It Might as Well Be Gay is an evening of queer romance and community featuring Golden Age musical theatre classics reimagined with a gay twist. The show features singers Molly Armstrong, Sara Ross Avery, Cassidy Beleele, Jasmine Belfast, Rosalie Burke, Barry-Suzanne Collins, Taylor House, Ria Ipa, Devan Kushnir, Alyssa Marie Leo, Francesca Litterio, Paige Lord, Mandi Marko, Anne E Miele, Mia Rose, Lucy Stearns, Dennis Taylor, and Zoey Wilson. Music direction is by Tiffany Marie Wilhelm. The production is presented by FATE, a NYC-based production company centering female and nonbinary voices.
Cast and Creative Team for It Might as Well Be Gay at Caveat NYC
Cast
Alyssa Marie Leo
Ensemble
Francesca Litterio
Ensemble
Paige Lord
Ensemble
Mandi Marko
Ensemble
Anne E Miele
Ensemble
Mia Rose
Ensemble
Dennis Taylor
Ensemble
Zoey Wilson
Ensemble
Devan Kushnir
Ensemble
Ria Ipa
Ensemble
Taylor House
Ensemble
Barry-Suzanne Collins
Ensemble
Rosalie Burke
Ensemble
Jasmine Belfast
Ensemble
Cassidy Beleele
Ensemble
Sara Ross Avery
Ensemble
Molly Armstrong
Ensemble
Lucy Stearns
Ensemble
Creative Team
FATE
Production Company
Tiffany Marie Wilhelm
Musical Director
News About It Might as Well Be Gay at Caveat NYC
IT MIGHT AS WELL BE GAY to Queer the Golden Age Canon at Caveat NYC
May 26, 2026 IT MIGHT AS WELL BE GAY, a queer reimagining of Golden Age musical theater classics, is set to perform at Caveat NYC, featuring 18 singers under the music direction of Tiffany Marie Wilhelm.About the Theatre
Caveat NYC Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ
What shows are coming up next at Caveat NYC?
Millennials 'R Us: New York, NY (08/05/26-08/05/26)
What shows have played recently at Caveat NYC?
We're Still in This Together: An HSM 20th Anniversary Celebration (06/15/24-06/15/24)
|
The Jackie Mason Musical-A Comedy Actors Temple Theatre (7/25-7/26) |
|
Brent Comer 54 Below (9/26-9/26) |
|
54 Below! DEBUT! 54 Below (8/29-8/29) |
|
Brandie Inez Sutton: Miss Sutton, Live! 54 Below (10/08-10/08) |
|
Leslee Warren: Light Dark & Stormy - Lena Horne Chelsea Table + Stage (9/17-9/17) PHOTOS VIDEOS |
|
It's All A Swindle Laurie Beechman Theatre (10/08-10/08) |
|
Big Broadway Drag Brunch with Marti Cummings 54 Below (8/01-8/01) |
|
Paulo Szot 54 Below (7/27-7/27) |
|
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance 54 Below (8/21-8/21) |
|
Lindsay Mendez and Ryan Scott Oliver’s Actor Therapy 54 Below (9/09-9/09) |