrew Burton Kelley as Henry, and Gabe Belyeu as Dr. Madden. Each is highly skilled, well cast, and deliver near flawless performances as does the orchestra, and the creative team.

Review: NEXT TO NORMAL at Mac-Haydn Theatre Image
Eric Van Tielen, Kylan Ross
Photo: Ann Kielbasa

It is clear that NEXT TO NORMAL is something of a labor of love for Saunders and everyone associated with Mac-Haydn. It also appears to be an artistic highlight of the 2022 season. Prepare yourself to be overwhelmed by the raw and exhilarating reality of what it means to care for yourself, and for one another. To those who might hesitate and think that a musical centered around mental health might be too far away from "normal", I suggest that "normal" is a setting on a clothes dryer. I respectfully add: get over it, and see this phenomenal production while you can!

Click Here to Get Tickets

Reader Reviews

Love Theater in Central New York? Join The Community!

Whether you've got past experience writing about theater or just starting, the BroadwayWorld Community offers a unique opportunity to become a champion for your local arts community, helping raise awareness of local offerings and adding another local voice to the conversation at a time arts coverage is shrinking in the press across the continent. Join us and become a pivotal part of the movement that celebrates and promotes the arts in the digital age.

Learn More
Need more Central New York Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


Così in Central New York Così
Glimmerglass Festival (7/17-8/14)
Così in Central New York Così
Glimmerglass Festival (7/17-8/14)
Fellow Travelers in Central New York Fellow Travelers
Glimmerglass Festival (7/18-8/16)
Madame Butterfly in Central New York Madame Butterfly
The Glimmerglass Festival (7/11-8/17)
Oklahoma! in Central New York Oklahoma!
The Glimmerglass Festival (7/10-8/17)
THE PROM in Central New York THE PROM
The Wood Theater (8/14-8/23)
Versa-Style Street Dance Company: “Rooted Rhythms" in Central New York Versa-Style Street Dance Company: “Rooted Rhythms"
Sloan Performing Arts Center (9/19-9/20)
Dogfight in Central New York Dogfight
Theatre444 (8/21-8/29)
Incident at Our Lady of Perpetual Help  in Central New York Incident at Our Lady of Perpetual Help
The Depot Theatre (7/23-8/09)
Doja Cat at Madison Square Garden in Central New York Doja Cat at Madison Square Garden
Madison Square Garden (12/01-12/01)